News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by wruza on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:50AM (#29046892)
This thread feels like 1860's consilium on what future will look like 500 years later. The shape of the metaverse will be formed by a new generation, not by older guys (and not by fortnite addicts who play by the rules of the former) who know nothing better than drive a fancy “car” on the “road”, as if roads or a concept of physical movement or the euclidean rule would still be there for common use and not for museums. Virtual worlds up to date, like second life, were mostly just stupid copies of “real life”, which was designed after some physical limitations, or fantasy worlds of parallel earth-likes with a limited magic.

If the only limitation of metaverse is Code and Content, and if that would be much easier to create, then in a blink of an eye it will turn into something absolutely inconceivable to mercedes benz drivers. What really is bullshit, is lack of imagination in people and a shitload of thought inertia. Personally, it feels like the article author has never ever been in the internet, confining themselves at a small circle of “social” networks bs. Those will live in an exact copy of their current environment, paying to bigcorps with their work hours to achieve “expensive” toys, to impress similar narrow-minded guys. I’ve seen second life at its peak, and this is exactly what they were doing there.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Oddskar on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:00AM (#29047807)
I read this three times and I'm still not sure what your point is.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by cromka on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:35AM (#29047983)
That we, "the old folks", just don't get it, limited by having passed our "exploratory" phase and well into "exploitation" phase (something I read here in HN the other day).

And they may have a point: after all, "the old folks" 30 years ago were saying the same thing about the Internet, well into 2000s.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by civilized on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:57AM (#29048411)
Oh come on. Usenet in the 1980s was full of people in their 30s, 40s, and beyond. Sure, some people didn't "get" the internet, but millions of demographically similar people were getting value out of it. That isn't happening, and won't happen, with this metaverse BS. And if it does, attentive people of all ages will see it coming many years in advance.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by parasubvert on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:25PM (#29049997)
Eh, I think Facebook is really onto something, particularly if you see Oculus as the main tip of the spear. They’re playing a very long game.

My high school and college friends and I are spread across the continent. The pandemic and a mix of Discord and Tabletop simulator brought us back together to do regular board gaming. This is effectively a VR environment without the headset.

My 12 year old hangs out on VRchat or Minecraft , simultaneously watching YouTube or Twitch streams at the same time with his friends when he is home. Today this is a mix of FaceTime , Discord etc, but all-in-one will be used if it’s better.

My younger daughter likes to explore VR worlds, and interact with them.

We are seeing what’s coming years in advance, but many aren’t looking. Facebook is going to eat this space up completely at their current rate of success, if Apple , Microsoft or Valve don’t step up.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by civilized on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:52PM (#29051820)
> The pandemic and a mix of Discord and Tabletop simulator brought us back together to do regular board gaming. This is effectively a VR environment without the headset.

This is the central problem for VR. The internet offers many experiences that are essentially "VR without the headset", from the Tabletop simulator you mentioned to World of Warcraft. What does the headset really add? You're still looking at a screen, except now you've got a damn thing on your head and are blind to the actual world around you. That virtual world better be really incredible to make up for it.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by parasubvert on Sunday October 31, 2021 @01:16AM (#29054670)
The quest 2 is surprisingly good at swapping between reality mode (via cameras) and VR mode, when needed. Augmented reality will make this sort of switching more important.

ultimately, people choose VR for the immersion. It’s why problem build home theatres or still go to the theatre, or visit amusement parks, etc., when they’d rather stay home. The headsets are getting far more convenient and comfortable. Still early.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by cromka on Saturday October 30, 2021 @01:05PM (#29050348)
> Oh come on. Usenet in the 1980s was full of people in their 30s, 40s, and beyond

That's anecdotal evidence. Just because there were user that age, doesn't change that their population, in general, was skeptical.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by machiaweliczny on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:32AM (#29049063)
I've read a lot of game reviews on VR and was surprised about demographics. Lots of older (40+) people there. Anyone has more reliable stats?

