News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by netcraft on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:29AM (#29175678)
the Gravitational Observatories are so impressive to me - I can remember reading about them being theoretical well before LIGO ever started construction, and the fact that theyre here and working just like we expected is so amazing. I can't wait until we have LISA in space!

But its so strange when we shut it off to do upgrades and stuff - like I totally understand why we have to do it, but its like we finally turned on a microphone and could hear things that were always happening but we could never observe before, and then we turn it off for a little while - the thought that there are events that are going on right now that we will never be able to detect because we arent listening gives me major FOMO.

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by pinko on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:45AM (#29175921)
LIGO collaboration member here: we focus on maximizing the cumulative number of detections over time, and it turns out that by turning the detector off for a year to upgrade it, we can increase the sensitivity so much that a year after that we will have more total detections than if we had left it running continuous for two years. So you also have to think about all the distant/faint signals we would never be able to detect because we kept listening at too low a sensitivity...

(We do make sure that we have a dramatically less sensitive sister detector in Germany, called GEO, listening whenever we're not so that we'll see something really close and loud, like a galactic supernova, even when LIGO is offline.)

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by wpietri on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:54AM (#29176057)
I sincerely love that your reply to FOMO was to point out how his FOMO should be even worse. This is exactly how my brain works when I'm optimizing something: I have to balance one obsession with all the other things I need to obsess about.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by ars on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:18PM (#29178189)
That makes me think of the "Wait calculation" in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interstellar_travel#Wait_calcu...
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by netcraft on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:05PM (#29177957)
Thanks for the info! I expected it was something like this, that you expect the increased sensitivity is worth it. I just wish we had more observatories running in different sensitivities - we've just got to get the cost down, thats all :)

I didn't know about GEO, thanks for that!

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by foo92691 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:04PM (#29178953)
Also the experimentalists get very antsy when they/(we) can't touch the instrument. :-)
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by omegalulw on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:17AM (#29176397)
> the thought that there are events that are going on right now that we will never be able to detect because we arent listening gives me major FOMO.

I can relate to the sentiment but keep in mind that human timescales are downright puny compared to cosmological timescales. And there's lots of stuff going on all the time (lots is an understatement) so I would say you won't lose much turning off the detector for a year.

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by netcraft on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:06PM (#29177977)
I totally understand this from a rational standpoint, but if you take that to its logical conclusion, you expect that nothing will happen in that year that is very interesting or rare, so why look at all?

Sure, our timescales are nothing, making what we have even more valuable, no? We've missed out on a whole lot of observations - we have a lot of catching up to do!

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by jaspax on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:33AM (#29175736)
Why would you have FOMO? Why is any particular gravitational wave important enough that you'd worry about missing it? I'm not trying to hassle you here, I'm genuinely perplexed by this attitude.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by wpietri on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:55AM (#29176086)
I used to work in a library and we all had a similar feeling about books. They were all valuable and to be preserved! Objectively, that's not practical. But that base irrational feeling is still useful and important.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:58AM (#29176125)
Technically we've missed at least four billion years of gravitational wave events, so a week of shutdown for an upgrade isn't going to make a huge difference to that.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by wpietri on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:34PM (#29177484)
Yes, that's where the practicality comes in. But I'm sure there are people who have FOMO over all that data collection we missed over the last 14 billion years. And that's good! Maybe somebody will come up with something clever that is better than nothing. E.g., all the CMB work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_microwave_background
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by BbzzbB on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:35AM (#29185086)
My crude searching tells me there are ~3 supernovas in our galaxy every century. Miss one now and the next might wait for the next generation of astrophysicist.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by techbio on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @11:41AM (#29176760)
I miss those days four billion years ago, before modern worries and before days.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by dylan604 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:08PM (#29179024)
only for Earthlings. I'm sure (hopefully) someone on a rock around a different star might have had those worries in their day too.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by DrBazza on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:13PM (#29177204)
Close by, interesting astronomical events are rare.

The last decent naked eye supernova was the crab nebula in 1054.

It would be a real shame to miss the next one in this galaxy.

Other "rare" (non-gravitational wave) events I can think of are: the Shoemaker Levy comet hitting Jupiter, the Carrington Event in 1859, Betelgeuse dramatically dimming (last year).

Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by t849846224 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:32PM (#29177450)
Last 'decent' naked eye supernova was surely Kepler's Supernova of 1604. And the recent fading of Betelgeuse wasn't all that unusual for a fairly typical red supergiant pulsating star.
Re:Astrophysicists unveil glut of gravitational-wave detections by netcraft on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:09PM (#29178023)
I replied to a sister comment similarly, but the one resource that we are severely limited by is time. There were events that were far more common in the early universe that we may never see now. Rare things could happen at any time.

The reality is that we can't observe 100% of the time for resource constraints and that the cost/benefit of upgrading is totally worth it in the long run - rationally speaking its the right move. I will just always wonder what we are missing out on that we might never have the opportunity to observe again - or maybe not in our lifetimes.