News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by supermatt on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:32AM (#29038157)
Facebook account will become meta account. Oculus will transition to meta account. There will be no difference.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by loeg on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:40AM (#29038250)
No, this would be an Oculus-specific account. There are enough legitimate criticisms of Facebook that we don't have to go around inventing false ones.

Edited to cite the announcement transcript[1]:

> And as we’ve focused more on work, and frankly, as we’ve heard your feedback more broadly, we’re on making it so you can log into Quest with an account other than your personal Facebook account.

> ... I know this is a big deal for a lot of people. Not everyone wants their social media profile linked to all these other experiences.

[1]: https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/meta-facebook-connect-2...

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by nixpulvis on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:04AM (#29038505)
Why the fuck do I need to log into my monitor?! it's bad enough the driver demands a running application which tries to sell me shit and pushes me into a place I don't want to be at all. It's literally hijacking my computer.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by playpause on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:15AM (#29038655)
The Oculus isn’t just a monitor, it’s a complete computer system with its own OS. If you just want a VR headset that is purely a monitor, buy one of those.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ryandrake on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:26AM (#29039589)
I agree with OP for regular wired Oculus devices. They are essentially monitors, and I wouldn't expect to have to have an account in order to use a dumb peripheral. For the Quest, you're right, it's more like a computer system with OS, apps, etc. I'd still rather be able to use it without an account, and only create an account if I wanted to interact with online services like apps and games.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by nixpulvis on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:36AM (#29039728)
Still! why must I log in to simply download an app!? Perhaps publishing an app is a more sensitive matter, then maybe it's worth validating things strictly behind closed doors... but to simply download and use software on a device I own, I can't fathom how we've slipped so far.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by vineyardmike on Monday November 01, 2021 @02:51PM (#29071169)
> Still! why must I log in to simply download an app!?

You have to pay them, they have to remember you paid them.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by eli on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:25AM (#29038803)
And an app store. It obviously needs some kind of login.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by arsome on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:31AM (#29038886)
I can use an Android or iOS devices without logging into their respective app stores easily, hopefully they allow similar on Oculus.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by eli on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:34AM (#29038916)
What would you do with it? Side load apps? The games in the app store are presumably the reason 99% of people buy it.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by gpm on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:44AM (#29039045)
On android - yes.

Specifically I would sideload fdroid, and then install (free) apps from there since it doesn't need a login.

Or maybe I'd (say, on windows) "sideload" steam, and install apps from there instead of from Oculus.

The idea that the only place I can get apps from is the "official" appstore is ridiculous.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by croes on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:53AM (#29039170)
This wouldn't change if it were a store account instead of a device account. Most people use google's play store but this doesn't mean every android device needs a mandatory google account.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by gregallan on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:44AM (#29039046)
Also MacOS and Windows have “App Stores” that you certainly don’t need to be logged into.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by gpm on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:47AM (#29039103)
The MacOS "App Store" (as in the thing they call the app store, rather than all the other ways you can pay for and install apps) does require you to login. Worse, they block updating the non-os software that came with your computer with logging into that app store.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by onion2k on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:29AM (#29038850)
Why the fuck do I need to log into my monitor?

Because you bought a system that only has apps from your monitor's app store available, and that means you have to prove who you are to use them.

It's no different to phones, consoles, etc.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by q3k on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:43AM (#29039036)
> It's no different to phones, consoles, etc.

You can use a Nintendo Switch or an Android phone without an online account.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by tgsovlerkhgsel on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:23PM (#29041882)
You can't install apps through "normal user" means on the Android phones I've had unless you add an account.

De facto, that means you need an account.

Yes, I know you can try to find copies of your banking apps on apkmirror and sideload, but... no. (Also, wouldn't that mean that you have to manually confirm every single app update, so a 10-minute button pushing session every week?)

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by tl on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:34PM (#29041269)
Not really. Nintendo eShop and Google Play Service will dark pattern you towards having an account in cases where they don't outright require it like DLC expansions to the "physical" cartridge you "bought".
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by croes on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:45AM (#29039086)
You can use via Link with a PC or side load apps, so Oculus apps aren't needed. Since when is it ok that I need an third party account to access my computer?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by nixpulvis on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:57AM (#29039215)
False, I purchased a VR headset to use with Steam VR (mostly), but I fully expected it to work in a standard way, with understanding to the variations in the handheld controllers.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by filoleg on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:56PM (#29042249)
> Because you bought a system that only has apps from your monitor's app store available, and that means you have to prove who you are to use them.