I personally feel that hardware need to be next-gen as I am nauseus but would be happy to have discord alternative to play in VR. Imagine drawing board, fake cinema, sharing games, arranging common space minecraft-like. I think this will work. You login after work and do creative shit with buddies.

This is how it works for me now but we have discord and own game that we work on. Happy to upgrade XP when new hardware comes.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by redisman on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:23AM (#29049492)
That demographic makes sense. If you’re 40 you grew up with the birth of video games, you read the sci-fi and the early hype and failure of multiple VR products along get decades and you have a bunch of disposable income
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by che_shirecat on Sunday October 31, 2021 @12:40AM (#29054544)
Saving this so I can come back and laugh in 10 years
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by peterthehacker on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:23PM (#29049983)
> we, “the old folks,” just don’t get it

Zuckerberg is 37 years old, so he’d probably be lumped into “the old folks” category. Why would he get it and not us?

I’m, a decade younger than Mark, so idk if I’m young enough by your standards to get it, but my sister and her friends are in college and think this is all a joke. None of them are interested in putting on VR goggles, let alone joining the “metaverse.” None of them had heard of it until Facebook’s name change.

The Metaverse is a top-down Wall Street sponsored hype cycle. It’s not a matter of “old folks” not getting it. It’s Zuckerberg’s attempt to distract Wall Street investors and consumers from Facebook’s growing problems.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by cromka on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:54PM (#29050247)
> It’s Zuckerberg’s attempt to distract Wall Street investors and consumers from Facebook’s growing problems.

Those problems, at their recent peak, are that – recent. Yet I know, for a fact, they have been working on the new concept for very long now. I spoke to a FB insider about a year ago already and he, in very diluted way, described what we know as metaverse now.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by qorrect on Saturday October 30, 2021 @01:15PM (#29050437)
> Facebook’s growing problems

I'm out of the loop, what problems are they having ?

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by jay_kyburz on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:32PM (#29060661)
They ran out of humans to sign up to Facebook.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by parasubvert on Sunday October 31, 2021 @01:21AM (#29054679)
If you’re looking at the consumer gaming and social media space, then you’d get it.

People underestimate Zuckerberg’s ability to see socio-technical far in the future at their peril. He was ridiculed for making a MySpace competitor, for getting rid of Facebook Apps, for the look & feel changes, the ridiculous prices paid for Instagram and WhatsApp… and he was right each time (for growing his business and his customer base).

Where he has been wrong is in putting Facebook at the centre of his empire, when it’s increasingly a legacy platform for family members, old people and maladjusted conservatives. Metaverse corrects this by making Facebook just one of several properties.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by pennaMan on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:02AM (#29048827)
The point is that this technology forum is in the sad state of being consistently dismissive of novel technology.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:14AM (#29048934)
Yup HN is legacy at this point. A bunch of old people yelling at clouds. It’s the new Slashdot. So it goes.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Oddskar on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:12AM (#29049388)
Such hogwash. Because people dismiss the latest lofty vision of a tech behemoth (that has a long graveyard of unsuccessful services behind them) we're now "legacy" and "old people yelling at clouds"?

Disregarding Meta entirely, I would say it's completely normal for people on HN to be sceptical of new things. Most new things don't work out. Most new things are either vaporware or snake oil. It's hard to tell the good from the bad sometimes.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:26AM (#29049510)
> Because people dismiss the latest lofty vision of a tech behemoth

No, the reason is because many new technologies are dismissed here not due to technical infeasibility, but because posters cannot understand the point or value proposition. When this is happening in response to technologies that many people are using and investing in as early adopters, which provides proof of some kind of value at a minimum, is generally speaking a sign of being out of touch to write it off entirely as doomed to fail, vaporware, etc, because you simply do not understand what people are investing their time and capital in.

