News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by dragonwriter on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:01PM (#29073050)
> A gap doesn't necessarily mean there is a problem

Yes, it does.

> unless you believe that proportional representation is important enough to do away with seats having a regional tie completely.

Two problems here:

(1) it prevents a false dichotomy that the only way to address the gap is erasing regional ties completely, and

(2) it confuses the question of “does a problem exist?” with the question of “is there a means of fixing the problem that doesn't have it’s own, equally or more significant problems?”

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ceejayoz on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:34PM (#29073438)
> Yes, it does.

For a concrete scenario: a 50/50 split state with three Congressional seats. One party will likely get one seat, the other two. Potentially by tiny margins.

There will be a major gap in representation, even with perfectly fairly drawn districts.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by dragonwriter on Monday November 01, 2021 @06:06PM (#29073845)
Heck, even with three seats with PR you get that result; that's a proportionality problem from limited granularity.

This is also why strong, independent, unitary executive systems are themselves an additional proportionality problem on top of any that exist in the legislative branch, as a one-member body is the extreme limit case of granularity-limited proportionality.

Of course, granularity-limited proportionality in a representative body has a fairly obvious trivial approach for mitigation to any arbitrary extent desired, so proportionality gaps from this source are neither non-problems or problems without corrections available.