Blatantly false. You can either play Oculus games (must, if you are playing without PC; basically the app store) or you can connect to PC and play any SteamVR games just like you would with any other headset (supported officially).

So with Quest 2, I get to play both the Oculus-only standalone games made for the headset specifically, as well as any SteamVR games that my friends with other VR headsets might want to play together.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by smoldesu on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:09AM (#29039390)
This is the iPhone-ized future we signed up for!
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by jensensbutton on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:08AM (#29038549)
You log into an ipad. What's the difference?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by nixpulvis on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:10AM (#29038595)
I do not own an iPad. Also... do you really have to? I haven't used an iOS in a little bit now.

Apple is hardly the model for technology we should be using these days. Their walled garden has rotten fruit and it doesn't even get you drunk, you simply fall ill.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by modeless on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:45AM (#29039081)
You have to if you want to install any software. Even free apps from the app store. No side loading allowed.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:16AM (#29038668)
I don't own an iPad, but I flashed my tablet with an Android Open Source Project ROM so that I have the option to not send data to anybody I don't want to.

Is Facebook planning to let us do this? Or are they just changing the brand logo on the login page for their required login?

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ootsootsoots on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:26AM (#29038805)
I use a pin code or thumbprint to unlock my iPad and login to Apples store

I can root it and install alternative store

What alternative software can I run on Occulus?

That and all the extra engineering for managing users for business reasons not technical wastes real resources to prop up a technology company that isn’t interested in novel discovery, but servicing contemporary business obligations

If they’re so smart and capable of pulling useful metadata off unstructured data, why do they need me to maintain a specific profile?

Really kind of feels like they rely on having concrete data and the meta part is marketing

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by BbzzbB on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:51AM (#29039147)
You realize iOS roots are developed by third-party geeks and void your warranty (unless that changed in the years since I've interacted with iOS, but I'd be shocked)? Maybe we should indeed force hardware manufacturers to offer a rooting/open OS option by default, but it's a weird criticism when you start off the comment by licking Apple's boot. Further, Facebook actually does offer to open up your deprecated Oculus Go headset now that they are done with the 2 years of guaranteed support to its devs. As such, people can keep tinkering and keeping it up to date (Carmack's opening remarks yesterday address this) with the help of Facebook. That puts them quite objectively ahead of Apple in this regard, the company which was fined in court [1] for draining older iPhone's batteries and slowing them down thru software updates.

Guaranteed all these people in this thread wouldn't be losing their shit over a hardware account if it wasn't from Facebook's holdco. Forcing a Facebook account was creepy, a dedicated Oculus (well, Meta) account is normal and defensible.

[1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/19/tech/apple-battery-settlement...

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by jensensbutton on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:15PM (#29041039)
> I can root it and install alternative store

Well if you can root an Oculus you can do whatever you want there as well. That's the whole point of... root.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by micromacrofoot on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:11AM (#29038605)
A massive network of cross-site tracking and a terrible track record for protecting personal information.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by evilduck on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:28AM (#29038828)
I mean, thats a complete lie. Got anything else?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by jensensbutton on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:15PM (#29041026)
Oh? The overwhelming majority of people don't log into Apple accounts when setting up their ipads?

Do better.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:24PM (#29041131)
Heya, I noticed that, in responding, you switched your premise from, "You log into an ipad", to, 'The overwhelming majority of people log into their apple accounts when setting up their ipads'.

Since this is disingenuous on your part, telling the person you responded to, to "do better" seems hypocritical.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by jensensbutton on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:30PM (#29041963)
I wonder who you think I meant by "you"? Did you assume I specifically know the parent in person and how they use their ipad at home? If so, and I can only assume you did otherwise your comment would be nonsense, I can see how that would be confusing and seem disingenuous to you.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:30PM (#29043219)
If you're suggesting that by "you", you meant "The overwhelming majority of people who set up ipads", that doesn't sound like a very credible retroactive explanation.

