From the article:
>Because [BTC] transactions are anonymous and (generally) irreversible, crypto assets are also a prime target for thieves.
Unless you are talking about a privacy coin, most crypto is pseudononymous. A record of every transaction is kept in perpetuity and can later be linked to a given person by following the trail of records when someone in the chain eventually provides a service that has to implement KYC (Know Your Client) protocols (e.g. an exchange, a bank, or a typical e-commerce merchant).
This doesn’t have to exist for a given transaction. This bitcoin is effectively public for the vast majority of people and it is effectively anonymous for those who are highly motivated to remain so.
Even if the chain of transactions does not lead to a hard identity, the mere act of trading by public key is to transact pseudonymously. An anonymous transaction would have concealed senders and receivers.
So no, the two words are not interchangable.
strange question because obviously you should not shove every technology into every project. I think a lot of projects would be actually very well served by not jumping on the ML bandwagon and throwing significant resources at problems that can often be solved in simpler ways.
And not just for technical reasons but as Zulip has decided for ethical reasons. Just like crypto's mentioned impact on climate or lack of regulation ML often has negative impact on privacy, data ownership/collection, bias and so on.
I would very much be in favour of projects more strongly considering the negative impacts a technology choice can have.
Yeah, except you are specifically calling out why their "we refuse to do crypto" post is just a virtue signal and a stupid one at that.
Think of this way: If someone made a post saying their company refuses to use ML because Facebook has unethical machine-learning algorithms, they would get laughed to another planet.
It's a straw-man opinion. It would be a far more reasonable blog post if they had said: "We don't need a blockchain or crypto tie-in because that has nothing to do with the problem we are solving nor will it solve it better".
If they wanted to, they could do crypto and completely reject the current paradigm. They could easily create their own blockchain, create their own ecosystem in the hopes of changing the industry and status quo... or they could just not do anything because they aren't interested in crypto.
Instead they made a virtue signal post to get kudos and back pats from crypto FUDs for the fact of crypto FUD-ing rather than the fact it's a reasonable and sound technical decision.
I've been in crypto since I was mining on Butterfly Labs hardware in 2013. It was a scam then and it's a scam now.
I only ever mined Alts, which from a maximalist perspective seems more like a scam. Of course, it’s just perspective. The only wrong ones are the eth maximalists. :-)
Not to mention, typically when the accusation is leveled, no attention is given to which virtues are being signaled, and why such virtues are bad.
This is a common rhetorical trick and it's frustrating how often it works - rather than arguing the specifics of a situation (which the arguer finds difficult to justify) a more general, more vague, and more obfuscated point is argued instead.
See also the OP and "betting a project against a technology", as an accusation of close-mindedness, which is amusingly vague. The blog post makes a point against a specific technology and goes to lengths to describe its reasoning, but a murkier, more abstract argument is made instead to color the company as somehow luddite-like.
Some opinions are unpopular, others are expressed to enrich the conversation rather than the speaker. Neither is virtue signaling.
I agree, and it's pretty obvious from the tone of the article that they haven't quite done their research, either.
> However, will this signal stand the test of time… my money is on, no.
This is where I disagree though. I find it wildly hard to believe that there is a future for cryptocurrency beyond it's current value. It's value right now is predicated almost entirely on hype, a resource that is quickly starting to die out now that NFTs and cryptocurrency aren't rallying half as hard as they were last year or the year before. Maybe this comment won't stand the test of time either, but it would take a hell of a revelation to push further adoption of crypto and somehow further inflate it's value.
Many world currencies are pushing 20% (reported figures, so reality is much higher).
Btw Bitcoin was invented in 2008 with the explicit purpose of being an inflation hedge, cannot be debased.
It doesn't matter if there's no more block reward because the ledger still has to be "signed", and the tx fee is what will pay for the work.
Centralized SaaS apps optimized for ads that could be shutdown, sold to languish at salesforce, or have constant spam aren’t the best we can do.
Zulip is better than discord on the above metrics, but doesn’t solve all of them. I think what urbit is doing is cool and solves more. There are other web3 experiments going on that are cool too.
However, will this signal stand the test of time… my money is on, no.