News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by yason on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:29AM (#2919947)
The current copying paradigm is utter 70's. Here's a hint for you from the 2000's, you Microsoft or Linux or Gnome developers:

What I would like is that copies seem instant and transparent. Actually, I wouldn't like to think of copying at all. I "copy" (or merely just order) a file to (appear in) some place and it immediately becomes accessible from there. Or I decide to move it back a few seconds later and I can do that.

In reality the computer should manage the low-level copying internally and consider it more like syncing.

I shouldn't have to care about how long something takes or how the kernel will queue the actual copy operations, or whether it copies anything at all but just creates a copy-on-write mapping to the same data. I also shouldn't have to wait for copying: I should be able to just copy something and immediately turn off the computer. The operating system would continue copying the blocks, if necessary, when it's restarted later. All copy operations ought to be logically atomic as well: either a copy is immediately made or it isn't, the physical details of copying and remapping the corresponding blocks shouldn't be any of my concern.

So, an immediate, transaction-based and logically coherent file operations with automatic kernel-level delayed-I/O backend is what I would call the 2000's.

I hope that there already is at least one research O/S somewhere that would do this.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by Mavrik on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:57AM (#2920026)
So basically, you'd "copy" a file on an external harddrive, plug it out and then have a surprise when you'd notice that the file isn't actually there when you get to another computer?

Because cross-device copying is the only place where this operation is slow, with modern HDDs all other operations are instantanious for all intents and purposes.

Good idea but you really should have put more tought on it.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by thisisfmu on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:04AM (#2920045)
Why let the exception case (removing an external drive quickly) ruin the main use case?

going forward it seems reasonable to assume ubiquitous network connectivity, so you can simply treat external drives as a cache and show a non-modal alert "please reconnect for sync, expected to finish within X minutes" iff the amount of data synced is large enough to matter via a 3G connection.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by hnhg on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:25AM (#2920082)
Because it is such an important case, and it's not as exceptional as you think.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by ori_b on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @10:35AM (#2920805)
Because it's not really the exception. I rarely copy or move files except when I want to transfer them to a USB key. Otherwise,they mostly stay where I created or initially downloaded them to.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by yason on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:31AM (#2920087)
Describing an end-user experience doesn't need to account for all the details in the first sketch. But pending sync is one of the easiest ones to handle.

You obviously unmount or decouple your external drive in software first and that's a good place for the operating system to inform you that:

  Ongoing I/O for your USB mass storage device.
  Wait for completion before unplugging.
And if there are many parallel I/O streams going on and this dialog is invoked, automatically prioritize anything that's being copied to the external hard drive first so that the user can unplug it as soon as possible.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by AndrewDucker on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:38AM (#2920102)
You obviously unmount or decouple your external drive in software first

You haven't met most users, have you?

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by ams6110 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @07:47AM (#2920317)
Precisely. How many users do you know who "safely remove" thumb drives, and how many just pull them out of the USB slot?
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by encoderer on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @07:54AM (#2920328)
But there's a whole class of problems here, not just removing an external drive.

I'm at my friends house, copying files from a network share over his wifi.

I'm copying from mounted network shares at home over the internet.

I'm putting files on, or pulling them off, a USB stick.

If copy turned into the feature you described, there would have to be a 2nd "no, REALLY, copy" command. Hardly a step forward.

That being said, there's no reason it couldn't work the way you describe if the system knows it's copying to/from local physical discs.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by sid0 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:37AM (#2920100)
You obviously unmount or decouple your external drive in software first

You do? I'm often too lazy to.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by sp332 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @11:35AM (#2921091)
I used to just pull it, but a half-dozen missing and corrupted files (one of which was a final project for a class in college) trained me out of that habit.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by jmilloy on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @09:43AM (#2920627)
This sounds like a shortcut. Those exist.

Also, besides copying files to removable drives, etc, the primary reason I copy a file is because I want two separate copies. Otherwise I would move it.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by chetan51 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @04:57AM (#2920027)
Why stop there? Why not just stop worrying about files and folders, and just think about documents, pictures and videos instead? Why should I have to care about the low-level filesystem at all?

Cue iOS.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by trezor on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:43AM (#2920113)
Cue iOS.

Which was a nice experiment which proved that it didn't work. You know what you can't do on iOS which most users want to be able to do?

Yeah. Work with the same document from multiple viewpoints, or applications. You can't work with documents across applications on iOS because you supposedly don't have files.

Like I said: A nice experiment, but it proves that "no files" only works for the simplest of use-cases and limits the ability to work with data beyond the limits that people reasonably expect to find.

Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by ugh on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @06:01AM (#2920149)
Nah. iOS didn’t have the time to prove anything at all. It’s not done yet.
Re:Windows 8: Improving our file management basics: copy, mo... by sid0 on Wednesday August 24, 2011 @05:42AM (#2920110)
Because that paradigm is currently restricted to rich people in first-world countries where always-on fast internet is ubiquitous and you can sync everything to the cloud without much trouble. The rest of us will continue using not-very-high-capacity USB sticks to move photos, videos and other data around for the foreseeable future.