This doesn't mean it's not under control of someone or a group of people. Claiming it's not under control just means you're hiding the true controller, which might be an embargoed entity like Iran.
If you have to submit a 1,000 long list of people each of whom has a fragment of control, so be it. Or spend a few dollars getting a Delaware corp.
This strikes me like Indiana legislating the value of pi. There exists a natural world out there, beyond human influence, and certain computer programs (particularly ones on Ethereum, where they run on all computers, not one computer) effectively become part of the natural world. The law is set up on the assumption that all actions are ultimately caused by a human or organization, but this may not be a valid assumption anymore.
If I may translate this in to politician speak, you're saying that the Iranian government and other OFAC-sanctioned entities can create autonomous fiscal cyberweapons which cannot be turned off?
(Requires a bit of imagination to do this without oracles, which are obviously a weak spot, but you could imagine having an autonomous bug bounty program that can automatically validate and pay out certain kinds of exploits. Self-funding ransomware?)
If there can be autonomous organizations, there can be autonomous crimes, and that is not a stable situation.
"few dollars"? More like a couple of hundred, some of that on-going and yes, it costs money to shut it down.
And, if you live in CA, you also get to pay $500/year for the privilege of operating a "not CA" corporation in CA, not to mention some other reporting.
You could probably suceed in arguing that mining was creating the asset.
> literally impossible to comply right?
This has sadly not always been a defense, like jailing women for miscarriage.
> but it's valueless until transacted
That's up for debate, and most people would disagree. Mining/staking revenue is taxed as income when received, not when you sell.
It is impossible to report "who" you received an asset from if you received it from a smart contract that is not under the control of any one business or individual. In the cases of most defi contracts, the assets involved are pooled from many thousands of individuals and act as a sort of autonomous market maker.
Cases where criminals obfuscate simple transfers are already prosecuted under money laundering laws, and they are very easy to prosecute because blockchains are a completely open record for anyone to data-mine.
If research into and use of financial smart contracts should be shut down immediately in the US, let them debate and make a law about that. Don't sneak it into a monster bill and pretend that it's about something entirely different.