News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by danny_codes on Thursday November 04, 2021 @03:43PM (#29111667)
On first read I don't see anything wrong with this bill. It appears to extend a reporting requirement already applying to cash transfers to other forms of monetary exchange.

I don't see why transferring money via a cryptocurrency vs cash should be subject to different rules.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by woah on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:21PM (#29112105)
Your comment is pretty unrelated to the article. It sounds like you're talking about a simple sending of cryptocurrency from one business or individual or another, but that's not what the article is talking about.

It is impossible to report "who" you received an asset from if you received it from a smart contract that is not under the control of any one business or individual. In the cases of most defi contracts, the assets involved are pooled from many thousands of individuals and act as a sort of autonomous market maker.

Cases where criminals obfuscate simple transfers are already prosecuted under money laundering laws, and they are very easy to prosecute because blockchains are a completely open record for anyone to data-mine.

If research into and use of financial smart contracts should be shut down immediately in the US, let them debate and make a law about that. Don't sneak it into a monster bill and pretend that it's about something entirely different.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by pjc50 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:39PM (#29112298)
> smart contract that is not under the control of any one business or individual

This doesn't mean it's not under control of someone or a group of people. Claiming it's not under control just means you're hiding the true controller, which might be an embargoed entity like Iran.

If you have to submit a 1,000 long list of people each of whom has a fragment of control, so be it. Or spend a few dollars getting a Delaware corp.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by nostrademons on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:20PM (#29112666)
Barring specific features like admin contracts or governance tokens, it is possible to have a smart contract that is not under control of someone or a group of people. Contract bytecode gets uploaded to Ethereum (potentially anonymously, and potentially generated by a computer). It then does exactly what the smart contract says it does, including potentially trading or transacting digital assets, in perpetuity, for as long as there exists at least one Ethereum node on earth. By default, smart contracts can't be modified by anyone, not even their creator.

This strikes me like Indiana legislating the value of pi. There exists a natural world out there, beyond human influence, and certain computer programs (particularly ones on Ethereum, where they run on all computers, not one computer) effectively become part of the natural world. The law is set up on the assumption that all actions are ultimately caused by a human or organization, but this may not be a valid assumption anymore.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by pjc50 on Friday November 05, 2021 @05:54AM (#29117215)
> it is possible to have a smart contract that is not under control of someone or a group of people. Contract bytecode gets uploaded to Ethereum (potentially anonymously, and potentially generated by a computer). It then does exactly what the smart contract says it does, including potentially trading or transacting digital assets, in perpetuity, for as long as there exists at least one Ethereum node on earth.

If I may translate this in to politician speak, you're saying that the Iranian government and other OFAC-sanctioned entities can create autonomous fiscal cyberweapons which cannot be turned off?

(Requires a bit of imagination to do this without oracles, which are obviously a weak spot, but you could imagine having an autonomous bug bounty program that can automatically validate and pay out certain kinds of exploits. Self-funding ransomware?)

If there can be autonomous organizations, there can be autonomous crimes, and that is not a stable situation.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by sfcryptonic on Saturday November 06, 2021 @02:58PM (#29132856)
Can you expand on this for me please . i am very interested in your perspective on this
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by deputydoofy on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:56PM (#29113903)
I understand the position that we should just handle it like cash because that seems obvious but consider that you risk killing a potentially very large new industry and area of consumption in it's crib by insisting that it must be able to behave within the framework of the current reality because that's how it is right now. For example what if peer to peer connections on the internet had been banned because a user is not allowed to operate their own phone exchange and come on, directly connecting with someone on a data line is basically the exact same thing as connecting with someone on a voice line. It should be done in a smart way, finding new ways to accomplish the goals if it's going to stifle innovation and put the USA behind other countries in the world.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by woah on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:24PM (#29112711)
The only people who could be said to be "in control of" a smart contract are the miners or validators producing blocks. But they are just executing the code of the blockchain and the smart contract, and if any one of them didn't do it, someone else would with no interruption of the network's functioning. So it is a real logical stretch to assert that they have any control.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by anamax on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:54PM (#29112965)
> Or spend a few dollars getting a Delaware corp.

"few dollars"? More like a couple of hundred, some of that on-going and yes, it costs money to shut it down.

And, if you live in CA, you also get to pay $500/year for the privilege of operating a "not CA" corporation in CA, not to mention some other reporting.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by thebean11 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:04PM (#29112517)
Who is on that list for an ETH staking reward or BTC mining reward? You understand it would be literally impossible to comply right?
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by pjc50 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:15PM (#29112628)
The "appears from nowhere" aspect is something of a problem, but it's valueless until transacted at which point the counterparty has the same obligation to know where it came from.

