News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by blululu on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:16AM (#29066833)
The simple answer is yes. You could make some elaborate post-modernist point about the impossibility of a value neutral perspective, and there is some merit to such claims, but there are also clear mathematical criteria that can be used to asses the fairness of a voting/districting scheme. This is as unbiased of a criteria as one can establish for voting rights and districting (unless your idea of bias is simply, defined in terms of agreement with the prevailing political ideologies, in which case we open the door to all sorts of procedural abuse).
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by finite_jest on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:32PM (#29069068)
I don't think the GP is asking whether it is possible to objectively assess the fairness of voting schemes. (Though of course that would be an interesting question)

He is implying that their testimony would most likely be very biased politically. I think that is probably true, and you can see that by skimming through their Twitter accounts [1][2][3].

However, this does not justify the university intimidating them with legally dubious means. [4]

[1]: https://nitter.fdn.fr/electionsmith

[2]: https://nitter.fdn.fr/ElectProject

[3]: https://nitter.fdn.fr/SharonFLUMC

[4]: I am tempted to say that the correct course of action would be to defund all social science departments (except perhaps economics), but that's politically unfeasible.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by WarOnPrivacy on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:42AM (#29068231)
> there are also clear mathematical criteria that can be used to asses the fairness of a voting/districting scheme

I think this illustrates how bias thrives in generalities - with as little evidence as is necessary to advance the agenda.

Deep examination of nuances leads to an organic, comprehensive understanding, one that is rocky soil for bias.

As example: Ideological media relentlessly push preformed talking points to prevent viewers from contemplating an issue beyond the desired scope.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by hodgesrm on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:27AM (#29066978)
> Regardless of your stance on the issue, does anyone actually believe that three "voting rights" professors will give a politically unbiased testimony in 2021?

Why is this question even relevant in a court case? There's no assumption anyone involved in either side of litigation is unbiased: in fact quite the contrary. The legal system including judges and juries is designed to sort out the contending claims.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by josefresco on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:14AM (#29066815)
You don't need a "voting rights professor" to tell you what they're doing in Florida is undemocratic, un-American and 100% politically motivated.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by f154hfds on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:26AM (#29066961)
As a curious non-Floridian, what about the bill is objectionable? I think I found the text here: https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2021/90/BillText/er/HT...

I personally find issue with the idea of convicts being unilaterally disbarred from voting while I also feel that verifying the identification of the voter is pretty crucial to a believable vote. But I didn't read the whole thing. There might be more objectionable material that I missed or didn't understand properly.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by notreallyserio on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:41AM (#29067153)
There’s a real risk that voter ID laws could bar more legitimate voters than illegitimate. If you feel there were, say, 1000 fraudulent votes but that voter ID legislation would prevent 10000 legitimate votes, would that be an acceptable trade off? I say no. And from what I have read in the past the ratio is far worse.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by throwawayboise on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:47AM (#29067253)
I mean, I have needed ID to vote for 30 years. I don't understand the objection to making some effort to verify that the person presenting himself as J. Random Voter is actually who he says he is.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ceejayoz on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:48AM (#29067268)
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/getting-a...

> For Settles to get one of those, his name has to match his birth certificate — and it doesn’t. In 1964, when he was 14, his mother married and changed his last name. After Texas passed a new voter-ID law, officials told Settles he had to show them his name-change certificate from 1964 to qualify for a new identification card to vote.

> So with the help of several lawyers, Settles tried to find it, searching records in courthouses in the D.C. area, where he grew up. But they could not find it. To obtain a new document changing his name to the one he has used for 51 years, Settles has to go to court, a process that would cost him more than $250 — more than he is willing to pay.

That's a pretty clear illegal poll tax, if you ask me.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by singlow on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:22AM (#29067889)
Can he not vote using the name the State does recognize?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ceejayoz on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:31AM (#29068038)
The article is pretty clear on that point.

> What he does not have is the one thing that he needs to vote this presidential election: a current Texas photo ID.

He can't get one without the proper documents, which he can't obtain.

