The test was perfectly fair because they used the CPU as delivered, as the average user would use it.
Nobody is buying these CPUs to overclock them to a specific power usage. They're either running them stock or running them at whatever comfortable overclock they can get away with.
Test stock versus stock and overclocked versus overclocked. Trying to normalize to specific power consumption doesn't make sense for enthusiast builds.
You surely mean "for low end" builds? Because for enthusiast builds it makes a lot of sense.
Why would you set up "enthusiast" level cooling that can handle 200W and higher, and then keep your CPU set to the default 135W?
At that point one should be buying prebuilt and hope the manufacturer properly sets up the system, because one clearly can't.
I am my friends are these 'nobody', we cant be arsed to overclock but want them to use all power avaliable
It's still overclocking.
PBO will drive a 5950X to something like 310W in some applications.
If you just change PBO limits, it never goes beyond what AMD knows their silicon can handle, and what is sold to the customer. Individual cores might already be boosting to those clock speeds over short intervals. You're just allowing more cores to do that and longer, within your configured power limits. The expectation here is thermal throttling, not an unstable system.
No one pretends PBO is not overclocking. Not even AMD:
> Precision Boost 2 is a performance-maximizing technology available in all AMD Ryzen™ and Ryzen™ Threadripper™ 2000 Series processors (or newer). This technology can improve your PC’s performance by raising clockspeeds
-
And PBO still voids your warranty and does not magically respect some limit: https://community.amd.com/t5/gaming/understanding-precision-...
> Because Precision Boost Overdrive enables operation of the processor outside of specifications and in excess of factory settings, use of the feature invalidates the AMD product warranty and may also void warranties offered by the system manufacturer or retailer.
-
Reply because I'm getting rate limited, probably over that one time I wasn't nice to dang
> Changing these values will not make your CPU reach voltages it wouldn't otherwise have reached, nor will it make your CPU reach clock speeds it wouldn't otherwise hit.
This is patently false! I don't know where you got this idea when I literally just quoted AMD saying it raises clocks past factory specifications!
Also sure where you think the additional power draw comes from...
AMD literally uses the tagline: "Precision Boost Overdrive: A Smarter Way to Overclock" -
I see no point in continuing a conversation with someone who doesn't understand the basic tenets of the technology they're trying to split hairs over.
PBO is overclocking. Simple as that.
Are you calling this explanation completely wrong?: https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3491-explaining-precision... This is someone who should really know what they're talking about.
> What is important to note is that PBO only affects these three power limits. The effect on CPU clock speed is indirect, and PBO will never boost the CPU past the advertised clocks.
I think it's fair to say adjusting power limits falls under a deliberately broad "overclocking" umbrella, but it's not really overclocking, and doesn't require you to do the effort part of real overclocking.
> This is patently false! I don't know where you got this idea when I literally just quoted AMD saying it raises clocks past factory specifications!
The part you quoted doesn't have the word 'clocks'.
If you don't know clocks is slang for clockspeed, you're out of your depth. So just stop talking.
> This technology can improve your PC’s performance by raising clockspeeds
And you're saying that technical documents from AMD don't know what they're talking about (it's a technical document. It's a technical article.)
But GN, the kings of stating guesses confidently with the worst understanding of statistics I've ever seen to an uninformed crowd do?
Please. I don't even care how you cope with PBO being an overclock anymore, call it a "raising clock speeds over stock" if it helps you sleep.
I phrased that badly. I was talking about the second quote there.
It's a little bit subtle.
The first quote says it will raise clock speeds.
The second quote says it will operate outside of specifications.
But nowhere does it say the clock speeds will be outside the specification.
It's raising the power limits outside the specification so that it can raise clock speeds inside the specification.
> And you're saying that technical documents from AMD don't know what they're talking about (it's a technical document. It's a technical article.)
If you can quote me something from AMD that specifically says PBO (not AutoOC) raises the maximum clock speed above the number you can boost to within spec, I will admit I was wrong and apologize. But the page you linked doesn't say that.
Allowing here means that in the typical motherboard you'll have to change PBO from the default "Auto" to "Manual" to see these settings.
Where do terms like "undervolting", "overvolting", "setting TDP" even fit in your vocabulary if you insist everything is to be called "overclocking"? These terms should be literally self-explanatory.
[1] But only technically, because for some reason the AutoOC feature is found in the PBO menu on motherboards, even though AutoOC is not part of PBO. They are however typically marketed together.
Because if you up the Power/Current limits on a Ryzen, they will run faster - especially in tests like Cinebench. You won't even have to 'overclock' them. Simply allow them to draw more power if your cooling, motherboard, and PSU can handle it.
To make that a fair test the tester would have had to crank those settings up as far as they go, or until they match the Intel processor. If the Intel processor is allowed to draw 250W, the Ryzen should get the same treatment.
For example a Ryzen 5900X at ~135W (CPU Package) should score around 8200 in Cinebench r20, and at ~200W it should score around 8900.
Since in the test those 200W are apparently for the whole system, it's pretty obvious the tester left those at the stock values.