You could probably suceed in arguing that mining was creating the asset.

> literally impossible to comply right?

This has sadly not always been a defense, like jailing women for miscarriage.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by thebean11 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:05PM (#29113062)
So you are advocating for something you yourself compare to..jailing a woman for a miscarriage?

> but it's valueless until transacted

That's up for debate, and most people would disagree. Mining/staking revenue is taxed as income when received, not when you sell.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by I_am_tiberius on Thursday November 04, 2021 @03:57PM (#29111820)
Did you read the "it imposes reporting requirements that, given the way DeFi works, would make it impossible to comply" part? If that's not wrong I'm not sure what you expect.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by Arcuru on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:09PM (#29111954)
Unfortunately, saying that something is "illegal by design" is not usually an effective defense.

This is just the kind of thing that cryptocurrencies need to contend with if they want to be used everywhere. Either they need to comply with the existing financial regulations or become powerful enough that they can change the financial regulations.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by godelski on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:14PM (#29112007)
Legal also didn't mean moral. But we're also talking about making something a law or not. I'm not sure how your comment really responds to the person saying that they don't want this to become the law.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by matheusmoreira on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:20PM (#29112086)
> become powerful enough that they can change the financial regulations

This is what should happen.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by bonzini on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:52PM (#29112411)
Until then (or for that to happen) they should focus on solving the issues that the reporting requirements are meant to solve.

Sure, all transfers are visible in the blockchain, but how do you preserve that information across tumblers and/or associate wallets to tax IDs?

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by tata71 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:13PM (#29112000)
Like Uber changed taxi licensing just about anywhere they flexed their wallet?
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by josho on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:11PM (#29111974)
Or where we are today raise enough attention (through articles like this) that this new requirement does not become law.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by BitwiseFool on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:12PM (#29111986)
>"saying that something is "illegal by design" is not usually an effective defense."

Is it though? Putting onerous requirements on something is an excellent de-facto way to effectively outlaw something when there isn't enough political will to directly ban it.

Edit: Look no further than what Texas is trying to do with abortion access. They can't directly outlaw abortion but they can add a bunch of inane requirements that make getting one prohibitive. Alabama continually passes laws that put additional requirements on the staff of abortion clinics and most of them are not reasonable, unless the reason is to make operation increasingly difficult. https://www.prochoiceamerica.org/state-law/alabama/

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by Cederfjard on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:25PM (#29112146)
Well, I guess it boils down to whether the requirements are still reasonable or not? If yes I guess the grandparent comment stands, if not I suppose there might be reason to review them. But just because something inherently can’t comply with laws and regulations doesn’t mean it should be given exemptions.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by kiklion on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:26PM (#29112152)
I did read but it assumes people know what a liquidity pool is.

So what is a liquidity pool? Example one indicated that a person could withdraw coins using tokens he got when he deposited coins.

So pools are something you deposit coins into for LP tokens and later can surrender the tokens for coins.

In example 2, they say that coins received from a liquidity pool swap cannot be traced. Why not? When the liquidity pool received the coins could it not associate the coins with where it came from?

Even if not, then the liquidity pool itself is the source of the coins. When it gets coins, it needs to know who sent it, and when it sends coins it needs to know who it’s sending it to.

All of this is possible. Just because they currently don’t track this information doesn’t mean it’s impossible to track. It would just require adjustments to their business to make it in compliance with regulations.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by dboreham on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:32PM (#29112212)
The key thing to note is that the LP isn't a "legal entity". It's a function running on some set of blockchain nodes.

Transactions on the LP are visible in the ledger, so if you want, you can construct a list of depositing and withdrawing addresses and amounts.

But cryptocurrency is fungible so it doesn't make much sense to try to match up deposit transfers with withdrawals to form some concept of "who paid whom". That would be equivalent to trying to identify who's money I got when I make a cash withdrawal at my bank's ATM.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by meheleventyone on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:40PM (#29112310)
Then the author/publisher is the legal entity? The code didn’t just publish itself!
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by nybble41 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:57PM (#29112447)
The author/publisher of the smart contract is not the counterparty to the transaction or the source of funds; publishing their information, even assuming it's available, wouldn't satisfy the requirements.

6050l should be repealed altogether, not extended to "digital assets". It was wrong when it was first passed and it hasn't gotten any better since.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by yokem55 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:49PM (#29112377)
Code is speech.

