Cannot agree more. I had around 300 CR-R/DVD-R and a couple dozen of DVD-RW disks, of various brands, mostly Sony, Verbatim, or Maxwell. Although those claimed to be able to sustain 10+ years, some even claimed to endure 50+ years, quite a few started to fade in 3 to 5 years and most of them failed when I last check after around 8 years. I might be able to recover a couple of them, but I would say 95% of them were long gone before I checked. It was quite a pity that some videos I archived on those disks were permanently lost. I knew those optical drives could easily become unreadable if the surface got scratched but I did not realize it could just fade away or I could have just keep those I don't want to lose on HDDs. I did not got a chance to check my floppies as my floppy drive got busted and there was really neither much point to get a new driver nor I could easily get one. Data on my HDDs is just fine, even after almost 15 years not been powered on.

Now I'm getting curios on how long my data can retain on a SSD without powering on it...