News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by ColinWright on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:22PM (#2914178)
Humor is very welcome here. But content-free humor is frowned on. If it's genuinely clever, genuinely contentful, genuinely adds to the discussion, then it's especially welcome.

But simple quips are not welcome. It's simply part of the culture, and it you try to go against it you will be downvoted.

People are desperately afraid of this community degrading into a Reddit style content-free, waspish, snarky, point-scoring back-n-forth.

Re: by bitops on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:32PM (#2914223)
Ah. I like this response the best so far. It's not reactive and I feel genuinely informed.

I certainly understand the fear of the community degrading and I wouldn't want HN to be like Reddit/Slashdot at all.

But there is an interesting unspoken undercurrent also on HN. Which is that it's the community for the sophisticated, intelligent hacker (and it certainly is that).

What remains unsaid though is that there's a certain uptightedness (sometimes) that people can't break out of. It may just come with the territory of very smart people. I tend to find HN the best community for programmers on the web. Loads of smart people on here.

But smart people have a hard time not taking themselves seriously, and when people try to point that out, I've noticed a trend where the elders put the kibosh on those individuals.

It's true that the trolls should not be fed, but many trolls are actually just pointing out what's real and getting burned for it. Like an "Emperor's New Clothes" situation.

In any case, thank you for your thoughtful reply.

Re: by mooism2 on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:54PM (#2914073)
Maybe people don't find your humour funny. Maybe people don't think your humorous comment adds anything to the discussion. Maybe people don't want HN to turn into Slashdot.
Re: by bitops on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:12PM (#2914143)
See, this where I think you can have humor without it going down the Slashdot rabbit hole. Also, humor is subjective and what some people find funny, others won't.

It seems to me that slapping down certain types of humor is encouraging another kind of uptight groupthink where we're always serious all the time.

Because we are sophisticated hackers who are oh-so-sincere about everything.

Gotta get a little rambunctious now and again, don't you think? To me the old spirit of programming has a good amount of humor in it.

Re: by sidcool on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:02PM (#2914103)
This isn't Reddit. You would be enshrined there. This is Hacker news and jokes are not welcome. We talk in language of Math and hrefs.
Re: by RobertHubert on Monday August 22, 2011 @04:17PM (#2913936)
Humor will not be tolerated.

End of line...

Re: by sidcool on Monday August 22, 2011 @05:02PM (#2914104)
</html>