If you need it spelt out for you, it’s very simple: Israel is a settler-colonial project in a world where settler-colonialism is seen as immoral and illegal. You’re not supposed to subjugate and dispossess other peoples, even if you bring them the benefits of an advanced civilization.
I don't think i have ever heard of an armed international conflict where one side was like "so the other side is super chill, too bad we are at war with them".
At this point in history, it seems likely every human being is descendant of people who at some time conquered other people.
Most of us live on graves and ruins of other civilizations or at least tribes. Much of that displacement was coerced or outright violent. Ironically, if the previous entity was obliterated completely (e.g. Carthage), there is no one left to nurture resentment.
The 'colonial' argument rings hollow.
Attempts at ethnic revanchism based on where humans once lived thousands of years ago is weird, creepy shit. It’s creepy when Hitler did it, and it’s creepy when you do it.
That led to a war, in which the arabs lost. They went all in and lost. One can only imagine what would have happened to the jews in Israel if they would have won.
Of course in the end that plan didn't happen, but i'm not sure i see why either side really had the superior claim to the land.
The territory was under the British control and before that was under Ottoman rule for several hundreds of years.
Turkey was conquered by the Turks, from Greeks, Armenians, and various smaller groups. Big parts of it not that long ago (~1 century). Somalia was conquered from Ethiopia. Pakistan from India. Bangladesh from Pakistan. Hell, Northern Iraq was conquered from the Kurds ... by Arab Nazi's. Seriously. History can be funny at times.
Most of these conquests are younger than Israel is. Why don't we see people follow Indian demands for re-annexation (and religious suppression) of Pakistan? Pakistan demands the same of Bangladesh (and yes religious suppression. "There are no sects in Islam" is part of Islamic doctrine. There are no splits in Sunni Islam, but somehow Pakistan and Bangladesh don't belong to the same Sunni Islam ... and are hundreds of millions of believers each).
Ethiopia wants to re-annex Somalia (and restore religions to where they were 100 years ago), and so on. Hell, there exist Indian extremists that would like to see Indonesia annexed too. Oh, and unlike the Israel-Palestine conflict, India and Pakistan are threatening to nuke each other. And China is now threatening them too, also with nukes, so there's plenty of new trouble brewing in that neighbourhood. And we haven't even mentioned China ...
Is anyone seriously suggesting undoing the conquests? For one thing that would be extremely impractical and a massive operation, even if they would cooperate (and I guarantee there'll be war in every case).
Why is this conflict so important? Compared to the India-Pakistan issue, it doesn't affect very many people (Israel and Palestine, even together, are at best the population of a medium US city, India-Pakistan-Bangladesh is 4-5 times the size of the entire US)
But I think I do see some factors. Israel-Palestine is so very, very small that it is actually conceivable that the west actually does something about it. India-Pakistan? We have zero chance to play a meaningful role there. Also the Israeli consider themselves part of the West, so they actually want the approval of the rest of the West.
But the second paragraph juxtaposing the Israelis is more interesting still in its tending toward Godwin's Law.
I've never before now heard of the whole Zionist movement cast in terms of colonialism.
I am grateful for the insight, as that will require some pondering.
The US, Canada, Australia, NZ can be considered settler's colonies much more than Israel since the europeans who settled there had anything whatsover with those places.
I would suspect most of the Israelites that moved there are actually western/european descent, whereas I would not be surprised if a lot of the Arabs there had actual ancient Jewish genes.
All that aside, are we really discussing who can claim ownership to a land based on ancient history, rather than human impact of change of ownership?
Ethnically there is no real difference, to the point that a disguised Jew or Muslim, provided they know the other language well, can blend in without any problem, even for longer periods. Which is a big problem for catching terrorists.
And it's even the case that when it comes to habits, even religious habits, there's a lot shared between Jews and Muslims that does not actually date back to ancient Judaism or come from Islam, but are for example not-that-old Iraki or Yemeni customs.
The region was named after the tribe, not the other way around
It is also true that Xinjiang was once peopled by the Han thousands of years ago, before the Uighers arrived, but that does not at all affect my understanding of the relationship between the Han and Uighers today. Why should it? It doesn’t change the fact that one side is extending its dominance over the other.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/98/Israel_a...
You propose that a country as small as Israel is colonizing the middle east. I am against the illegal settlements, but the compassion to colonies just doesn't fit at all.
Israel would find it much harder to keep control of Palestinian territory if their opponents quit the idea of violent jihad and turned to non-violence. Unlike China, Israel is a democratic and fairly small country, and obvious oppression of non-violent opponents would not fly there. Both the internal and the international pressures against the hawks would have become unbearable.
I know a fair share of Israelis. They aren't bloodthirsty conquerors and slavers. They are mostly afraid of pizzerias, schools and buses being bombed again, and it is not an irrational fear.
However, most of the criticism, at least the one that isn't "kill the Jews" type, comes from Israel's occupation of the West Bank and the apartheid-like conditions that are there. There you can't talk about Hamas and the rockets killing children because there are none as Israel is in full control of the area.