Texas's list of requirements is at https://www.dps.texas.gov/internetforms/Forms/DL-15.pdf; he'll need proof of residence, which is likely all under the name he's been using for half a century.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by notreallyserio on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:29AM (#29068000)
Wouldn’t that be fraud under voter ID law, providing a false name?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by singlow on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @04:13PM (#29099684)
How would it be fraud if the name is his, legally?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:40AM (#29068196)
Pretty clear not an illegal poll tax since this man is an edge case who uses a name with no proof. It’s sad that this is ultimately his mother’s fault, and he can’t ask her for the $250 to fix this.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ceejayoz on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:43AM (#29068243)
It's his mother's fault for not anticipating a policy half a century into the future?

Are you prepared to similarly be declared an edge case and not permitted your Constitutional rights?

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:55PM (#29069438)
It's his mother's fault for losing the documentation of his name change.

Am I prepared? Yes. I have all my important identity documents locked in a fire safe. If something should happen to them, I'm willing to pay the $250, etc. amount to fix the problem.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ceejayoz on Monday November 01, 2021 @01:43PM (#29070162)
That's not what I asked.

I asked if you'd accept "you don't get Constitutional right X because you're an edge case" if it were your edge case and not someone else's.

($250 is, to many on HN, an insignificant amount. To some in the world, it's the sort of expense that'd mean eviction or having to skip your diabetes meds for the week. No one should have to pick between necessary expenses and their right to vote like this.)

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @04:07PM (#29072318)
You changed your question by paraphrasing. Surely, you know how the original question could be inferred to be more about the specific thing we're discussing. But I'll placate you and answer your clarified question:

Yes. I live in California and own guns, so I've already seen my state make many compromises on the most liberal (not as in 'left') interpretation of my 2nd Amendment rights. Some of the laws even result in extra fees. And no, I don't "get" my 2nd Amendment right in the same sense that people "get" that right in Texas.

Anyway, I'm not sure we're going to get through talking past each other on this topic. Voter id is clearly intended to ensure and enforce an implicit voting right that my-vote-counts-the-same-as-yours (disregarding any complaints about the Electoral College). If people cannot acknowledge that and want to pretend voting is identical to, say, speech, I'm not sure how to even continue the conversation from there.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by _jal on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:59AM (#29068521)
Always nice to see people willing to write off other peoples' disenfranchisement as a rounding error or 'worth it' (whatever 'it' is.)

That is exactly the attitude the authoritarians are counting on.

This is how you lose your own representation.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @01:00PM (#29069530)
Thank you for scare quotes around something I never said. What will you accuse me of next?

I don't think any of this is "worth it," I just don't agree with coming up with sob stories as a counterexample. It's not that hard to hold onto important government documents like your birth certificate, social security card, etc. The argument against disenfranchisement shouldn't look like such a clear edge case.

If anything, I think there's a case to be made that the government shouldn't be using paper documents handed to potentially irresponsible parents to verify identity, and then holding someone responsible for their parents' fuck-ups. But the jump from such an argument to saying we shouldn't verify voter identity at all is an absurd one.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by _jal on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:55PM (#29071248)
Wait, are they scare quotes, or am I quoting you?

The fact that you can't decide makes me think you know I wasn't quoting you, which was contextually obvious.

I find the rest of your argument equally sincere and convincing.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by notreallyserio on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:35PM (#29071862)
It’s also really easy for someone to steal your documents. It’s not unheard of for an abusive partner to steal documents in order to trap their victim.

I know your pattern now, you’ll call this another edge case sob story and set it aside because it isn’t convenient for your argument.

As for your paper document argument… what is your proposed alternative? You must have one, else you wouldn’t have floated it.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:51PM (#29072092)
Appreciative to see we've all moved on from, 'voter id is inherently racist,' to, 'what if my dog ate my voter id?'

(Aside, today is having fun with quotes day.)

