News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by vorpalhex on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:12PM (#29234194)
One of the things I think about is how do you make stuff in the apocalypse?

Take soap for instance. People have made soap since the dawn of time - you just need fat and lye. But how do you actually.. do it?

For that you need instructions, which means either a library of books vulnerable to all sorts of ills, or a collection of pdfs and movies. If you go the digital route you need some kind of viewer.

Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by gregjor on Monday November 15, 2021 @10:49PM (#29236564)
Soap isn’t what I would consider a necessity. If you survive the looters taking all the soap from dark grocery stores you can probably find someone who knows how to make soap. Until then you can bathe in water, assuming you can find clean water to spare, because drinking water is more valuable than bathing water.

Pretty much everything you need to get by in the imaginary post-apocalypse world (which will be littered with consumer goods for a long time) you can find the Boy Scouts Handbook. The normal human solution to not knowing how to do or make something (historically) is to find someone who does and partner or barter with them. Trying to collect and carry around all of the world’s knowledge seems the least plausible way to go.

Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by giantg2 on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:52PM (#29234613)
If you do it a couple times the process is easy to remember. A recipe can be written down. If you remember the basics you can make up the recipe as you go and check pH with strips or the zap test (and hope you weren't too heavy on the lye!). Many other basic things are similar. After all, they were inveted/perfected with ancient tech/resources.

There are plenty of other things that would be more difficult make, source, or do. How do you preserve food to modern standards if you don't have canning lids and can't make them, refrigerators don't work (some climates might not matter as much), or a local salt/nitrites source? Fermenting is one way, but doesn't work for everything.

Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by austinjp on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:52PM (#29235144)
If you're in a situation where it's feasible to make soap, you won't need to worry about it. You'll either be in a stable community or safely isolated. In any other circumstance, soap won't be on your mind.

In a society with soap-making potential (this is a fun categorisation) you'll need materials and capability. If you're in that situation, I sincerely doubt PDFs are going to be useful unless they've already been printed and/or frequently discussed, i.e. books and stories.

Maslow's hierarchy of needs may have issues, but it's surely a useful heuristic.

Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by 7952 on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:26PM (#29234924)
To survive you probably need to be part of a larger community anyway, and someone will know how and can do it at reasonable scale. And you would need that scale to be able to get enough resources.
Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by hoseja on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @07:46AM (#29239879)
Like 95% of modern industrial processes aren't described in a reproducible manner anywhere in the open, as far as i can tell. I find that a great shame.
Re:Ask HN: What kind of electronics would you stockpile for ... by Gustomaximus on Tuesday November 16, 2021 @09:54AM (#29241186)
I wonder if Encyclopedia Britannica sets will be getting dug out if information like this is needed in a non-digital way.

They are a wealth of information and quite common through to ~20 years ago. I imagine sets of these will remain somewhat common for another 100 years in peoples garages or on display etc.