News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by acdha on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:22PM (#29205669)
I find it useful: it tells me that the project leaders have principles and are also capable of making good technical decisions. One of the main reasons why so many blockchain integrations get significant negative pushback is that blockchains aren't effective at accomplishing the purported goals. A project which is run by the whims of VCs or the owners' conflicts of interests (e.g. Reddit's decision to boost their co-founder's other holdings) are likely to make more than one decision which is contrary to the interests of their users.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by baby on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:49PM (#29205882)
That article contains many false claims so I wouldn’t be so sure about the good technical decisions.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by acdha on Friday November 12, 2021 @06:52PM (#29205903)
If that's the case, you should have no trouble identifying at least one claim and the evidence that you believe makes it untrue.
Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimmydorry on Saturday November 13, 2021 @12:22AM (#29207627)
Not GP, but the first term you can search for in an article like these is "anonymous". If the writer claims Bitcoin allows anonymous transactions, then they have failed the first and most basic test of crypto literacy.

From the article:

>Because [BTC] transactions are anonymous and (generally) irreversible, crypto assets are also a prime target for thieves.

Unless you are talking about a privacy coin, most crypto is pseudononymous. A record of every transaction is kept in perpetuity and can later be linked to a given person by following the trail of records when someone in the chain eventually provides a service that has to implement KYC (Know Your Client) protocols (e.g. an exchange, a bank, or a typical e-commerce merchant).

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by ethanbond on Saturday November 13, 2021 @08:08AM (#29209470)
> … someone in the chain eventually provides a service that has to implement KYC (Know Your Client) protocols (e.g. an exchange, a bank, or a typical e-commerce merchant).

This doesn’t have to exist for a given transaction. This bitcoin is effectively public for the vast majority of people and it is effectively anonymous for those who are highly motivated to remain so.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by jimmydorry on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:05AM (#29217552)
The proper word is pseudonymous.

Even if the chain of transactions does not lead to a hard identity, the mere act of trading by public key is to transact pseudonymously. An anonymous transaction would have concealed senders and receivers.

So no, the two words are not interchangable.

Re:Why Zulip will not get on the blockchain bandwagon by ethanbond on Sunday November 14, 2021 @01:33PM (#29219305)
Yes, and the distinction is not meaningful to the argument being made.