News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by drclau on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:59AM (#29121121)
I have this idea that maybe ads should be entirely disallowed from everywhere, except for catalogues, printed and online. Crazy, right?

It would work like this: you feel like spending money or you want to buy a specific type of product? You pick-up/load the catalogue and browse until you can't take it anymore, or at least until you find something. And then follow a link to the seller's website, or get the address of the local store. No more ads everywhere, not in the physical world and neither in the online world.

Admittedly, I have not spent much time thinking about it and the possible side effects.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by bostik on Friday November 05, 2021 @04:07PM (#29124158)
> ads should be entirely disallowed from everywhere, except for catalogues, printed and online.

I've been saying this for a few years now, but that's only part of a Terminal Solution[tm].

I wouldn't disallow online ads, because done sensibly (https://bostik.iki.fi/aivoituksia/random/no-stalking.html) they could happily coexist with everything else. Here's the more heretic take: make the core EU take the universal one - any and all data on an individual is ALWAYS the property of the person in question. No exceptions. Any third part storing a copy of it is merely a guardian of the data, not its owner. Then require for every single use of that data to compensate the individual.[ß] That flips the incentives, because all of a sudden every data processing round costs you real money that you have to pay out. Not in amortised compute costs, but in actual payouts.

In a strange twist, the sums themselves don't need to be particularly large. The sheer overhead of requiring accurate accounting, auditable records, and all the extra back-office operations to make it possible to repay people at a global scale is expensive enough to transform the practice of hoarding personal information from an asset into a liability with capital L.

In other words: if you want to advertise to me, you need to pay me for the privilege of wasting my time, my bandwidth, my electricity and my screen real estate. Through the nose, if needed.

ß: I'm willing to make an exception to legal hard requirements. But unless you're a government conducting their necessary activities, you pay.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by igorkraw on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:09PM (#29121259)
I've been thinking about this for a year and haven't found any downsides
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by kelseyfrog on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:29PM (#29121526)
São Paulo's been living it for 14 years. I'd love to hear from residents how they feel about it too.
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by asxd on Friday November 05, 2021 @01:05PM (#29122011)
That's fascinating. Looks like this is due to the clean city law put in place in 2006 that removed upwards of 15000 billboards and other outdoor ads.

The wikipedia entry [1] contains an account from a local reporter there. Here's the first bit:

> São Paulo is a very vertical city. That makes it very frenetic. You could not even realize the architecture of the old buildings, because all the buildings, all the houses were just covered with billboards and logos and propaganda. And there was no criteria. And now it is amazing. They uncovered a lot of problems the city had that we never realized.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cidade_Limpa

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by ATsch on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:19PM (#29121389)
Capitalism is a system where, so it is claimed, atomized individuals pursuing their "rational self-interest" produce an inherent moral and societal good. This is to be aided by a lack of regulation and interference by non-market forces. The freer the markets the freer the people.

This case is a pretty clear example of how this is not in fact the case. By the metrics of a captialist system this should be a huge success. You have investment, voluntary contracts, free markets and fierce competition that results in huge amounts of innovation. Yet the result is horribly useless waste that hurts society. I think it's pretty fair to call it out.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by ATsch on Friday November 05, 2021 @01:01PM (#29121963)
I can't personally speak to the effectiveness of all of the systems humans have lived under or seriously proposed, but I'm fairly certain that among them capitalism is pretty unique in being a system where a paperclip maximizer can be considered a good product. (incidentally also fairly unique in being the only system so far under which hunans have created a global extinction level event)
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by robocat on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:00PM (#29122667)
That sounds like a straw man argument to me. I think capitalism is amoral.

Regulations are added to restrict some of the harmful effects of uncontrolled greed.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by cbsmith on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:59PM (#29121945)
It's not blaming capitalism. It's blaming purism.

X at "its purest" is pretty awful, for all values of X.

Shocking news flash: pretty much any system has unintended consequences, distortions, etc. You invariably need checks and balances (which rob it of its "purity") in place to mitigate. When you get into the extra-legal space, where those checks and balances are most mitigated, you see some pretty terrible stuff.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by throw10920 on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:15PM (#29122866)
> It's not blaming capitalism. It's blaming purism.

I've never seen an article that blames "purist capitalism" on HN (maybe two that reference "lassie-faire capitalism"), and dozens that just blame "capitalism", no further elaboration given. The most straightforward explanation is that capitalism itself is being blamed, and I think that this explanation is supported by the recent (past 20 years?) increase in support for socialism/communism (both in the US and globally).

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by cbsmith on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:24PM (#29124887)
I guess it depends on how you read it. This article is pretty clearly critical of "capitalism in its purist form", and [checks notes] it was posted on HN.

So your perception may be more of projection of your own POV than that of others.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by ClumsyPilot on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:45PM (#29121740)
"they never address what solution they want. Communism?"

As much as I enjoy hackernews, is it economically illiterate. There are 50 different economic schools of thought, and 'Capitalism/Communism' are not among them, they are vulgarities.

'Capitalism' of 1800 was mercantelism - it was protectionist, featured slave trade, etc.

'Capitalism' of 1980's was Keynesianism, when income tax was 70% in the top bracket, high inflation, cheap housing, we could build infrastruture effectively, etc.

'Capitalism' of today is 'Neoliberalism', and it's the pinnacle of laissez-faire approach to economy.

There is also Shumpeterianism which proritises technological development, Austrian school, and countless others

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schools_of_economic_thought

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by mikestew on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:46AM (#29120940)
I highly recommend staying away from hemlock tea, despite the fact that I am unable to provide you with an antidote.

