Re:Ask HN: Would you build a new search engine today?
by endisneigh on Friday November 12, 2021 @07:19PM
(#29206115)
What you're describing isn't really that simple. Let's say you only take the top 200 to 500 sites, for example.
For one, these top 200 to 500 are always changing. Suppose you keep them static. The sort of things like "spam", "fake news" and so forth are highly opinionated categories. Even if you know objectively that a site is spam, it's possible that it contains the information the user is looking for.
Ultimately it would devolve to full curation, which has been tried and doesn't really work to the extent necessary to justify its own existence.
Re:Ask HN: Would you build a new search engine today?
by 1270018080 on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:15PM
(#29203389)
There should be a browser extension that completely removes any reference to Pinterest. Like it never existed.
Re:Ask HN: Would you build a new search engine today?
by 0des on Friday November 12, 2021 @04:12PM
(#29204586)
"Unpinterested!", if you use Chrome - https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/unpinterested/gefa...
"Unpinterested!", if you use Firefox - https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/unpinterested...
A new search engine would just drop the top x sites from its index, and be aggressive with dropping sites. Blog spam? Link farm? Quora? Pinterest? Wikihow? Don't index them at all. A Shitty wordpress site that's just copying stuff verbatim from other sites? Drop them. Over engineered SEO? News sites? Fake news? Satire sites? Don't bother with them etc. (or maybe put a clear disclaimer in the case of satire sites)
Make search about what it's supposed to be, discoverability.
There are so many golden sites out there to be discovered under the absolute cruft Google and the like bury us in. And the new 'you.com' isn't any better because they're just getting their results from Bing, and they've been caught taking their results from Google!