News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by missedthecue on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:22PM (#29112695)
Hmm. Covid lockdowns last year decreased global carbon emissions by only 6.9%, but reduced GDP by about 3.5%, according to a quick Google.

Given this, it seems that reducing carbon emissions by 100% would cost a lot more than 2% of global GDP, making us better off just living with global warming.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by kadoban on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:11PM (#29113567)
You're assuming that the method of reducing carbon emissions would be lockdowns?

What a broken premise, you must realize that makes no sense?

Same logic: Burning down my kitchen eliminated 1/8 of the ants in my house, therefore the cost of exterminating all the ants would be burning down the whole house.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by missedthecue on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:13PM (#29114014)
No.

I'm saying that lower economic activity and lower ghg emissions are correlated; they move in the same direction.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by kadoban on Thursday November 04, 2021 @09:09PM (#29114367)
They're conditionally correlated. Some ways you touch one touches the other. Same as the ants and the house.
Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by missedthecue on Thursday November 04, 2021 @09:47PM (#29114581)
Yes, you're correct that it's possible to trade some more highly emissive things for less emissive things, such as an ICE car with an electric car, and that won't necessarily lower GDP. But that's not what I'm talking about. Trying to prevent climate change is mostly a massive waste of time, effort, and money if you're only going to knock out a quartile or half of emissions. Even if we get to the point that the world emits 18 billion tons of CO2 per year instead of the 36 billion we do at present, the climate will continue to warm, and so you'll have spent all this time, money, and effort and still be where we are today anyway.

So when we're talking about stopping all greenhouse gases and preventing further warming of the planet, you're going to necessarily cripple economic output, and as far as I can detect, it's going to be by a lot more than 2% of GDP.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by kadoban on Friday November 05, 2021 @12:21AM (#29115410)
> But that's not what I'm talking about.

Okay, but is there a reason you're not talking about that, other than that it is bad for your argument?

> Even if we get to the point that the world emits 18 billion tons of CO2 per year instead of the 36 billion we do at present, the climate will continue to warm, and so you'll have spent all this time, money, and effort and still be where we are today anyway.

Warming isn't binary. Dumping twice as much CO2 into the atmosphere isn't the same thing as half.

> So when we're talking about stopping all greenhouse gases and preventing further warming of the planet, you're going to necessarily cripple economic output

Is this just a feeling? Seems unmotivated by the rest.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by pharmakom on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:00PM (#29113020)
Not quite. COVID shut down sectors by infection risk not by carbon intensiveness.
Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by qeternity on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:58PM (#29112999)
You have the causality reversed.

In covid, the emissions dropped because economic activity slowed (to the tune of 3.4% gdp). The economy didn’t slow because we reduced emissions.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by missedthecue on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:51PM (#29113428)
The causality actually doesn't matter to much for my argument.

Less travel, manufacturing, and general production in 2020 was what caused both gdp and ghg emissions to drop. They are correlated. They both move in the same direction.

Re:The costs of global warming: 2% of global GDP by pharmakom on Friday November 05, 2021 @08:19AM (#29118155)
They don’t necessarily move in the same direction since climate change has a significant cost to GDP.