For example this comes up continually with VR and AR and crypto, extremely rapidly growing technologies with tons of capital flooding into them. It's one thing to say we can't do something, it's another thing to see entire industries forming around you and tons of capital being allocated and saying it will all fail simply because you don't see the point.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Oddskar on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:33AM (#29049573)
Will you recognize that it doesn't actually have to be a point to it, though? As long as you can spellbind investors there doesn't actually need to be something useful that's build at the end of the day. "Crypto" is a good example of this. A lot of the products and services that were build using Blockchain could just have used a normal RDBMS.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:39AM (#29049630)
Sure, no doubt. But the arguments fielded on HN as to why these various technologies are dead ends and will implode once people become rational are weak. They're usually from people who literally have never used the technology (or, used it many years ago.) At best, they have, don't get it (which is fine) but then go on to make the leap that since they didn't get anything out of it, the whole thing is a house of cards. This is a similar error as thinking every new tech that comes along is going to be the next big thing.

The value prop of VR and AR is remote social presence on par with f2f and full sensory override. This is why Facebook is pivoting the entire company around it. This is not something to ignore and dismiss, unless you think Zuck is a complete idiot. The value prop of crypto is economic freedom. This is why VCs are pivoting their entire portfolios around it and why more than a trillion USD have rushed into it. This is not something to ignore and dismiss, unless you think the entire alternative Internet-based financial system being developed around crypto is a bunch of hot air. At a minimum, for those technologies, they deserve steelmanning given how far they've run without dying. The hubris it takes to dismiss things as big as these, which as much potential to radically alter society, isn't just unfounded, but foolish, given that being on the wrong side of this trade in the direction of dismissiveness is hugely risky if you are a technologist.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by secondviewing on Saturday October 30, 2021 @05:44PM (#29052527)
I want to make one thing clear from the outset - I want to get it. I want to get it because I want to restore my enthusiasm for tech. I want to understand how crypto and AR/VR are not a gimmick, a barren offshoot of human creativity that will lead nowhere.

> The value prop of VR and AR is remote social presence on par with f2f and full sensory override

Full sensory override how? VR (and VR-facilitated AR) can't even create an immersive visual experience at this point. It hasn't yet cracked the "3 dimensions" chestnut. You talk of "full sensory override" as if plugging into the brain stem was right around the corner (and was going to bring about that override).

If you did have full-sensory override, you might be onto something, but the way things are today, with the tech so inadequate, it seems like a non-starter. Full-sensory override, if it will come, will likely come from a completely different direction. Think lucid dreaming.

> The value prop of crypto is economic freedom

The kind of economic freedom where even your ability to get involved in crypto at all is fully dependent on centralized exchanges, and their approval of you as a client? That, or rummage around in your attic trying to find a spare power plant that has to be there somewhere, so that you can enter the game via mining.

I am sorry. I really would like to believe. But these hot technologies seem to come with insurmountable design flaws that have been there from day one, were still present at day one thousand, and will be there at day ten thousand. I think that is the reason for the broad skepticism.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:26PM (#29053440)
What are you drawing your conclusions re: VR from? Have you followed the research and used the hardware? It seems pretty clear we will have VR goggles that feel effectively indistinguishable from real life in terms of fidelity and optics relatively soon.

Also there are already decentralized exchanges within crypto assets (eg uniswap), but you do need to find a counter party to get out of fiat. It’s being worked on and centralized exchanges aren’t your only option. It would be worth catching up on DeFi.

Edit: btw I meant visual and auditory sensory override - I agree it is a ways off before you have full proprioception etc, if ever. Not necessary to beat face to face social presence tho.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by kirenida on Sunday October 31, 2021 @04:53AM (#29055556)
> It seems pretty clear we will have VR goggles that feel effectively indistinguishable from real life in terms of fidelity and optics relatively soon.

Just out of curiosity, what about other senses? Smell, touch, temperature, taste?

How close are we to fully experiencing a dinner / concert / mountain hike in VR?