Just because a solution isn't provided does not necessarily invalidate one's criticism. And China as your poster child for communism? Man, I don't want to get all "no true Scotsman" on you, but...

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by cheese_van on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:21PM (#29124862)
Perhaps but if you assume a spherical true Scotsman...
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by elefanten on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:55AM (#29121063)
Your analogy perfectly defeats your point.

The alternative to drinking hemlock tea is not drinking hemlock tea.

You can't not pick an economic system of organization. Even if you don't pick one, you will have one. So the question becomes "what's the best choice available?"

To choose "not capitalism" is still choosing something -- something which may work much worse.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by InitialLastName on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:19PM (#29121388)
Your assumption that selection of a system is binary, as in you either have an absolute unrestricted free market or you have uncompromising centralized state control of the entire economy is missing the question.

We don't have either of those things now (neither does China). Control of the economy exists on a multidimensional spectrum, of which there are many possible options; blaming "capitalism" for a problem is shorthand for noting that, in some situation, the unrestricted free market is leading to negative externalities or a poor use of the commons.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by mikestew on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:14PM (#29121311)
Thanks, Neil Peart?[0] I'm not saying "don't choose", or "choose differently". I'm saying one doesn't need to offer alternatives in order to state that $THING might have downsides. Just because I have a lot of money tied up in the U. S. stock market doesn't mean that it's hypocritical to point out the jackassery that can come with capitalism...like ad tech.

[0] https://www.rush.com/songs/freewill

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by kelseyfrog on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:37PM (#29121631)
In agreement. Far too many "debaters" do not acknowledge this truth. Identifying a problem and proposing a solution are two different things. I get that actionable statements are appreciated, but they aren't a requirement. Conflating the two rhetorically sophomoric.

Another way of putting this is the burden of proof to also provide on a solution is not on the problem identifier. Asking as much is implicitly making the argument that the problem doesn't exist because the solution doesn't yet exist. We can all agree how absurd that is.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by throw10920 on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:21PM (#29122932)
> I'm saying one doesn't need to offer alternatives in order to state that $THING might have downsides

Which is a completely reasonable and true point! And it's a rhetorical pattern that, if we could assume noble intent more often, would be way more popular.

However, unfortunately, when people act in bad faith, the reasonable expression "x has problems" can have the subtext "we should use [popular alternative y] instead". This is the case with supporters of socialism and communism - "capitalism is bad" is not used in order to try to improve the regulatory mechanisms around capitalism (which, as other people have pointed out, are absolutely necessary), but in order to try to drum up support for their favored economic system instead.

The pattern that consistently appears is that people who are trying to improve or draw attention to the regulatory landscape around capitalism consistently talk about regulations (e.g. focusing on the FAA's lack of oversight over Boeing, or old environmental regulations that were revoked under a recent administration), and the people who are trying to advance another agenda instead throw out lines to the effect of "capitalism bad" or "this is the result of capitalism".

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by gjsman-1000 on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:49AM (#29120972)
I understand - I'm not saying it's not capitalism, but that I don't see from this article why using a different system would prevent this from happening. It's just something to blame.
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by xmodem on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:29PM (#29121530)
Here's an idea: like, capitalism, but with some restraints on it to protect the world. You know, like how we have regulators that (nominally) ensure food safety and clean air and whatnot.
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by blacksmith_tb on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:15PM (#29121334)
Hmm, I don't read it that way. It's just as easy to interpret that subhead as "the dose makes the poison" in which case the author isn't arguing for Communism as the solution but less-pure Capitalism (i.e., not the Wild West). The advertising industry does strike me as a particularly unpleasant outgrowth of Capitalism, and I liked the characterization of it as buying and selling of things without value, not in the trivial sense of monetary value - it has that, clearly - but social value.
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by circlefavshape on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:53AM (#29121043)
When someone blames "capitalism" for something, what they usually mean is that they'd like if this thing didn't happen, but don't have any concrete proposal for preventing it. It's equivalent to blaming "society"
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by ClumsyPilot on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:50PM (#29121799)
If we followed this logic, we'd still have slavery because "you can't blame capitalism" and the famous poster at protests "race mixing is communism"
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by ryandrake on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:06PM (#29121214)
You could also substitute "unregulated capitalism" for "capitalism". Often when someone criticizes capitalism for allowing some social ill, the underlying message is: This wouldn't happen if there were some regulatory guard rails and a legal system that punished this particular ill.
Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by kelseyfrog on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:57PM (#29121899)
A lot of us actually mean capitalism because we believe that the incentives it creates are inherently baked into its structure. For example, the construction of capital markets inevitably lead to labor exploitation through a natural series of actions and reactions. That's anti-capitalism 101.

Anyone who has worked at a heavily funded startup knows this. They may not have the words for it, or they may even like it, but they cannot deny that the situation creates the incentives.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by bravura on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:01PM (#29122679)
"the construction of capital markets inevitably lead to labor exploitation through a natural series of actions and reactions"

Can you explain what this means, with some key examples?

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by kelseyfrog on Friday November 05, 2021 @02:26PM (#29123007)
I really wish I could, but this is essentially asking for a distillation of Capital Vol 1 in a Hacker News comment. If this is something you're interested in, I encourage you to read it from the source. It spells out exactly this.

If that doesn't quite suit you, feel free to reach out (email in profile) and I'm sure we could find a way to convey this conversationally.

Re:An inside look into the illicit ad industry by betenoire on Friday November 05, 2021 @11:46AM (#29120947)
That paragraph stuck out to me too.. it makes no sense. They say it is refined capitalism but also nothing of value is being traded. Isn't capital supposed to have value? That's refined snake oil.