I'm not arguing they do. But I've seen conventionally grown apples that were nearly the size of my head, and I've never seen organic produce that comes anywhere close.
Granted, that just means it would be difficult to pass off organic as conventional, while the reverse you could just pick conventional earlier, but I think arguing "organic does not look different" is asking me to disbelieve my eyes every time I go to the grocery store.
Some producers get rid of much of the fruit early in the season which results in fewer, larger apples. Organic producers could do this just as well, but generally don't.
I think a lot of times with "organic" produce, the taste improvements come from something else - typically using different, heritage varieties that were bred for flavour, rather than looking good on the shelf.
this is patently false. the easiest and most obvious case is eggs.
try it yourself. buy a dozen of the cheapest factory farm eggs you can find and a dozen of organic cage-free eggs. crack them open and look. they barely look like the same thing. factory farm eggs look pale and sickly - organic looks rich and nutritious.
of course, you could just search it:
It is essentially marketing.
It's trivial to make worse handicraft than mass produce, but handicraft makers realize that if they charge N times more they've got to add at least some value. They also focus in areas where it's possible to add value (no handicraft Android phones or Lego bricks).
So when you actually buy some handicraft item/organic food, it is usually different/better quality, not because this is inherent property of the production process, but because the price has to be justified.
People have magical thoughts about what organic does. Roundup and synthetic fertilizer do not affect flavor.