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by wruza on Sunday October 31, 2021 @06:00AM (#29055840)
Teslasuit has some of these features (temperature and touch). It’s pretty expensive, but so are trips to mountains, I guess.

The key point is effectively, imo. If not completely real, there may be a line of deepdive that once you cross it, real trips will still feel “better quality”, but not as in vs “staring at the monitor in your room”. VR doesn’t have to be REAL or even resemble reality, it just has to be convincing.

In my view, there is no point in “walking around” with your real legs in VR, or having the human shape at all. Think of it as a PAL/NTSC converter from human to VR-entity which may or may not be human in different situations. There is no human dinner, concert or even mountain of importance in there. You may be e.g. a spaceship flying in the heat of a quasar, or a building bot with 360 view of its surrondings that moves along the eye focus and feels nearby constructions with its ”skin”. That’s what I was talking about in the root comment (that’s still naive and narrow-minded compared to what is to come). Sorry for this analogy, but most of comments against vr are like “we don’t need modern cities because these are not built for horses”. Yes, no horses, no haystacks, no blacksmiths. It doesn’t mean people will not rush into the city once it’s built with all the infra.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by jay_kyburz on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:42PM (#29060726)
I think people are just responding to how much hype there is. Yes it is cool, immersion feels fun and different. Lifting up that jar and looking at the alien in the first room in Alyx was very cool.

But its just a new way of looking at pixels on a screen. You can't actually "do" anything that you can't already do now.

You can pretend to fly the moon. You can simulate going on an adventure. Its all just entertainment.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Sunday October 31, 2021 @07:17PM (#29061419)
Try meeting with other people. Particularly people you care about. That’s the value prop, and is why Facebook is all-in. Not because of entertainment.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by unixbeard1337 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:07PM (#29049846)
>This is not something to ignore and dismiss, unless you think Zuck is a complete idiot.

Well...

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:16PM (#29049914)
unixbeard1337, I hate to break it to you, but Zuck is not a complete idiot.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by rapiz on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:09PM (#29053912)
> A lot of the products and services that were build using Blockchain could just have used a normal RDBMS.

That's how you dismiss the value and can't understand

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by qorrect on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:25AM (#29049010)
I'm going to go ahead and ask you to get off my lawn.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by jgilias on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:29AM (#29049037)
I've seen all kinds of demographics and localities on HN. What would be the new HN then?
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by jay_kyburz on Sunday October 31, 2021 @08:20PM (#29061809)
I'm nearly 50, I think the Metaverse is a solution looking for a problem, but I don't hate all new tech.

I'm excited about Deno.

I really like the idea of serverless, cloud functions, and these new durable cloud objects that Cloudflare is talking about.

I'm super excited about the Steam Deck. A powerful, handheld PC running Linux, with real buttons I can click, not all just touch screens.

I can understand how Smart Watches will be cool eventually. When they are unteathered and running an open OS.

I will grudgingly admit that the stupid siri voice assist ball thing my wife bought is useful. We use it a lot for setting timers and alarms, playing music, and we are slowing finding more ways it can be useful. I can see that as Siri gets smarter, she will be more useful, so I can understand why everybody is going ape shit over AI.

I think e-bikes scooters are cool. I think EV cars will change the world significantly. I do a 15 minute commute on a scooter every day.

There is a lot of great new tech out there. VR is not one of them.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Karunamon on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:28AM (#29049528)
I don't think that's an age thing as much as a knee-jerk cynicism thing that's been here since at least 2011.

Don't read HN if you want to be excited about something new, read HN if you want it to be torn apart with constant negativity.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Valakas_ on Saturday October 30, 2021 @02:21PM (#29051075)
If you look at future predictions they almost always make the same mistake: they're based on the technology available at the time they were made.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by unknownOrigin on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:58AM (#29048420)
Astroturfing Meta
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by verve_rat on Saturday October 30, 2021 @04:23AM (#29047054)
Without the "concept of physical movement" how will "food" get to your "house"?
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by verisimi on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:57AM (#29049265)
'Food' will be piped directly into your veins, via the food pipe in your 'home cubicle'. Lol :)

And will then exit, captured and recycled!

