1. Dry-weight scales are very common in produce/stores and extremely common in EU stores (I'm in Russia right now and it's de-facto the standard for most every store)
2. Get a few scales cause you can use them for all produce year around, and they easily earn their keep, and the upkeep is cheap
3. Pre-pick pumpkins under a certain threshold and sell at flat prices; this creates two sale levels: one for those who want a big pumpkin to mess with, one for those who just want a pumpkin to carve. The latter doesn't need to be heavily regulated, your workers can just eye-ball it and given the margins around Halloween you won't really lose out (probably such "eye-balling" will benefit the farm, not the consumer)
The technical solution here might eventually be more accurate, but it doesn't really benefit anyone. The conditions to make the camera detection work are wonky and you probably end up wasting more time making sane conditions for detection than you do just setting some limits.
Similarly, don't forget that too much tech, and it actually might __discourage__ people as they see the farm as non-authentic. The aesthetic of an organic "real" farm doesn't include a lot of high-tech in many people's minds, and you risk offending the wisdom of the masses by being "too technological". Granted, there's absolutely no difference in the end result, but consumers certainly thing differently about it (there's a reason a lot of people still prefer a human cashier to the touch-screen terminals at fast food restaurants, and it's not efficiency, that's for sure)
For that matter, you could pre-label everything outside of a "commodity" which you could segregate. But just weighing seems more straightforward than messing with boxes and seems like it would be a pretty good proxy.
Low tech, works well.
I don't really want a teched out pumpkin patch.
Otherwise, build a box, and the smallest box that fit the pumpkin determines its size.
Does the weight increase linearly with size? If it’s especially hollow, probably not, while an especially large and hollow pumpkin may be uncommon and should be sold for a high price.
Edit: I guess a better question would be, can you predict desirable carving qualities and visual size accurately as a function of pumpkin weight?
Whole families dress up for the experience. People love being in a pumpkin patch and searching for their favorite pumpkin. They love doing it with their family. They enjoy the risk of wheeling them and guessing how much they weigh.
And the farm makes more money when they grow heavier pumpkins.
This isn’t an activity to be taken so seriously.
Scales and measurement aren’t really necessary. I could eyeball and wobble a pumpkin very quickly and give a fair price. But then I am having all the fun, not the customer.
Put the tech into making it a better experience!
Oh is that tractor pulling a wagon? Got to go!
Grocery stores pipeline the unloading & loading steps.
This is basically how it works at my local landscaping store where they sell gravel by weight.
> - Move your barrow under a camera.
Minimum $5k, closer to $25k, to set physical hardware, network, queueing line and instructions
> - It would take a picture and through image recognition identify and classify pumpkins based on size.
$100k+ capex to get implemented model on hardware, sufficient training samples + training expertise, QA, etc. Ongoing opex for maintenance (sun, weather), model maintenance, and cloud infra / use
> - This would be pushed to cashier with total.
Customers would argue with cashier, much like self-checkout lines at big box stores.
> - Maybe where confidence level on classification was low it would prompt human intervention.
Confidence could be high on false positives/negatives.
-----------------------------
Overall, I like the idea of AI-assistive technology implementations. Are we to the point where it won't wreck the economics of a small operation?
To address their primary note directly: I do indeed speak this way when reviewing details and considering hunches on viability. If someone only needs a conclusion then I give them one. Most people legitimately considering something, like creating an ML implementation (something I do all the time) and mapping to business feasibility, benefit by understanding the "why" of a conclusion. That by chance you do not personally benefit is not pertinent. If I have read your comment appropriately, I recommend adopting this interpersonal wisdom: https://xkcd.com/1053/
This would encourage people to shop early as they would get the pick of the crop - so to speak. Latecomers to the party would have less choice, obviously, but would still be incentivised to buy anyway since there are not that many alternative pathches to choose from in a given area.
The price could also be reduced as time goes by so the day before halloween you're almost certain to sell the most amount possible.
Aka selling different styles of pumpkin at different price per weight. The seller can sell to people willing to pay more for various styles, and people willing to pay more for various sizes. And to people wanting to spend less, and everyone in between. Which is what already happens.
One would need to know what a typical amount of waste is and the cause of that waste to determine if there is too much waste and how to fix it. But I am guessing whatever waste there is now is a pretty optimal amount of waste unless there is some new development that reduces the volatility of producing pumpkins.
Farming in general is like that, since so many variables are outside of peoples’ control. You have to aim for extra even if you are not projecting to sell all of it, assuming the cost of making the extra is absorbable.
Pumpkin falls on an Arduino controlled button, adds +1 on a price multiplier
All pumpkins get unloaded on a checkout wheelbarrow for customer to load on their car.
To open the cage and collect the checkout wheelbarrow you have to pay price is sum of multipliers times their respective base price.
Unsold loaded checkout wheelbarrows in cages can be pushed by staff at the beginning of the queue with a "pay with credit card and leave in 30 seconds" sign, at a 10% premium.
When we got to the front we had to match our pumpkins to a template based on size (cost from 50p to £10) and then a cashier would tally up the total.
I got chatting to the owner whilst waiting and he was open to a more tech smarter way to pay to avoid the queues.
Anyone have ideas on how to do this, ideally using existing tech mashed together in a low/no code way?
So flow would be ...
- Move your barrow under a camera.
- It would take a picture and through image recognition identify and classify pumpkins based on size.
- This would be pushed to cashier with total.
- Maybe where confidence level on classification was low it would prompt human intervention.
To me weighing the barrow would be another, perhaps better, solution but the farmer wasnt keen on this and ran out of time to dig deeper!