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ModernMech on Monday November 01, 2021 @09:41PM (#29075814)
Abusive partners exerting control by restricting access to important documents is a very real problem for many women, and men for that matter. Also this is something abusive parents and human traffickers do. It should not be minimized and trivialized as “my dog ate my voter id”.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:18PM (#29076544)
I’m trivializing the use of the victim of an event as justification to say we can’t have voter id. It’s a strange argument, coming off as if voter id laws and protecting people from spousal abuse must be at odds, so anyone who supports voter id must support spousal abuse as well.

Is the next argument that Hitler wanted voter id? At what point do we get to actually discuss the merits of validating a person is who they say they are so they get exactly one vote?

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by ModernMech on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @09:20AM (#29080776)
If you want to champion a law that impacts someone's fundamental rights as a citizen, rights protected by the US Constitution, it's your duty as a fellow citizen to consider the impact of that law on everyone, and to show that you've taken appropriate consideration as to the first and second order impact of your proposal.

Implementing a voter ID law in the way being pushed right now will disenfranchise people, and it seems like every time an example of an impacted group is brought it, they are summarily dismissed and their existence minimized as "edge cases" or mocked. e.g. "What, are minorities so dumb they can't get an ID?" or in this case "What, did the dog eat your voter ID?"

But it doesn't change the fact that this law you are pushing will take away their rights. What are you going to propose to make them whole, or did you not think it through that far? It would just be nice if you would demonstrate you are as concerned with disenfranchising your fellow citizens as you are cracking down on suspected and heretofore yet unproven massive voter fraud.

> At what point do we get to actually discuss the merits of validating a person is who they say they are so they get exactly one vote?

Well, it would be nice if the side claiming massive systemic voter fraud would prove their claims. That would be a good starting point. Then we could have actionable fixes that address a specific problem to minimize collateral damage. I just don't understand why we have to engage in a massive civic project that will strip rights from citizens under literally no burden of proof for those making these claims.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by isoskeles on Tuesday November 02, 2021 @03:12PM (#29086056)
Why do you think I'm obligated to defend the position that "massive systemic voter fraud" is the only valid reason for asking people to identify themselves when voting? It's interesting considering I never brought up massive systemic voter fraud, I only brought up that a $250 fee to resolve a one-off problem with someone's identity, that his mother ultimately caused, isn't a "poll tax."
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by Miner49er on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:26AM (#29067946)
Why make voting harder and more expensive then it already is?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by andrew_ on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:51AM (#29068372)
Apologies for replying to your question with a question. What is hard and expensive about voting today?

I'm interested in your experiences on the topic, as I've personally not had a voting experience that was hard or expensive. For what it's worth, I'm considered a minority in the U.S.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by cmh89 on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:23PM (#29068900)
It depends on where you are. In my state (Oregon), voting is easy and secure. We vote by mail as a default and if you move and don't get your ballot, you can go to any voting office and request all the way up until when polls close on election day.

Now, if you are in republican held states like Alabama or Georgia, it's going to be a different story. republicans use several methods to disenfranchise voters, voter ID is just one of them.

1. republicans always aim to have the shortest polling hours possible. This benefits them because their base tends to be older and more time/ability to vote during the day. Working-class voters are especially impacted by this because if they can even get time off during the day, they probably will have to pay for the privilege of voting in the form of sacrificing hours at work and getting a reduced paycheck.

2. The second thing republicans do is close polling stations in areas they don't expect a lot of support. This creates massive wait times for folks who are more likely to vote Democrat.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/smartphone-data-s...

Those hourly workers who are already sacrificing money to vote have to take even more time off to cast their ballot.

3. Another tactic is voter roll purges. A lot of folks don't know that they've been unenrolled from the voter rolls till they show up on election day. This particularly effects renters who might not realize they aren't registered at their current address, and miss mail regarding it because its sent to their former address.

4. republicans will also just shamelessly attempt to discourage Democratic turnout. For example, Georgia got rid of voting early Sunday morning to put a damper on the 'Souls to Polls' movement. There is no rationalization for this. They didn't even bother to lie about it. They just wanted to squash a successful Black get-out-the-vote initiative.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by the_snooze on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:48PM (#29069318)
>3. Another tactic is voter roll purges. A lot of folks don't know that they've been unenrolled from the voter rolls till they show up on election day. This particularly effects renters who might not realize they aren't registered at their current address, and miss mail regarding it because its sent to their former address.