Welcome to the future!

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by wruza on Saturday October 30, 2021 @04:31AM (#29047090)
Are we "talking" about 2040 or 2140?
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by Jasper_ on Saturday October 30, 2021 @04:39AM (#29047131)
I'm not going to be alive in 2140 but I'd bet we won't have broken the laws of thermodynamics by either 2040 or 2140.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by JoyrexJ9 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:13AM (#29047871)
By 2140 humans no longer require food?
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by acheron on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:13AM (#29049397)
That seems soon. Other estimates say that won’t be true until the year 4545.

https://genius.com/Zager-and-evans-in-the-year-2525-lyrics

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by hansel_der on Saturday October 30, 2021 @07:45AM (#29048032)
sure they'll require sustenence but i highly doubt that our definition of food will apply
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by agumonkey on Saturday October 30, 2021 @06:28AM (#29047625)
quantum emergence
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by danaris on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:13AM (#29048496)
> The shape of the metaverse will be formed by a new generation

Even this begs the question.

Why do people take it as a given that there will be a "metaverse"?

I mean, personally, I think that a genuinely interoperable, decentralized VR/AR infrastructure would be pretty neat—I have no idea if it would solve any specific real-world problems, but "decentralized and interoperable" is a world better than the systems we've got in the current internet.

But...that's just the thing. Where's the incentive to make it genuinely interoperable and decentralized, especially for a company like Facebook? They want things to be under their control, so they can mine them for data and sell ads on them.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @11:51AM (#29049731)
The idea of a metaverse of some form or another falls out as a consequence of an assumption that there will be devices people wear that allow software to fully override their visual and auditory experience. These kinds of devices in their most rudimentary form have already arrived for experiences that do not incorporate the physical world (or other people in the physical world), but the ones that fully "close the loop" on physical reality being incorporated into the rendering pipeline will arrive in 2022.

There are no great incentives for Meta or whoever to make their vision of the metaverse align with the openness of the web or Internet, other than perhaps a desire by their leader to do something good for the world to cement his legacy. So this is why it is important smart people work on providing alternative visions, as oppose to writing off the entire thing while the future arrives and we're left subject to corporations because the nay-sayers didn't understand what was about to happen. (See also: the iPhone)

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by tsimionescu on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:15PM (#29051525)
> There are no great incentives for Meta or whoever to make their vision of the metaverse align with the openness of the web or Internet, other than perhaps a desire by their leader to do something good for the world to cement his legacy.

Wow, have you ever seen Mark Zuckerberg talking, or noticed any of his actions? To imagine he would drive Facebook to do something out of "a desire to do something good for the world to cement his legacy" is comically outside any realistic possibility.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by gfodor on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:52PM (#29051818)
I was talking about companies in general, and wasn’t suggesting these were likely possibilities for any of them.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by greggh on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:58AM (#29048795)
It does not beg the question. It raises the question.

Any form of argument where the conclusion is assumed in one of the premises. Many people use the phrase "begging the question" incorrectly when they use it to mean, "prompts one to ask the question". That is NOT the correct usage. Begging the question is a form of circular reasoning.

Logical Form:

Claim X assumes X is true.

Therefore, claim X is true.

Re:The metaverse is bullshit by sobellian on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:21AM (#29048980)
Parent used it correctly - "Why do people take it as a given that there will be a 'metaverse'?" He's arguing that these "people" are assuming their conclusion when they state that the metaverse will be shaped by a new generation.
Re:The metaverse is bullshit by poetaster on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:55PM (#29050256)
I write poems. I write music. I write code. I build books. I play songs. I compiled this client.