News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by satronaut on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:33AM (#29201126)
This article is horrible. It fails to discuss the benefits of using proof of work as a consensus protocol. It uses chips, it doesn't waste chips.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by lpcvoid on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:37AM (#29201202)
There isn't a single redeeming quality about Cryptocurrency. The sooner it dies, the better. "Using" chips for useless heat generation has no benefit at all.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by capableweb on Friday November 12, 2021 @01:12PM (#29202611)
I agree that people tend to over-hype cryptocurrencies, but there are examples of good being done in the ecosystem. Pineapple Fund (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pineapple_Fund) is probably the first that come into my mind, distributing $86 million worth of bitcoins to various organizations. That would not have happened if it wasn't for cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin specifically)
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by zucker42 on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:10PM (#29203329)
Likewise Amway is a great company because its CEO sometimes donates to charity.

I mean seriously, is this a real argument. Bitcoin is good because one person who got rich from it happened to be philanthropic? Where do you think that money came from? The answer is other "investors" who were told Bitcoin would make them rich. If the best justification for Bitcoin's existence is the Pineapple fund, Bitcoin must be the stupidest charity fundraising effort of all time, which is saying something.

The intrinsic value which Bitcoin provides is that it is as a currency, i.e. a way to transfer and store value. But as the Bitcoin detractors in this thread point out, it's value in this role is far outweighed by its costs.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by capableweb on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:34PM (#29203597)
> I mean seriously, is this a real argument.

Yes, it's a real argument against "There isn't a single redeeming quality about Cryptocurrency". I agree that not everything with cryptocurrency is good. In fact, I'd argue most uses today are bad, and only a few are good.

But I haven't argued for that everything about cryptocurrencies are good.

Remember; "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by zucker42 on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:47PM (#29203740)
A rich Bitcoin owner donating money to others isn't a redeeming quality of cryptocurrency, it's a redeeming quality of a person who owns cryptocurrency. It has nothing to do with intrinsic qualities of Bitcoin, and so I don't think it redeems Bitcoin in the slightest.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by FDSGSG on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:11PM (#29201773)
Cryptocurrency makes it much easier to buy and sell drugs online, this is a huge redeeming quality. Even if we assume that we are ideologically opposed to drug trade, we'd be liars to claim that cryptocurrency is useless. It de facto isn't.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by dannyw on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:47PM (#29202294)
Also donating to WikiLeaks, snowdens...
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by artursapek on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:47AM (#29201363)
Have
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by jsutton on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:43AM (#29201294)
I guess you'd say the same thing about open source cloud computing? Crypto is an evolution of that, after all.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by lpcvoid on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:44AM (#29201330)
I seriously fail to see the relationship here. Please explain?
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by leesalminen on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:54AM (#29201506)
Using Ethereum as an example, the code is open source. The Ethereum Virtual Machine is a cloud computer. As in, when you execute code on the EVM it is executing on someone else's computer for a per-use price. Hence, "open source cloud computing".

At least that's what I think the parent is getting at. I would agree it's a bit of an obtuse analogy and doesn't necessarily apply to all of crypto as a whole.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by WalterSear on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:20PM (#29201902)
Due to the massive redundancy and waste involved, the entire EVM performs less useful computation than one of AWS's smallest EC2 instance types; less than a current Raspberry Pi attached to a 100 gig SSD.

In practical terms, the machine I'm writing this on is closer to cloud computing than the EVM is.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by leesalminen on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:27PM (#29201988)
> Due to the massive redundancy and waste involved, the entire EVM performs less useful computation than one of AWS's smallest EC2 instance types; less than a current Raspberry Pi attached to a 100 gig SSD.

Ok, yes, that's fair. That doesn't totally negate the analogy, though. It just shows that it's a potentially inferior solution.

> In practical terms, the machine I'm writing this on is closer to cloud computing than the EVM is.

I think what the parent was getting at is the whole "cloud == someone else's computer" trope. Without knowing more details about the computer you're using to post on HN it's impossible to know but I think it's pretty likely you own the computer you're currently using. You wouldn't be using your employer's computer for non-work purposes, right? ;)

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by zucker42 on Friday November 12, 2021 @02:13PM (#29203369)
It's like cloud computing if any code I wanted to run ran redundantly and simultaneously on all of AWS's computers and I had to share those computers with the rest of world in a competitive bidding process.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by __alexs on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:56AM (#29201537)
I don't think causality really works like that, even the Bible for this one right.

"The son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father, nor the father suffer for the iniquity of the son."

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by __alexs on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:43AM (#29201306)
Grinding up working RTX 3090s to use as aggregate for building roads also "uses chips" but might also be considered waste.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by capableweb on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:44AM (#29201311)
There seems to be two camps of opinions regarding cryptocurrencies.

The first one is people who don't see any value whatsoever in cryptocurrencies. They typically say PoW is "waste" because they don't see value in the output, so there is no argument against them, as everything related to cryptocurrency is waste. It's largely a waste of time talking to these people, as they have made up their mind.

The second group are people who see maybe a bit of value or more in PoW. Since there is a hypothetical value, there is no "waste" as much as "use" of doing this hashing. They see value in having a cryptocurrency network, so even if it's wasteful, the greater good is more important for them. It's largely a waste of time talking to these people, as they also have made up their mind.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by VHRanger on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:54AM (#29201503)
You could just move it to proof-of-stake.

Seriously, even if you find value in Bitcoin, proof-of-work is unsustainable.

At current rates it's burning 0.5% of world energy. If price went to $300k it would end up burning 3% of world energy.

As the article notes, this is regardless of L2 solutions - energy use is purely a matter of market price.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by TimJRobinson on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:38PM (#29202171)
It's not quite market price, it's miner rewards. As Bitcoin gives off less and less rewards (it halves the amount every 4 years), the amount of miners should go down, as it then becomes unprofitable for a lot of them.

This is actually a second problem of Bitcoin though - If in say 20 years it ends up being worth a lot, and gives very little mining revenue causing few people mine it, it becomes vulnerable to attack from nation states. Because the cost of a 51% attack is only a fraction of the possible rewards for a successful attack.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by cesarb on Friday November 12, 2021 @01:41PM (#29202962)
> As Bitcoin gives off less and less rewards (it halves the amount every 4 years), the amount of miners should go down, as it then becomes unprofitable for a lot of them.

Unfortunately, there are second order effects. The miner reward is a constant selling pressure on Bitcoin, as miners must sell some of the rewards to pay for electricity and hardware. As Bitcoin gives off less and less rewards, this selling pressure reduces, which tends to increase the Bitcoin price (less supply for the same demand).

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by limusrazor on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:37PM (#29202150)
PoS is not as decentralized as PoW. With PoW, you can literally transform energy into cash. In order to be part of a PoS network, then you need to buy the token/coin first. What if you are in a country that restricts crypto? How can you participate in the network? The whole point of using blockchain is to make something truly decentralized. If you are sacrificing decentralization, then you should ask yourself whether you are using the proper data structure for the problem that you are solving.
Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by VHRanger on Friday November 12, 2021 @11:41AM (#29201269)
It uses them because they cost money.

And securing the network costs money in a proportional amount to the market price of the coin.

The network is no more or less efficient burning through 20% of the human race's energy output as it is burning 0.2% or 0.000002%.

It produces no additional transactions, no more or fewer coins. Just more waste product.

Re:How badly is cryptocurrency worsening the chip shortage? by satronaut on Friday November 12, 2021 @12:13PM (#29201808)
it's way cheaper and more humanitarian to secure value in Bitcoin using computer chips than it is to send the US military into foreign countries to support the petro-dollar