I hear this a lot, but states do have to keep their voter rolls up-to-date by law. People move in and out all the time, and not everyone votes in every election. Are there mechanisms that you think are effective in reducing the chances of someone mistakenly getting removed, while still allowing for stale records to be dropped?

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by cmh89 on Monday November 01, 2021 @01:00PM (#29069536)
There are two things that could alleviate the problem without disenfranchising voters. One, don't purge voter roles right before major elections. Two, allow for same day registration updates.

You show up, they find you in the system at your old address, you submit an updated registration card, they hand you a ballot, and we all move on with our lives.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by the_snooze on Monday November 01, 2021 @01:57PM (#29070369)
I think that's totally reasonable, but I'm still left wondering when and how states should actually carry out purging their voter records. Would a year before a presidential/midterm election be fair? Six months? What about primary elections?

As for same-day registration, I'm sort of for it, but only if people understand the cost involved. And it's not about money. I served as a poll worker in California many years ago, which has very accommodating rules for voting. You can register same-day, vote out-of-precinct, the whole smash. It makes it really easy for voters, which is a good thing. But it has a price: it makes the check-in process more complicated. If there are a lot of people who need to do same-day registration (as was the case in my precinct when the city renamed a street a few weeks before the election), then it causes long lines.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by cmh89 on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:38PM (#29070970)
Why would you do it before major elections if it's just about book keeping? You could purge them a month after mid-terms and a month after general Presidential because those get the most turnout.

When you purge your voter roles becomes a lot less important if you allow for registration/reregistration on election day regardless.

Oregon has same day registration update (and we have motor voter) and no long-lines because we vote primarily by mail.

Disenfranchising voters to 'avoid long-lines' is just a red herring.

There are lots of ways to create quick, safe voting. Election problems are the result of a deliberate attempt to make voting harder for certain people. Full stop.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by andrew_ on Monday November 01, 2021 @01:55PM (#29070339)
I've lived in Michigan, Georgia, Florida, and Texas and (again, as a minority) have never experienced any of these. I'll admit that confirmation bias is a real thing and may apply here, however these points smell of common media talking points and heavy, heavy tribalism. Even as a registered Democrat, I just do not buy into the "Democrats are purveyors of voting righteousness and the Republicans are out to destroy our right to vote" narrative.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by cmh89 on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:47PM (#29071102)
That's great for you! That doesn't really have any bearing on the documented reality of republican disenfranchisement of voters.

Sometimes 'common media talking points' are talking points because a real and serious problem exists. There's plenty of evidence of the problem if you want to take the time to get educated on it.

republicans ARE out to destroy the right to vote. They are actively anti-democracy to the point of spreading outright lies about the 2020 Presidential election and attempting to overthrow the democratically elected candidate for US President. This really isn't a 'both sides' thing.

When you have to pretend that both sides are bad so as to appear fair, we call that 'enlightened centrism'. republicans represent a minority of Americans. They'd never have power again if we had fair democratic elections. Democrats represent the majority of Americans. They benefit greatly from fair democratic elections. It's just that simple.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by treebot on Monday November 01, 2021 @03:44PM (#29071984)
> republicans represent a minority of Americans. They'd never have power again if we had fair democratic elections. Democrats represent the majority of Americans. They benefit greatly from fair democratic elections. It's just that simple.

This is the truth, and is why Republicans are doing what they are doing. It's not because Republicans are bad and Democrats are good. It's because Republicans are going to lose otherwise.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by the_snooze on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:56AM (#29067388)
When it comes to voter ID, the devil is in the details. I'm a poll worker in Virginia and think our ID laws are pretty fair. We accept driver's licenses and passports, sure, but we also take employer photo ID, any current Virginia school ID, and even old Virginia driver's licenses up to a year after expiration. If a state gives affordances like these to make it easy for people to fulfill the ID requirement, I don't see what the problem is.

