Facebook with creepier services and dark patterns (e.g onboarding literal children despite internal data pointing to adverse mental effects)
Google + ads that favor their own services
Everything on killedbygoogle.com
Apple's on-device file scanner
Spotify forcing auto-play on connected devices as a feature
Amazon charging $10 shipping for whole foods despite whole foods already making a healthy profit
BMW charging for apple carplay (this changed last year to Free I believe)
Mercedes and Tesla charging for vehicle DLC
everything that's ever required a library of Congress dmca exception to work around
Etc.
....it's life, unless you can seize political power and not be corrupted by the many machinations of corruption that have evolved in the US in the last few hundred years.
Some days it feels like the whole field is premised on taking advantage of people, not trying to make the world better for them. I am values-driven, so it just really hurts to see so much bad behavior in my chosen field (software). I don’t like the irrational “tech bro” hate that’s popular these days, but I’m a little more empathetic when I realize that most consumers have probably faced technology that is actively taking advantage of them. Uncool.
> Some days it feels like the whole field is premised on taking advantage of people, not trying to make the world better for them.
Yeah, despite all the initial optimism, it seems one of the main consequences of connected software was to remove the technical barriers to whole classes of unscrupulous behavior that the market incentivizes.
Drug companies can be pretty user hostile. Epipens and their price hikes comes to mind.
Good example, especially considering the law was weaponized against only a relative newcomer to that game rather than all the existing players who'd been doing it for years.
Funny how these things give in shortly after the 2y warranty ends.
Disclaimer: repeat victim of headphone breakage. Looking at you, Sennheiser.
IIRC it was some ~70€ chat headset (perhaps dumb from me to even get those). The HD599 started getting electrical problems (asymmetric hearing).
I also had a bit longer ago a Speedlink Medusa (my fault).
Now have Meze 99 Neo and gonna get a pair of DT 990 and hope for the best.
Don't push the narrative that only "evil" people can do bad things. Then, since almost no one thinks they are evil themselves, no one will believe they're doing bad things.
The ticket would certainly not be named "Ignore user's default browser choice", but only an extremely naive developer would believe this is good for their users. A developer that finds this objectionable would ask to be transferred to another team, but most won't.
I'm not saying that developers should refuse the work, just that they're not innocent about what they're doing.
If you can work for FAANG you can work somewhere else and make a comfortable living, it's not like we're talking about someone doing shady work to put food on the table. Why do we not hold people accountable?
If someone shills for big oil or the tobacco industry we have no trouble pointing out how unethical it is.
>You get in, make your coffee in a fancy Microsoft-branded cup, and then a PM gives you the “actively shit on our customers” ticket. Presumably the engineers on the windows team are either in golden handcuffs, or actually derive sadistic pleasure from making the world worse for users, and making the field of software engineering less trustworthy."
is what I was referring to.
If you work for one of these companies, there is no clever self-justification. You can either lie to yourself or own the truth. Doesn’t matter if you’re on some VR offshoot division of Facebook. You are part of all the terrible damage and death they cause.
Just last week I was reading about a court ruling proving a local bank overcharged interest on car loans, entire department knew, and they did this for years. Effectively stealing from people. The other day a retail store tried to get out of warranty obligation under the excuse that I don't have the receipt, even though I have the warranty card with serial number - a friend working in support said it was a common tactic to see if people would give up.
If you think this is an example of a morally questionable job I'd like to know what universe you live in.
I’ll also point out that in the case of the bank overcharging, it sounds like outright fraud (totally unacceptable) and the courts held them to account. It is shocking that fraud and corruption happen, but at least society seems to have a mechanism for dealing with it.
Software engineering isn’t morally questionable, if you aren’t going out of your way to make the world worse for people. There is no compelling reason to do that, so the vast majority of jobs should be perfectly reasonable. I love my job in part because I’m never asked to actively make my product worse, or work against users and customers. We’re imperfect and don’t always work as well as we could, but at least we’re working in the right direction.
All ethical upstanding folk, Monsanto, Nestle, by their standards Microsoft are saints.
> People who drive trucks.
