There is one fundamental problem with using any sensors for global positioning: a stationary frame of reference is indistinguishable from the one moving with a constant speed on a straight (actually geodesic [2]) line (inertial frame of reference, general principle of relativity [1]). So accelerometers and gyros indeed can give you accurate orientation and acceleration/deceleration data, but they will inevitably accumulate uncertainty for long eventless movements, so use of GPS will be needed to occasionally calibrate the true position. The obvious options is to augment this data with readings of wheels rotational, airspeed sensors, radars, etc, then such systems may last even longer without cross-calibration with GPS.
1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_relativity
2. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geodesics_in_general_relativ...
Actually, they constantly accumulate uncertainty; no change in motion required.
These forums have an interesting kind of collective intelligence. People commenting here rarely (if ever) have full knowledge of the specifics of the particular instance of the topic at hand, but often have very deep knowledge of the associated theory.
In my experience, if you take any 10 people and form a team or company to make some product, they won't have anywhere near the breath or depth of knowledge that people here could bring to bear. What they have is time and persistence, but I guarantee you that they're "flailing about" and wasting time on many wrong or suboptimal solutions. In most cases, someone here could set them on the right track within minutes.
It's so strange to me that the Internet enables this, but we use this superpower for essentially nothing more than casual chit-chat. We show off our knowledge, where we happen to have a particularly impactful trick up our sleeve, win some meaningless points, and feel smug about ourselves for an afternoon. I do this all the time. It's fun.
But what would happen if we did this properly? Like Uber? Made it into an app where startups, research teams, and software developer houses could use the collective knowledge and advice of hundreds of thousands of people instead of just the dozens on their staff? Just click here to get expert advice on your question, $55 guaranteed price? Would you click?
Maybe it is time that we all plugged into the group consciousness and started contributing to the collective... /s
These are code words I almost never use. I'm no Gary Larson [0].
But someday scientists will discover that they were plum fools for dropping the advancing momentum in vacuum science as badly as they did when solid-state electronics needed to be quickly developed & adopted.
[0] https://i.pinimg.com/originals/98/ed/7a/98ed7ae52758dbb4a645...
https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F...
Maybe it would be needed that those (startup, research teams, software developer houses) learn before to listen to their customers/users.
Everyone of course is different and has different experiences, but in the last few years (personally) I found an increasing "detachment" between the people that write the software and their users.
Maybe it us just me, but it seems like users (even paying ones in case of commercial tools) are considered more a nuisance than a resource.
For more individualized problem solving, this just amounts to consultancies, no?
On patents...if you're in a sufficiently unexplored space, simple ideas become eminently patentable. So -- given the context -- yeah, pretty much any thought made that is aware of these systems is likely patentable.
Profitable to patent? That's a different question.
There is nothing wrong with making few conversational comments without being aware of the details in a particular paper. This is how scientists talk to each other BTW. If I was at a conference with the authors I'd say something similar to the OP above, then they'd agree or disagree.
^https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=mBN1xwcAAAAJ&hl=en
There are way too many papers to do that for every one that comes out in my field, though, so I've gotten pretty good at skimming a paper quickly and making a snap assessment. I might say I'm aware of or acquainted with said paper, but I'd never say I'd really _read_ it.
So charitably speaking, I'd interpret the top-level commenter (avsteele) as meaning that they've only skimmed the paper and these are off-the-cuff comments, rather than that they haven't looked at the paper at all.
They are going for a UHV***, probably <1e-10 mbar, but want to do it with a passive pumping design. In an ordinary chamber to get there you'd do a pump down, then bake it to remove the water. Then use an ion pump plus occasional firing of a titanium sublimation pump to remove the hydrogen that leaks in (ion pumps don't work so well for hydrogen at low pressures). They have some expensive chamber that doesn't suffer from these leaks.
Still a lot of other work to do though. I see a table full of optics to make the MOT*. Also see a pair of anti-Helmholtz coils for the magnetic field. They could maybe replace those coils (which probably drive a few amps) with permanent magnets (assuming they don't need to switch the fields on and off which I imagine they don't because it can't imagine a pulsed design that wouldn't risk missing data)
Passive getters work for a good long time with low leak rates. These you can just buy**. To be honest I'm not sure why you need such a fancy chamber. I'd guess a good NEG pump, a small chamber, and good seals would make you fine for a long time, but I'd need to do the math to be sure.
*https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magneto-optical_trap
**https://www.saesgetters.com/products-functions/products/neg-...
***https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-high_vacuum