And I don't think fraud is a particularly good reason to be for voter ID. The ID requirement seems to speed the line along. We don't need people to spell out their names, especially for non-native English speakers with uncommon or foreign names. The security argument for voter ID strikes me as bogus, but it has a place for efficiency and accessibility.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by runako on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:07AM (#29067601)
The problem is not at the point of acceptance, it's at the point of issuance. An egregious violator is Alabama, which systematically closed DMVs in Black counties [1].

The point of modern voting suppression is it's designed such that each hurdle on its own looks reasonable to people new to the issue. But the aggregate is intended to suppress voters in a targeted way. The architects of these programs even publicly say as much, it's not a secret.

Without making the direct comparison, it's worth noting that the Jim Crow voter suppression laws similarly evolved from humble beginnings. That's why it's important to watch the trend line, and these laws do not trend in the direction of more voter participation.

1 - https://www.governing.com/archive/alabama-demands-voter-id--...

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by the_snooze on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:29AM (#29068015)
I don't think we're disagreeing here. I did say the devil is in the details. I'm putting forth Virginia as a state that does it well (i.e., there are multiple independent sources of valid ID, so we can't pull Alabama-like DMV shenanigans), and pointing out that voter ID has value in ways not often discussed, particularly in making the voter check-in process go more smoothly.

There are interesting trade-offs to consider in the voter ID discussion.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by Frondo on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:22PM (#29068890)
This is also why, until the Roberts court gutted the VRA, the courts looked at outcomes of policies and not just intent -- anyone can say the intent was to stop fraud, but if the outcomes are suppression, that used to matter. No more, and that's why state legislatures have jumped at the chance to enact so many laws that "stop fraud" (a problem for which there has not been, and still does not have, any evidence.)
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by SkeuomorphicBee on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:29AM (#29068004)
I don't know anything about Virginia, but based on your comment alone I see clearly what the problem is. What you described is a system that disenfranchises everyone that satisfies tree simple rules: doesn't drive, don't travel internationally, and don't work for a large company. E.g. urban poor service-industry worker (outside of chains, no restaurant issues employer IDs).
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by the_snooze on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:37AM (#29068142)
>What you described is a system that disenfranchises everyone that satisfies tree simple rules: doesn't drive, don't travel internationally, and don't work for a large company. E.g. urban poor service-industry worker (outside of chains, no restaurant issues employer IDs).

If you took a few moments to look up our voter ID requirements, you'd find that your characterization is totally unfair and inaccurate. We also accept utility bills, government checks (i.e., for those on government assistance), and a signed affidavit saying you have an ID. I'm a Virginia homer through and through; I think we do voter ID the right way.

https://www.elections.virginia.gov/media/formswarehouse/vote...

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by nradov on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:38AM (#29068167)
Any citizen or legal resident can obtain a state Real ID compliant card even if they don't drive, travel, or work. Most states offer reduced or free fees for low income individuals.

https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/driver-licenses-identification...

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by yardie on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:15PM (#29068789)
If voting is a right and voting requires ID then it should be on the government to cover the costs of providing that burden.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:46AM (#29067232)
>would that be an acceptable trade off?

Depends on the margins of victory perception of the fraud among the other voters.

If people widely consider the elections to be illegitimate high participation doesn't do anything to solve that.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by notreallyserio on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:32AM (#29068063)
People that believe that are substituting feelings for evidence, so passing laws to assuage their concerns doesn’t make sense. That’d be like requiring drug testing for people to get public assistance, but worse because voting is so fundamental.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by hindsightbias on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:51AM (#29068373)
Is voting a Right or a privilege? If a Right, where does the Constitution denote what crimes cause the loss of that Right?

Plenty of people saw no problem with poll taxes and reading tests. This just the latest swirl.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by Miner49er on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:22AM (#29067871)
It makes it harder to vote, simple as that.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by CoastalCoder on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:26AM (#29066965)
I don't mean to nitpick, but calling this un-American strikes me as the No True Scotsman fallacy.

I.e., Florida is part of the U.S. So if Florida does it, in at least a small way it is American.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by josefresco on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:31AM (#29067030)
It doesn't represent American ideals, but it does represent the reality of America's current (and past) political and cultural landscape.