Edit - To expand this thought: If I exercise my freedom of speech by writing a smart contract and publish the code, how can I be liable if someone else uses that code on an actual blockchain?

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by meheleventyone on Sunday November 07, 2021 @07:58AM (#29139073)
Speech still has liability for example libel. But in this case I would agree that the person that published the code on the blockchain has liability. Which is why I included both occurrences in my post.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by nostrademons on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:23PM (#29112698)
The author/publisher might be anonymous. Also, the code could publish itself - one of the opcodes in the Ethereum VM is "create contract".
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by meheleventyone on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:31PM (#29112765)
The code has still been authored to use that op code. Even if you were using a genetic algorithm or similar to generate contracts and some happened to be useful the authorship is still with the author of the original program. Anonymity protects you from having to defend liability not from actually being liable and obviously in the case of crypto has been defeated in the past.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by fasteddie on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:17PM (#29112045)
That's the point, though. I could make a non-crypto based money transfer software that does not store sender or recipient information in the db. That too would make it impossible for that software comply with the law. Or the authors sculpture example.

Just because the nature of the software makes it impossible to comply with particular laws doesn't make it good or bad. You need to make a value judgement if the regulation itself is valuable.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by elil17 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:12PM (#29111984)
Report requirements have been around for every other form of transaction. The fact that a bunch of companies went out and built products that would not be able to comply with a very foreseeable regulation is their own fault.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by _jal on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:26PM (#29112153)
This is starting to get to the original intent of creating Bitcoin - attacking the nation state's taxation and enforcement capability.

It'll be interesting to see how this plays out.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by dboreham on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:34PM (#29112244)
I'm not sure this was the "original intent". Perhaps an "early adopters' vision". I think the original intent was just to make a workable implementation of electronic cash, something that had been discussed in the literature (without the nation state attack aspect) for decades prior.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by _jal on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:49PM (#29112380)
I was on the mailing list where the original paper and first implementation was released.

Of course I can't speak to what was in "Satoshi"'s heart. But I am convinced that person was a member of the list, and shared the anarcho-capitalist goals/dreams that many of the members had.

More generally, other attempts at digital cash were highly discussed topics in those crowds, and the interest was primarily in the ability to transact anonymously and confidentially, because of what that would do to taxation.

If you're interested in what that crowd was thinking at the time, there's an exhaustive "FAQ" still available, written by one of the more vocal proponents of digital anarcho-capitalism:

https://nakamotoinstitute.org/static/docs/cyphernomicon.txt

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by badloginagain on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:19PM (#29113171)
While I would agree that the libertarian anti-establishment cypherpunk culture was ingrained in the early stages of Bitcoins adoption, I would argue the driving motivation of BTC participants have changed.

The overwhelming culture of Bitcoin now is Number Go Up, which will be tested should US regulators fall more anti-crypto than pro-crypto.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:27PM (#29113695)
FWIW, reducing the power of states - and especially nation-states - is not specifically an anarcho-capitalist dream or goal. It was left-wing anarchists that started that ball rolling.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by _jal on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:25PM (#29114090)
I'm not sure it is even true that "lefty" anarchists got there first, but in any case I'm talking about a specific "salon" of people who spanned a couple mailing lists and about a decade of conversation.

If you're interested, I suggest reading some of Tim May's writings. He was very much a very right-wing anarchist focused on destroying the state, and saw encryption, privacy tech and digital cash as mechanisms to do so. I distinctly recall reading a long essay he wrote explaining why he vehemently disagreed with Kropotkin, if you're looking for a way to distinguish this school of thought from Syndicalists.

(I do not endorse his views at all, my highly simplified view is his philosophy played out in reality ends up being indistinguishable from feudalism. I focus on him because he was a sort of spokesman for that crowd, wrote just a ton of messages and essays over a long time, so there's a huge record of his thought, and he was really smart, well educated, and capable of writing cogently.)

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by rsj_hn on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:30PM (#29114130)
I would say that Montesquieu was on the "reducing the power of the state" bandwagon even before then.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:36PM (#29113764)
So as somebody whos probably pretty close to left-wing anarchism, I think markets are the more dangerous shackle when compared to the state.

We need the state to abolish markets, only then can we abolish the state.

Doing it the other way round will just result in all of us being slaves to Jeff Bezos.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:05PM (#29113966)
Left-wing anarchism comes in many flavors, and not all of them are hostile to the markets - think "freed markets" etc.