Like, it's confusing for sure, but not on the part of the reader. It doesn't even make sense. Most people don't even _have_ ipads.

And even if they did, you're basically saying, "this small subset of self-selecting people who are okay with their tablet requiring a login to work, are okay with their devices requiring a login to work", which isn't very convincing to others, either.

And even if _that_ made sense, 'these other people are okay with it' is probably one of the weakest possible arguments in favor of /anything/.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by jensensbutton on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:34PM (#29044284)
> this small subset of self-selecting people who are okay with their tablet requiring a login to work, are okay with their devices requiring a login to work

I'll go ahead and assume English isn't your first language. I was saying the vast majority of people who own ipads are fine with needing to login to an account to get the most out of it. Doesn't seem like a particularly controversial statement.

Now go ahead and find some way in which the above sentence is technically incorrect, but you're starting to look silly.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @07:28PM (#29044634)
How does the statement "the vast majority of people who own ipads are fine with needing to log into their device" convince those who do not, and are not?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by evilduck on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:25PM (#29044224)
You can just click the skip button and use an iOS device without any account. Whether or not people want to do this is an entirely different conversation but Apple does not require it.

You do better and stop moving the goalposts and lying.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by bananabreakfast on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:40AM (#29038993)
That's silly, you don't.

An oculus is not a monitor, it's an entire game console that includes a screen. Are you this incredulous about having to log in to an iPad or a Switch?

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by SantalBlush on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:26PM (#29040391)
Yes, there was a time when we didn't need accounts for every piece of hardware we use.

It is a fact of life that companies will impose more and more profit-maximizing inconveniences upon the customer as long as the customer is willing to accept them. It only stops when enough customers push back.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by pseudalopex on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:42AM (#29039024)
Yes.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by iforgetti on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:44AM (#29039050)
Does Meta provide a guarantee that data won’t be unified between Facebook and Oculus accounts ever? If not, what is the value of this distinction beyond PR?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by micromacrofoot on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:22AM (#29038752)
Oculus no longer exists. It's Meta, which is The Facebook company.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by CharlesW on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:56AM (#29039209)
And just to add a bit more color, Oculus-the-subsidiary became Oculus-the-brand in Sep 2018.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by Closi on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:14PM (#29040246)
> No, this would be an Oculus-specific account.

Hmm, the statements you posted don’t quite say that.

I guess it’s still possible that users could be required to register a “meta” account which is separate to your personal Facebook account, although you can sign into your personal Facebook account with your meta account via single sign on. I think this would technically meet their wording while also not fulfilling the spirit of what everyone wants.

For instance, you can have a Google account that isn’t linked to your personal Gmail account, because not everyone wants their search history linked to their email - just change Google to Meta, Gmail to Facebook and search history to social media.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by AlexandrB on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:08PM (#29040185)
> No, this would be an Oculus-specific account.

This is not stated anywhere. I don't see why Facebook couldn't create a Meta SSO that you can use for Facebook and/or Oculus and call it "job done". For them it's a win/win. Most people would choose to "migrate" their Facebook login to Meta. Those annoyed by this could just create a Meta account. Notably there's no mention of whether you'll need to use your real name for logging into Oculus as you do with Facebook. My bet is: probably.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:13AM (#29038626)
Would Facebook be physically prevented from ever accessing or linking to data on the Metafacebookulus account, ad vice versa?

If not, sounds like a Facebook account by another name.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by micromacrofoot on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:25AM (#29038793)
It's literally the same company, why would it be prevented?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by long_time_gone on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:32AM (#29038889)
Because of the security and risk implication of not preventing it. Goldman Sachs is both an investment bank and an asset management firm, literally the same company. However, they have clear protocols in place to separate the two sides because otherwise the opportunities for impropriety are too high. I could see a similar argument for separating Facebook and Oculus accounts.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by micromacrofoot on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:40AM (#29038988)
Sure, but Goldman Sachs business model isn't aggregating and selling data. Facebook's is.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:47AM (#29039117)
The fact that the two components of an analogy are not the same thing is the point of the analogy. If they were the same thing, the analogy would be useless.