Which other ethno-nationalist states do you laud this way?
It is unrealistic and unacceptable to expect the State of Israel to voluntarily subvert its own sovereign existence and nationalist identity and become a vulnerable minority within what was once its own territory. - https://web.archive.org/web/20210519103412/https://www.adl.o...
Eritrean migrants resettled from Israel to Sweden [..] The resettlement - which Israeli NGOs said included 54 Eritrean women – was part of the “ongoing process of willful deportation to Sweden,” - https://www.jpost.com/National-News/Eritrean-migrants-resett...
Denmark and Australia?
Denmark is sending Syrian and Afghan migrants to Rwanda in Africa.
Australia is sending their South Asian and Middle Eastern migrants to remote pacific islands.
Your article about theEritreans moving to Sweden states "the Israeli government was not part of the initiative".
Israel is literally occupied Palestine.
In case people don't notice, that's extreme sarcasm.
Every nation on Earth has taken over others, just look at the native peoples of every country in North and South America, of Nordic Countries, Australia.
Look at how Europe's borders were re-written 1000 times. Africa. The Middle East.
If the beef is (and it seems to be for some) that they "took land", get over it. Because where you live "took land" too.
A more interesting discussion, I think, is why does Hamas consistently reject the Israeli peace offering and two state solution?
This is simply not correct. Israel's borders have continued to expand in the 21st century.
Humans genocided other people for tens thousands of years. That's not a good reason to morally justify genocide today.
The Jewish people are a convenient folk devil and frankly have been for a millennia. Historically they have always been a small relatively closed population with influences that tended to exceed their population size. That makes a good target to deflect hate to when folk in power need to distract their populace away from themselves.
Personally I think Israel’s restraint is remarkable.
I know you didn't know that, but with that in mind, I do not think the wikipedia article will change my mind much.
Its known as the covert way to discriminate against arabs..
Edit: for precision they said it was like that for many small business who look for seasonal guys like waiters ..
What is interesting is that the tide is turning and your view is becoming less common, especially among the youth in developed nations, particularly Ireland. This is good news, for the well-being of Israelis and Palestinians alike.
Perhaps, as a start, let's find some common ground: I firmly believe that both Israelis and Palestinians deserve peace, prosperity, and full rights.
Ask the travelers. Ask those on Direct Provision. Ask the people who got dumped in Ballymun with promises of parks and shops, only to be abandoned for decades.
FWIW, it seem clear to me that the Palestinians have got the nasty end of the stick and deserve better, as much as you or I do. If the only answer you have is one that means that all the Jews in Israel die (ala BSM though they don't yet have the guts to say so) then the Jews of Israel aren't gonna help you.
If they don't fight, what outcome do you see?
This kind of thing comes up every few weeks, at least it does if you read the IT who's editorial policies have a pretty clear slant on this - as is completely their right - even if I don't much like it.
This week the attention was on the Minister of Foreign Affairs and his dislike of Israel's recent classification of several NGOs as terrorist organizations.
Sorry to be pedantic, but this was not Sally Rooney's decision. As part of the BDS movement, she did not want to patronize an Israeli company that would be handling the translation. Rooney has stated that she has no objection to the novel being translated into Hebrew.
Regarding Finkelstein (who has been endorsed by David Duke and others): Bronzik, Benz, Seligmann and many more have shown many flaws in his book.
It's easy to throw some articles around and put appeals to authority ("Finkelstein is also a solid introduction") in a comment. No conflict it as clear as people on any side make it sound.
If you're going to argue from authority, then you have to be prepared to have the authority questioned. This isn't the USSR. We're allowed to say that your holy texts are nonsense.
I‘m sorry to question your deities. You brought them to the table.
mysecretaccount, this is my only account. Also, it‘s midday in Europe.
What would you do if you were Israel?
Israel doesn’t care about civilian deaths. They care about optics.
That hamas is worse isn’t really relevant for the Palestinian civilians.
Do you know how many Palestinians were killed and how many others become refugees until this day (since 1948) living in refugee camps in the West bank, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria?
Rockets? Do you know that the Palestinians have been fighting since 1948 and for decades their only weapon was rocks? yes rocks.
Did you ask yourself, why are the Palestinians fighting in the first place? have you ever visited the west bank?
Palestinians are not all Hamas, and even Hamas have a just cause.
Human rights? have you ever seen how Israel treat Palestinian human rights?
*Update*: oh wait, you're being sarcastic right? because that's the only way your comment will make sense
Israel drops leaflets before bombing so civilians can clear out.
When Hamas stores weapons in schools and Hospitals, Israel exercises extreme caution to minimize casualties.
Israel is the only country in the world with the self restraint to not destroy a neighbor that constantly fires rockets at them.
Next time you criticize Israel, think about how it would feel to have rockets raining down on your children, your loved ones, co workers, friends for no reason other than the fact that you exist.