It’s a lazy language so estimating real world performance is hard. It has a slow compiler and a very shallow pool of talents. You don’t really need to be a complainer to think that removing it from your organisation code base is a step in the right direction if you are not an Haskell shop. I would do the same with Ocaml despite liking Ocaml.
Ah yes, the language that's so famously bad at performance that its only noteworthy usage in industry is... a trading firm that needs to be able to handle data in microseconds to make money. If only they had chosen better.
* The full compiles can be slow, but incremental compilation with ghci and cabal is never so awful in practice. And I've worked on some big projects.
* I don't think the talent pool is especially shallow. I've never had trouble hiring Haskellers or finding a job as a Haskeller. If you broaden your scope to the Haskell-interested (and have teaching and learning core to your culture), it's even easier. I built some projects entirely with teams of new Haskellers. Went great.
So, first you have to hire quite senior Haskell engineers, and then at one point switch them to tracking Haskell to new hires.
There aren't many companies who are willing to do that, and for a good reason.
Only prerequisite is a good attitude. If you start bean counting, you've already lost. If you think this level of software engineering cost optimization is necessary, you're just making your workplace worse.
If those interns and juniors came to you knot knowing Haskell, then this is a very bad way of teaching people. You end up with bad, non-idiomatic code, poorly understood concepts etc.
> If you start bean counting
It's not bean counting.
Turns out you can learn the ropes & values in a couple months tops. Then you can learn with anyone and grow together.
All the things you fear are barely consequential in practice in Haskell. All those things - who cares? What's the worst that can happen? The language puts such a high floor on the code it's okay. The main mistakes these newbies can make are stuff about database & distributed system design - orthogonal to Haskell and something they should be mentored on anyways.
However, a large engineer org that brings in senior non-Haskeller engineers/managers/leadership is bound to run into political troubles imo. Those types tend to blame Haskell and use it as an excuse for rewriting and re-orging - hence giving them newfound power. This isn't FUD or a strawman. This is observed behavior of many "respected" "old heads" I've had to work with/for.
That's just my experience from 3 different companies lol :) You can build software at any scale with Haskell - you just have to actually like and want to use Haskell for its cultural and technical benefits. Sadly, a complainer at the top of the org chart who can't even read Haskell code can easily come in and force Haskell out. That's just facts.