Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by mixmastamyk on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @06:21PM
(#29168920)
A different world.
The confusion rests on the name of the file I think. If it were named "accounts" (closer to its use) people wouldn't be too surprised it was readable. Then shadow could have been named "passwords."
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by dredmorbius on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @07:13PM
(#29169387)
I've ... had that argument, and only very barely succeeded in prevailing, within single-digit years.
With a user who's lost multiple accounts to weak passwords.
Or should I say, the same weak password. Which they still use in some contexts....
I'm of the opinion that allowing users free choice in passwords is no longer viable. At a bare minimum reuse of any known-compromised password must be rejected.
RMS famously campaigned against passwords in his early pre-GNU days at MIT (though I'd say his perspective was specific to the computing environment then; it was more of a matter of how a small group of hackers should cooperate to use an expensive machine, he wanted everyone to have access to everything).
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notyourday on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @06:12PM
(#29168854)
Eh, no, it is world readable because even though programs that manipulate/read hashes are privileged, programs that map <uid>:<gid>:<name> are not. This is still the same. If you want to be able to use "ls" as a non-privileged user and see names, you need to be able to access /etc/passwd.
So... what did I write? To quote:
"but passwd was left because a lot of platform software and scripts depended on it."
Re:The Surreal Horror of Pam
by notyourday on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:09AM
(#29173392)
because it is affecting libc and glibc, not the platform software or scripts depending on it.
There was a time when it was considered ok to have the salted and MD5-hashed password available to all users.
Then people learned to bruteforce the password and so the hash itself was moved to shadow file but passwd was left because a lot of platform software and scripts depended on it.
This may shock people nowadays but back then this was fine. I remember having to explain to the users (and sometimes loosing) the need to have a password at all.