Making it difficult for certain groups of people to participate in the democratic process is unfortunately a long-standing American tradition.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by CoastalCoder on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:27AM (#29067979)
> It doesn't represent American ideals

Could you expand on that?

My original comment was based on the assumption that the Florida issue demonstrated a lack of ideological consensus amongst Americans. Thus my "no true Scotsman" observation.

So I see two ways that I might have been off the mark:

(a) Florida's actions don't represent those officials' ideals, or

(b) we somehow don't include those officials' ideals when talking about American ideals.

Both (a) and (b) seem like interesting topics of discussion.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by sofixa on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:13PM (#29068752)
> It doesn't represent American ideals, but it does represent the reality of America's current (and past) political and cultural landscape

Which ideals? Don't forget that the US literally started with slavery and land ownership-based voting rights for males only. Incredible progress has been made, but with huge caveats ( no slavery except as punishment, anyone can vote but... ).

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by pyronik19 on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:11AM (#29067694)
Insecure elections don't represent American ideals.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by minitoar on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:34AM (#29067073)
By that logic, anything going on in Columbia is equally American.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by CoastalCoder on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:22AM (#29067875)
The conversation was using "American" as short-hand for "related to the U.S.A." My comment used that colloquialism as well.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by djbusby on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:43AM (#29067178)
Did you mean Colombia?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by jensensbutton on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:25AM (#29066954)
What does "politically unbiased" mean here, exactly? The way I interpret what you wrote is that you're against the current push for making it easier to vote and anything that disagrees with that will be seen as "politically biased" by you. Is that correct?

I guess the other option is that you disagree with expert witnesses as a concept?

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by runako on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:12AM (#29066798)
Remember that testimony is given in an adversarial setting, and answers are framed by the attorneys questioning. So the idea is that either yes, they will give unbiased testimony, or the attorneys will be able to make it plain to the jury that the testimony is biased.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by twofornone on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:15AM (#29066827)
Or option 3, the plaintiff counsel successfully convinces some or all members of the jury that a biased testimony is unbiased.

These are "experts", after all. They're already starting from a position of credibility, and I don't think the defense lawyer is necessarily equipped to deconstruct whatever the "experts" spend their professional lives working on, regardless of the objectivity of their teatimony.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by babyblueblanket on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:19AM (#29066872)
By this logic, no experts should be allowed in court unless the opposing lawyer has as much education as the expert in their subject.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by twofornone on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:25AM (#29066944)
If the subject is politically polarized then I am inclined to agree. Its an open secret that right leaning opinions are taboo across academia. That doesn't actually mean such opinions are wrong.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by JKCalhoun on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:32AM (#29067044)
> Its an open secret that right leaning opinions are taboo across academia.

This sounds like something someone would say whose opinions were not defensible academically.

Anecdotally, I see examples of right leaning opinions from academically schooled contributors to HN all the time.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by runako on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:33AM (#29067050)
Reminder that attorneys for both sides are allowed to bring their experts. The process itself is not biased toward either side.

> Its an open secret that right leaning opinions are taboo across academia

Not in the South, they aren't.

> If the subject is politically polarized then I am inclined to agree

Does this apply to police testimony as well? Courts use their testimony all the time, and it's certainly politically polarized much of the time.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by toss1 on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:10PM (#29068710)
>>Its an open secret that right leaning opinions are taboo across academia.

Nonsense

I went to a top school in the US and encountered if anything, a constant right-leaning bias, and some people at the same school at the same time are now top RW personalities on Fox, books, etc.

What is happening is that the RW, and particularly the GOP, which was formerly the party of science, technology, and progress, has in more recent years turned towards authoritarianism and this requires a decoupling from facts.

And, yes, the facts (e.g., anthropomorphic global warming, vaccination, voting dynamics, etc.++) do in fact lean against common RW shibboleths used to crank up their populist amplification needed for their ambitions.

If a bona-fide expert presents data and expert scientific interpretation about how vaccines, public health measures, or voting actually works, that is not political. What is political is calling that political and attempting to silence it because you do not like the conclusions.

