I don't get the problem with Foundation. Like why can't they take the source material and create their own interpretation? What's so wrong with that? Maybe someone will go on and create a Vorkosigan Saga interpretation too?
I read the books. Loved them. Really enjoying the show too.
You’re disappointed because you have set expectations on what they should do. But that doesn’t mean it’s bad. I got over the “it must follow strictly” mindset a long time ago.
> You’re disappointed because you have set expectations
They created those expectations by clamming it is an adaption of the books. Imagine if I claim that my show called "The lord of the rings" is based on the novels but the only thing in common is that the main character is named Frodo.
The characters keep avoiding explosions and evading terrorists, mostly uninterested and unaffected by them, focused only on their eventual meeting with their CIA contact who is code named Godot.
Occasionally an unusually big action sequence will trigger an extended reflection on the banality of it all.
And the thing is that I love Waiting for Godot, so I could make a strong pitch.
I've just read an interview with the writer, David Goyer:
https://variety.com/2021/tv/features/foundation-apple-adapta...
It's frustrating and I'm not sure why. I think it's because Goyer didn't realize that the 80's books were fan fiction.
Isaac Asimov was always his own biggest fan.
If you write an adaptation of the Foundation series that focuses on Gaal Dornick you're working with a prequel.
The only good prequel ever made is Godfather II, right?
Because a good story starts as late as it possibly can.
So in this case, self-referential or not, Goyer was doomed. He's basing the series on some very bad books.
Casino Royale is considered a prequel because Bond just gets his double-0 in it, while all the other ones he already had it.
The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly is a prequel as well: it is set in the US Civil War, while the others are set after it.
If you want to make an action-y television series, then choose action-y source material. There's so much good sci-fi (and fantasy) out there that can be used for that type of style. The Vorkosigan Saga for one:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorkosigan_Saga
While it may be possible to adapt Waiting for Godot into a Die Hard-like movie, why would you do so?