Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA
by coliveira on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:14AM
(#2908493)
The problem is not decentralization, but that all manufacturing is outside the US. The part of the process left here is the design. But what if the design is done by somebody else tomorrow? Then companies in this country will have no role to play.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA
by derobert on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:26PM
(#2914404)
When you say "all manufacturing is outside the US", you have a very interesting definition of all. You may want to check UNIDO's industrial statistics, for then you'd find that the largest manufacturer country is not China, Japan, Taiwan, etc… it's the US.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA
by bzbarsky on Tuesday August 23, 2011 @01:50AM
(#2915518)
The US does different sorts of manufacturing from China/Japan/Taiwan. There is not that much electronics manufacturing in the US.
But yes, by value of output, the US is a major manufacturer; we especially specialize in manufacturing large expensive stuff.
The Forbes author is arguing that it is hard to innovate when all the manufacturing expertise leaves. To support this he argues that some Kindle parts are made in China, others Taiwan, others South Korea. To me this is evidence that innovation occurs at a decentralized level. Innovation occurs when companies specialize and focus on a better battery, or screen, or lens instead of a better device. Most people on HN seem to believe that small decentralized start-ups are more innovative than bigger companies. Why is decentralization good for software innovation, but bad for hardware innovation?