Speaking for myself, I'm probably closest to mutualism than anything else, and I just don't see how you can have a state that strong that doesn't inevitably lead to stratification and rigid hierarchy.

Conversely, I don't see how markets are the problem. Capitalism is a problem, sure - but capitalism requires the state! To accumulate capital indefinitely, you need abstract property rights, and then you need the state to maintain the registries of who owns what, and to enforce - with violence if need be - the owner's monopoly on the property. Conversely, if the government, or the society at large, simply refuses to acknowledge such property rights, how would Jeff Bezos become himself?

(Yes, ancaps themselves think that removing the state would usher hyper-capitalism, but I don't understand why everybody is so ready to accept that claim while ridiculing most everything else they have to say.)

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:10PM (#29113994)
Do you not believe that Jeff Bezos would gladly take the monopoly on violence from the state if it were offered? And without the state maintaining those registries, what would stop him from just laying claim to anything he wants?

And maybe it wouldn't be him, but somebody who's shown more propensity for violence, say Erik Prince. If we don't use the state to rob those people of their power first, there will be nothing in their way once we abolish the state.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:43PM (#29114210)
You're basically saying that Jeff Bezos would become the government of his newly-formed state, which would be bad for its subjects. I agree with that last part.

But the state is just an abstraction. It's the people who are in the way of Jeff Bezos doing something like that. In a centralized state, it's people who are in service of the state - which, in practice, usually means people in service of someone like Jeff Bezos, simply because sociopaths can play the power game better than anyone else. I don't see any fundamental difference between Amazon and the US Government in that regard. The latter is ostensibly democratic, but in practice, representative democracy at best just gives voters the opportunity to back one elite group against the other - so on matters where they're all in agreement (e.g. that elites should have all the effective political and economic power), it doesn't really solve anything.

In a decentralized society, it's organized community that stands in the way. You can argue that it's not strong enough to face someone like Bezos - but, again, Bezos only has the economic power that he has because our government actively protects his concentration of it. If it's not there to do so, how would he acquire the monopoly on violence in the first place? A lone guy with a gun doesn't have a monopoly on violence. A lone guy with enough capital to subsidize a private army might, but that's not possible in a society where capital can't be accumulated indefinitely.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:55PM (#29114280)
> The latter is ostensibly democratic, but in practice, representative democracy at best just gives voters the opportunity to back one elite group against the other - so on matters where they're all in agreement (e.g. that elites should have all the effective political and economic power), it doesn't really solve anything.

I agree with you here.

> A lone guy with a gun doesn't have a monopoly on violence. A lone guy with enough capital to subsidize a private army might, but that's not possible in a society where capital can't be accumulated indefinitely.

This is where I disagree. He already accumulated plenty of capital and that's exactly the problem. Nothing stopping him from hiring an army with his amazon bucks.

In order to switch to this decentralized society, we need to reset hierarchies, like ones based on capital accumulation first. The only entity I see that would possibly be strong enough to do so is the state.

Now getting it to do so is the tricky part. I'm not sure anything short of a vanguard revolution would do the trick, but vanguards have the unfortunate property of trying to hold on to power after the revolution is done.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @09:08PM (#29114359)
This seems to have worked pretty well for the Zapatistas so far, and more recently in Rojava:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_power#Strategy_and_ideolo...

(Note that crypto meshes really well with this paradigm.)

I will also add that "resetting" accumulation of capital doesn't require any physical acts of violence, either. The only reason why e.g. Bezos owns as much as he does, is because he says so, the government confirms it, and we all collectively accept it as a society. But take that last part away, and it all falls down like a house of cards. And you can't pay for an army with wealth that you don't actually control.

OTOH if you try to "reset the hierarchy" through centralization of power, it just replaces one set of elites with another. Worse yet, the new elites get more tools at their disposal to maintain their dominant position - all while talking about how they're really doing it for the sake of public good etc.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by serverholic on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:33PM (#29112231)
It’s also attacking the current financial system where elites get special privileges and act irresponsibly.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by fny on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:18PM (#29112070)
Honestly, I think this is outside the spirit of the law.

Say you take your money put it in a bank account, the bank lends that money out again. Are you responsible for knowing the recipient? No. I imagine the same will be extended to putting money into a swap pool or DEX.

Now say you actually send money to someone over $10k and don't report it. This is just like a 1099.