In this specific analogy, the point is, despite having different business models, society benefits from either conglomerate separating their respective two aforementioned business units.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by long_time_gone on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:12AM (#29039416)
No, their businesses are managing money and taking companies public. They're overall revenue would benefit from aligning those businesses, but they aren't allowed to. They are kept separate because of the risks of having them together. The Facebook scenario is a different (but comparable) situation.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:29AM (#29038861)
Exactly, so an "Oculus-specific account" would not actually be an account specific to Oculus, it would be a differently-branded Facebook account, too
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by croes on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:43AM (#29039031)
That's FB's claim at the moment and after so many tricks and lies by FB I'm pessimistic. Their contract excuse to circumvent the GDPR does not make them credible.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by darrenf on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:11AM (#29038613)
UploadVR asked Andrew Bosworth directly. https://uploadvr.com/quest-2-unlinking-facebook-accounts/

Quote: We asked Bosworth directly if we could unlink and delete our Facebook accounts from Quest and still keep our software purchases, to which he simply replied: “Yup”.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by 2Gkashmiri on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:35AM (#29038926)
Plot twist. When you delete your fb account, your identity is switched to your shadow profile and any account you subsequently link to your oculus is linked to that shadow profile
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by bni on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:15AM (#29039453)
I have an Oculus account with some games that I have never connected to Facebook despite multiple reminders to do so.

Wonder what will happen to it.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by Shish2k on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:40AM (#29038257)
I’d assume this is the case, but is there actually any evidence either way, or are we all just speculating?
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by loeg on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:43AM (#29038295)
Transcript[1]:

> And as we’ve focused more on work, and frankly, as we’ve heard your feedback more broadly, we’re on making it so you can log into Quest with an account other than your personal Facebook account.

> ... I know this is a big deal for a lot of people. Not everyone wants their social media profile linked to all these other experiences.

To me this strongly suggests that it is a separate account, and is not required to be linked to a Facebook account.

[1]: https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/meta-facebook-connect-2...

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by piva00 on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:48AM (#29038337)
I'd love if they clarified if not being directly linked to a Facebook account would mean it's not being harvested and shadow profiling the user to end up linking to whatever is their definition of a "person" in their ad systems.

This corporate-speak makes me very cynical and I hate it but given FB's history I would like a completely clear statement that data harvested from Oculus is not immediately linked to an identity of myself in some system of the FB colossus.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by krinchan on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:08AM (#29039368)
I think the other key feature they’re angling for is suspension or banning of a Facebook account for whatever reason will no longer cost you your entire Oculus library.

It’s a very long standing problem. Many people created new Facebook accounts just for Oculus, bought maybe $80-$100 worth of games, and then got their Facebook account banned[*]. There is pretty much no recourse but to whine on the Oculus subreddit till the community rep escalated them past tier 1 support. Even then, the result would be “We’ve refunded your purchases please use your actual Facebook account.”

It’s probably gotten bad with charge backs and returned headsets that they’re finally doing something about it.

[*]: The common speculation is that this would trip a similar heuristic to “Egg Accounts” on Twitter and would be banned without recourse because that particular piece of Facebook’s automation didn’t have visibility into the Oculus-side purchase activity. The assumption by Facebook being the account didn’t have any content so if it was an actual human they’d just create a new account.

Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by micromacrofoot on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:14AM (#29038649)
Unless it's part of some legally binding document I wouldn't trust it anyway. Despite the name change they're still Facebook. Data harvesting is their business.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by Uberphallus on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:01AM (#29038470)
Without giving much detail, where I work many accounts from different businesses aren't linked... in customer facing systems. But internally everything is linked, and well linked (for good reasons). FB will profile you even more even though you can use a different email.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by blitzar on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:59AM (#29038443)
I am speculating here - but it looks a whole lot like a move to head off anti trust
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by BbzzbB on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:01AM (#29039270)
It looks like a company that's been talking about this direction for ~6 years already which decided to precipitate the rebranded holdco (and maybe speed of R&D/capex) in light of recent controversies. Bit of this, bit of that.
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by YetAnotherNick on Friday October 29, 2021 @10:33AM (#29038903)
Umm, what again is the criticism for crating meta account vs creating oculus account(without fb)? I think at this point whatever fb does it will be criticised?
[dead]
Re:Oculus Quest is removing the Facebook account requirement by lexpar on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:38AM (#29039766)
This is really not a high quality comment.