An industry know for their honesty and reliability, no organised crime involved ever.
It's shocking to me how much people here get outraged over relatively trivial stuff.
Long term value creation is a lot harder to prove, but I still always try to push for it. But most organisations can't deal with it, their decision making mechanisms are so broken that they need someone else (arbitrary data) to do the job...
Health Insurance, look up the case of Allena Hansen. Her face was ripped off by a bear in the wilderness but somehow got herself to a fire station for an airlift. She said that dealing with Blue Cross Blue Shield afterwards was by far the worst part of the experience, because "having a face" is considered cosmetic.
I used to work for a smaller group insurer and I'll never forget how at every single all-hands meeting and innumerable company-wide emails for 5 years the CEO would dedicate 20 minutes to whining about pre-existing conditions getting deleted by Congress.
I think there is a 3rd and more likely possibility, namely, that they've either been brainwashed, or convinced themselves, that the actions they're taking are right & righteous.
They are right for their bank accounts.
They sleep on their USD $200K/year bed (if college grad). Or if experienced with 5 years of experience, then their $400K/year bed.
In some cases, you find it highly objectionable, but because large corporate entities are authoritarian in nature and you don't want to risk getting fired, you complain but ultimately get the job done anyways. You don't get over it and keep it in a long list of things you find questionable before you decide it's time to change teams or companies. The "PM" in this equation likely feels the same as you, because no single PM at a large company like this has the authority to make decisions like this nor tell their dev team what to do (it's an influence role, not an authority role - authority is for folks with bigger paychecks).
Or you get paid and know about a more complicated/nuanced take that only people on the inside know about, so you do the work and move on because you probably don't care that much.
It's very easy to just anthropomorphise everything and say "ha, that one is evil with evil intentions and sadistic joy", but it's far more likely that it either wasn't actually designed to work like that and it's simply some crappy default behaviour, or there is some marketing VP who went beyond his scope and forced an implementation detail 4 layers deep in the organisation. Then that one might be bad, (but still just incompetent - even just checking historical cases would have shown that to be a bad idea) but all engineers, all managers, all POs? Unlikely.
This was already done.
The new ticket would have said something like: "Stop users from being able to override the special links that only work in Edge. Make very sure that users have no way of working around this behavior even if they really want to."
A bit like:
- "openInBrowser(url)" (the mistake)
- "openInEdge(url)" (the malice)
- "openInDefaultBrowser(url)" (the one configured by the end-user).
I have no idea what they are doing under the hood, but I'm pretty sure some of it can be easily identified for being a mistake, malice or something else. But because I don't know, and apparently neither do most people here, speculation on the effect being the main intent or a side-effect alone is iffy at best. The functional outcome remains the same of course, and I'd rather start out with calling it a bug than anything else. If Microsoft then comes out calling it "works as intended" then yes, that's just nasty.
Just because it "looks" the same doesn't mean it is the same. There is a vague reference about a few KiB of added compiled code and the fact that it's an insider build, but other than that just an exploration of previously valid avenues that no longer apply, and the bundled outrage of assumptions based on a whole lot of nothing.
I don't know what the actual implementation is, the article on the website doesn't seem to know, and neither do you. So all we can do is speculate, and it appears some people choose unproductive outrage over technical exploration.
[1] https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-doubles-down-on-its-...
There usually isn't a "make the product worse" ticket. It's often more a matter of not having enough time to do it the interoperable way.
That's not to say "actively shit on our customers" tickets don't exist, just that it happens so often because of far less sinister, far more mundane reasons.
Every field. The seller-buyer relationship is supposed to be adversarial. This is why competition is so important, and why ignoring anticompetitive practices is so damaging: the only way to prevent companies from throwing punches your way is to be able to punch back.
I'd be interested to know if you assume the opposite, that companies in general act in the interest of their customers?
Are there other fields so thoroughly invested in making the world a worse place to be a consumer? Why is big tech so obsessed with torching their long-term reputation in exchange for a few usage share points in the short term? How do engineers sleep at night, knowing their role is to be a malignant, user-hostile, value-destroying force in the world?