What it does mean is that people making claims like yours are most likely in the wrong here, and are attempting to silence the very real opposition because they do not like it.

Stop it and rethink.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by twofornone on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:14PM (#29074551)
Your anecdote does not match study/survey data that has been around for at least a decade.

>And, yes, the facts (e.g., anthropomorphic global warming, vaccination, voting dynamics, etc.++

Part of the problem is this insidious, preemptive appeal to "consensus" as a misleading substitute for certainty, particularly in biological or social sciences. This isn't physics or math and the science is never so certain as to justify putting careers into jeopardy over dissent.

>a bona-fide expert presents data and expert scientific interpretation about how vaccines, public health measures, or voting actually works, that is not political

It is political when the science on these subjects is not actually settled as is dishonestly claimed and the only allowable opinions of so called experts at the vast majority of our academic institutions consistently align in a certain political direction.

Reality's liberal bias is an illusion, borne of groupthink, social shaming, a collusive media, and exclusion/shaming of dissent. The fact that one or more experts believe something does not make it true, and there is clear evidence of political bias in the sciences. For a more obvious example, consider nonsensical "consensus" that race does not exist, or cannot be used to predictively classify humans. Look at what happen to Watson for daring to suggest that maybe 200k years of natural selection did not stop at the shoulders. The same ideologically driven bias has spread to virtually all soft sciences, and laymen do not understand the hard/soft distinction.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by KittenInABox on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:13PM (#29068755)
Can I, in the process of litigation, bring in political polarization experts to testify that a subject is too politically polarized to permit experts testifying?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by toss1 on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:26AM (#29066960)
Sure, the defense lawyer may not be personally "equipped to deconstruct whatever the "experts" spend their professional lives working on".

However, the defense team certainly has the full capability (including budget) to find their own experts in the field to present to the jury whatever counter-arguments may exist to the plainiff's experts.

If the defense fails to do so, it is either their malpractice, or the reality that they actually have no effective argument.

Either way, even with your original assumption that those plaintiff experts are biases, that is ZERO reason to prevent their testimony.

The only reason to prevent their testimony is that the defense has no real case, and they know it.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by runako on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:24AM (#29066931)
You are correct! But this is the situation with our entire adversarial legal system. We have in general not solved this by excluding expert witnesses, so it is indeed out of the ordinary to block testimony like this.

For example, police have a long-documented history of not giving reliable testimony. And yet these "experts" provide testimony at most criminal trials. If a state is willing to allow its police to provide expert testimony, why not its other employees?

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by klyrs on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:49AM (#29068337)
What's to stop the defense from finding their own experts?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by obelos on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:20AM (#29066886)
It is none of U of F's business whether or not their testimony is politically biased.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by throwaway0a5e on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:50AM (#29067302)
It is so far as U of F is willing/unwilling to have its reputation put on a particular side of a particular political issue.

Frankly, I think "if you're getting paid you can't use our name" is a sane policy for all issues on which professors may testify.

It shouldn't be hard to imagine the shoe being on the other foot and some energy company paying professors to testify that some new environmental law is asinine. But of course just because it's not hard to imagine doesn't mean everybody participating in the discussion doesn't have the amount of cognitive dissonance that prevents doing that. It is 2021 after all.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by obelos on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:04AM (#29067560)
> It shouldn't be hard to imagine the shoe being on the other foot and some energy company paying professors to testify that some new environmental law is asinine.

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, but this is completely normal and happens all the time.

Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by klyrs on Monday November 01, 2021 @11:46AM (#29068294)
The problem here is that U of F is engaging in censorship and witness intimidation. Your prejudice that their testimony will be "biased" is quite irrelevant to the first amendment question at hand.
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by JKCalhoun on Monday November 01, 2021 @10:26AM (#29066959)
If not people who specialize in voting rights who exactly would you expect to be brought forth to lend their expertise?
Re:University of Florida bars professors from testifying in ... by bastardoperator on Monday November 01, 2021 @12:21PM (#29068877)
Yes... Apparently someone at UF is super scared they might be too honest.