More precisely, they say 118M extra people in 2020 which is 12M less than projected, but that's small comfort to the hundred-million people who can't get enough to eat.
https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/agriculture/brief/food-se...
> Hunger was trending upward even before the COVID-19 pandemic, which exacerbated existing effects from extreme climate events, conflict, and other shocks to economic opportunities.
Only a tiny fraction of that 118M is needed to make COVID look like nothing in comparison.
Nobody would say that chronic hunger isn't horrible - it is - but it is highly disingenuous to compare it directly with deaths. Chronic hunger is a systemic issue.
There are simply too many confounding factors to arbitrarily place the blame for a given % of hunger increase on COVID mitigation measures. We know it had some significant effect, but can't say much beyond that, and certainly can't draw any conclusions about whether the measures were appropriate or optimal based on that. To do so would be lying with numbers to advance an agenda.
Furthermore, letting the virus run wild and kill millions more could have resulted in tremendous increase in hunger itself - economies and supply chains don't handle mass death well, ever. Now you might say that is speculation, but it's no moreso than the % of 118M argument that you forwarded.
It's far to early to be Monday morning quarterbacking the pandemic - we are still very much in all dimensions of it.
Gross underestimate, india itself has an excess mortality of 5M or more.
An average person in the US spends $2,641 per year on food. If you're a dev making 100k per year, that's less than 3% of your income. Increase that by 25% to $3,301 and it's still just a little over 3%.
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/12/this-map-shows-how-mu...
Some countries spend as much as 50% of their income on food. A 25% increase bumps that up to almost 63% of their income.
Would you consider yourself in trouble if you were spending 60-65K per year on food?
That's still not equivalent because your excess of 30-35K is still enough to buy lots of nice things. If you're making 5K per year, that leaves just 1-2K for everything else you need. Remember, consumer goods aren't really cheaper in these countries.
$2,641 per year is just over 7 bucks a day. If a $100k salaried dev is able to pull that off, it’s only because they are milking the free office food.
Eggs are $0.75/dozen here right now. Tuna is $0.79/can. Legumes round to free. Meals aren’t free but they aren’t expensive. You can live damn well on $7/day if you are remotely competent and have even basic cooking skills available to everyone.
Food in the US is very inexpensive.
As an example, red curry doesn't cost a lot per person. The most expensive part is the chicken and there isn't that much considering the rice, the sauce, and the vegetables. Curry dishes are a stable in fast food because they are easy to prepare, cheap and quite tasty.
The bigger question is if a $100k salaried dev is willing to spend time cooking. Personally I practice the once-a-week cooking model where I buy in bulk and focusing my cooking on a single day in order to make finished portions that I freeze. This saves both time and money. The more expensive aspect here is actually breakfast, which is hard to make cheap since bread, butter and cheese are all things that is hard to save money on by buying in bulk.
Lockdowns impact the entire system, and proclaiming some jobs as "essential" and other as "non-essential" is the highest form of arrogance as all employment is essential to the business that employs the person or they would not have the employee.
Supply Chain's are very fragile, as the world has come to see, you toss a monkey wrench in the center of that by have governments attempt a top down mandated lock down where they deiced by fiat who should work, who should not, well you are going to have a bad time.
As history has shown now.
Central Planning never works, never has worked, and never will work. People need to stop trying it
Yes, that's obviously what I believe. Thanks for the condescension, I see we're off to a great start.
> Lockdowns impact the entire system, and proclaiming some jobs as "essential" and other as "non-essential" is the highest form of arrogance as all employment is essential to the business that employs the person or they would not have the employee.
Okay, but presumably a smart government would decide that all jobs involved in the production and transportation of foodstuffs are essential. I know my country's government did.
> Supply Chain's are very fragile, as the world has come to see, you toss a monkey wrench in the center of that by have governments attempt a top down mandated lock down where they deiced by fiat who should work, who should not, well you are going to have a bad time.
And how do you distinguish the monkey wrench of "government fiat" from the monkey wrench of "lots of people who work in the supply chain getting sick"?
https://interactive.aljazeera.com/aje/2020/covid-19-in-us-po...
> Central Planning never works, never has worked, and never will work. People need to stop trying it
I haven't seen any evidence that anyone tried to implement Central Planning, but I'm happy to read any you might have.
That is the folly of this way of thinking, all jobs are interlinked, you can not just extract jobs from the market and not have an impact.
The person that cooks breakfast for the truck driver that picks up the food from the warehouse that stored the food that came from the factory that made the food from ingredients from a farm field is just as "essential" as ever other person in the chain.
As is the IT worker that works on a helpdesk for the credit card processor that service the restaurant that truck driver above stops at every morning
As the manufacture of the monitor stand that the IT worker uses to hold up their monitor to enable them to service the Restaurant of the truck driver...
and on and on we go down the chain.. Look up I, Pencil[1] for a better understanding of this
Government just pulling out people they claim are "not essential" to food production or other essential things is foolish because all jobs are essential. Period. non-essential jobs do not exist, and any government claiming there is, and claiming they are smart enough to make that determination should never be trusted with anything.
>I haven't seen any evidence that anyone tried to implement Central Planning
The very nature of choosing who can work, who cant, what is jobs are essential, what jobs are not is Central planning
...the truck driver can make breakfast at home.
> As is the IT worker that works on a helpdesk for the credit card processor that service the restaurant that truck driver above stops at every morning
The truck driver probably shouldn't during a pandemic.
> Government just pulling out people they claim are "not essential"
Again, if you have actual evidence of this, I'll read it man, but otherwise I've got no time for your anarchocapitalist rants.
Should he cook his own lunch too? Maybe he can wake up at 3:30AM for that.
What about his dinner? Maybe he can wake up at 3AM.
Can he read his kids bedtime stories? Maybe he can wake up at 2:30AM so that he has time at the end of the day. After all, he has been deemed essential.
So, what time of day was he previously stopping at a diner for breakfast? And how long did that catered breakfast take? Longer than a bowl of cereal and two bits of toast?
> Should he cook his own lunch too?
Who the hell cooks lunch? And if it takes you 30 minutes to make sandwiches and grab a piece of fruit, I feel for you.
Kudos though, that was an amazing linked list of reductio ad absurdum fallacies. Have you considered going into media relations for a political party?
Your suggestion of price controls is like a certain French queen telling her starving population to just eat cake.
It's easy to dismiss what these people are going through because it's far away and out of sight. I don't want to be that person.
https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/agriculture/brief/food-se...
https://www.un.org/en/food-systems-summit/news/2021-going-be...
It's not far away and out of sight, I come from a third world country myself. If it weren't for these laws 99% of the food would be exported and people would starve.
It's definitely an issue for regions that cannot grow their own food, yes. There are not enough of those for 130 million people to starve. And while yes, there are multiple ongoing famines, none of them are caused by lockdowns. Instead, their root cause is either drought, crop failure or predominantly war. It's important we find the right causes.
Food growth has not slowed. The growth in food growth has slowed. Food production is still increasing every year.
I don't mean to say that hunger is not an issue. It is. It's just that lockdowns have not been a significant issue in this respect. In the places where hunger is a deadly issue, international food prices simply do not matter.
Most of countries in South America pay an average of $1-3 per hour. Bangladesh pay as little as $0.09 per hour and Sudan pays a mere $0.04 per hour. Dozens of poor, African and Asian countries pay less than $0.30 per hour.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_minimum_w...
When international food prices go up, the "poor" in the US become inconvenienced. Elsewhere across the world, hundreds of millions starve.