Honestly, all the fear over what this is going to do is total FUD. It's not that difficult of a rule to deal with for law abiding citizens, and anyone who wants to continue using crypto to launder money or evade taxes will keep using mixer wallets.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by nickff on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:23PM (#29112124)
>"Say you take your money put it in a bank account, the bank lends that money out again. Are you responsible for knowing the recipient? No. I imagine the same will be extended to putting money into a swap pool or DEX."

My read of this law is that the bank or recipient of your money would be required to make the report (as they are the 'possessor'), which appears to already be the case (so-called KYC laws). I think you may be underestimating the amount of regulatory compliance that the government requires of many businesses.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by fny on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:09PM (#29112563)
Exactly, the banks don't report that YOU paid money to others on a loan, the bank has it's own reporting requirements, hence you are not liable. Interestingly, financial institutions (which includes exchanges) are currently exempt from the reporting requirements in this law "the only businesses that are exempt from section 6050I are banks and financial institutions."

So my take is they haven't figured out how to regulate the institutional aspect, they're simply attempting to monitor person to person transfers as a first pass. And this makes sense given the wash sales and other tricks people are trying to pull via NFTs and the like.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by pjc50 on Thursday November 04, 2021 @04:40PM (#29112313)
> Say you take your money put it in a bank account, the bank lends that money out again

The bank has a corporate identity which can be held liable.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:45PM (#29112881)
If something can't possibly be implemented in a legal way, then maybe, just maybe, it's just a bad idea?

"It's impossible to comply with the ban on murder while we continue killing people" - Yes, that's the point. Stop doing what you're doing.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by nightski on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:51PM (#29112938)
Except it can. This is a bill that has not passed yet. That is the entire point of the article, to argue against this new legislation.

No need to equate DeFi with murder either, that's just being ridiculous.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @05:55PM (#29112976)
I think the framing of this article is super biased. It implies that there is a right to DeFi and that this law would take away that right (it also seems to imply it would do that by accident since legislators couldn't possibly do this on purpose.)

There isn't a right to undermine the nation state and maybe, just maybe, the government is for once waking up and doing a useful thing by nipping this in the bud before it becomes dangerous?

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by toomuchtodo on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:11PM (#29113111)
Crypto proponents, painting with a broad brush, believe that code should be above nation state laws and regulations.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @06:15PM (#29113150)
... and then get outraged at anyone wanting to avoid that dystopia.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:31PM (#29113731)
There's a natural right to undermine the nation state - or any other actor - when said actor itself undermines natural rights. Whether you believe that freely exchanging goods and services is a natural right or not is another question.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by krapp on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:39PM (#29113780)
>There's a natural right to undermine the nation state - or any other actor - when said actor itself undermines natural rights. Whether you believe that freely exchanging goods and services is a natural right or not is another question.

This resolves to "there is a right to undermine anyone or anything for undermining your beliefs," because what is and isn't considered a "natural right" is entirely subjective.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:55PM (#29113898)
Rights are social constructs, of course. But we rely on such social constructs all the time. Any ethical system, when you unravel it down to the very bottom, boils down to some axioms that are taken for granted - you can't construct ethics out of nothing.

OPs implicit assertion that undermining nation-states is somehow bad does not have a foundation that is any more stable.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:39PM (#29113786)
One could even say there is no such thing as "natural rights".

If it's not codified in law, it's not a right, it's a feeling.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:28PM (#29113709)
Conversely, if something that isn't obviously problematic cannot be implemented in a legal way, then maybe, just maybe, the law in question is a bad idea?
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @07:31PM (#29113724)
Maybe. But this doesn't apply here since taking control of money from the state is obviously problematic and will result in us devolving into neofeudalism.
Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by int_19h on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:00PM (#29113930)
It's not obviously problematic to me, and I don't see why it's a dichotomy between nation-states and neo-feudalism. The states haven't had that much power over monetary policy for most of human history - and there were many different forms of social organization in said history, of which feudalism is a fairly small subset.

Nor is it obvious at all that there are no other forms that have yet to be tried. Or are being tried - I mean, the Zapatistas are crazy decentralized, but it's not a feudal society, either.

Re:DeFi and the “digital asset” felony hidden in the infrast... by malermeister on Thursday November 04, 2021 @08:05PM (#29113969)
The logical outcome of giving any and all control over money to market mechanisms is anarcho-capitalism, where the market is the only thing that matters.

The logical outcome of anarcho-capitalism is feudalism, as people with more money concentrate more and more power with no state to stand in the way. Sooner or later you either do what Jeff Bezos wants or his Prime Forces will see that you are punished. Who's gonna stop them?