News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:26PM (#29034841)
Out of curiosity, what makes this hard to follow?

When I click on the link, I get taken to a page on twitter.com that shows me a post, in normal linear order. It reads to me like ordinary English text, in the order you ordinarily read or write it in. The text is not interrupted, except by the little "replies / retweets / likes / share" bar that appears after every tweet.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by notreallyserio on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:48PM (#29034948)
I’m just not used to reading multiple paragraphs of text with large gaps populated with junk between each sentence.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:46AM (#29035258)
Isn’t that what the HN comment section is like, though? Or maybe I’m just used to reading things like design documents at work (with tons of comments), or standards documents (with footnotes that take up more space than the page body).
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by notreallyserio on Friday October 29, 2021 @07:13AM (#29037226)
HN threads are more likely to have multiple sentence paragraphs in a single comment and replies are nested N levels deep. The UI between each reply is minimal (aka not tuned for “engagement” KPIs) and is almost too subtle.

Also, replies to tweets within one of these multiple-tweet posts are hard to even get to, and I genuinely cannot figure out why Twitter used that design. It can’t help engagement.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by abdulmuhaimin on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:32PM (#29034875)
let me rephrase your word, but negatively. The text is interrupted by the space-wasting "replies / retweets / likes / share" bar that appears after every tweet.

Not to mention that on the desktop, the text is literally only quarter of the screen. Add that to the very frequent interrption bars, you are in for a very long scroll while reading

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:39PM (#29034902)
> Not to mention that on the desktop, the text is literally only quarter of the screen.

A quarter of the width? Well, naturally! The optimal line length for readability is somewhere in the 50-100 character range. This is one of those things that is actually backed by empirical research (lots of research... experiments in readability are cheap and easy to conduct, and people have been doing these experiments for a long time). The width of lines of text in tweets is on the shorter end of that range.

Hacker News, for example, is an example of a site with poor readability. The text is as wide as the window. To address this deficiency, I open Hacker News in a narrower window. It's still harder to read.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by readflaggedcomm on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:22AM (#29035150)
Now assume your and Twitter's research is wrong. How do I make it readable?

Not with CSS, their markup is impenetrable. You have to have another site scrape and reformat the content. Shameful.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:42AM (#29035243)
Why would I assume that the research is wrong? We’re talking about a century’s worth of readability research, here. Cheap, easy-to-replicate studies which have been done over and over again over the decades. Backed by simple-to-explain theories that explain why. Seems like a completely unreasonable assumption, to be frank.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by kbenson on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:27AM (#29035461)
> Why would I assume that the research is wrong?

Because it's highly that even if it's correct in aggregate, there will be outliers that the opposite is true, and they'll benefit from different formatting.

That is, even if it's right, it might still be wrong for them. So the question being asked is, why is it made so hard to change?

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by aseipp on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:45AM (#29036561)
The context of the thread here wasn't about people with different visual abilities or anything complaining about the fact they're being left behind by Twitter's UX team, it was literally someone asking "Why do you think this is unreadable", some whining that "The text only uses a quarter of the screen", which was responded to with "A century of readability research has shown that's pretty good idea, actually!", which is a literal fact. This is very easy to understand and it isn't remotely computer-centric -- imagine a book where the "margins" didn't exist in any form and words just filled the page from edge to edge. It's not some random thing these basic margin rules also came to computers, and it's not some UX fad; you only need to ask what the difference is between a 1998 CRT and a 2021 4k screen to see why.

Like, you're talking about "what's right for them" as if that's supposed to pull my heartstrings, but the grandparent even literally said "I am going to re-phrase your question negatively", it's not like they're going to magically be convinced or actually argue about any readability metrics in any kind good faith, it's literally just a reflex. I wouldn't waste my time defending it on some egalitarian principles or whatever.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by abdulmuhaimin on Monday November 01, 2021 @05:51AM (#29064700)
Dont get me wrong, twitter UX is great for what it is, for tweets. Because theyre at most 280 character length. A blog/essay is a different story
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by readflaggedcomm on Saturday October 30, 2021 @02:05AM (#29046385)
My hatred of Twitter's layout is not principled, I assure you. It's purely aesthetic and visceral.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by mrec on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:31AM (#29035192)
> The text is as wide as the window

Only on a small screen. An HN `div.comment` has a `max-width: 1215px;` rule.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:44AM (#29035251)
Ah, well I typically don’t have super wide windows, because it has a negative impact on readability. The difference between 1215px and higher widths isn’t really significant anyway… above a certain line length, readability has already reached its minimum and doesn’t decrease further as the lines get longer.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by lostlogin on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:19AM (#29035131)
> what makes this hard to follow?

Short of interspaced adverts or popovers, what could be done to make it worse?

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:39AM (#29035229)
What a wonderful non-answer. “I think the answer to your question is obvious, so I will not answer it, and just give a sarcastic reply.” But, I’ll still answer your question about what could make it worse…

It could have super-wide text, like Hacker News. That would make it worse. The line length is a fairly comfortable length, unlike Hacker News’s dizzying long lines.

It could have unusual scrolling behavior, like those Apple product announcements. That would make it worse.

You’ve mentioned the biggest thing that makes websites worse—interspaced adverts and popups, which are downright ubiquitous now. Nearly every site I visit has those.

Honestly, it seems very easy to read for me.

Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by lostlogin on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:27AM (#29036130)
Apologies - there was no sarcasm intended. I am dismissive of the twitter format for this content as I don’t like that something that seems suited to a blog post is split into dozens of short snippets with reactions, likes etc beneath. It is rare I make it though them as the format seems designed to be skimmed and skipped and I vastly prefer the HN format with more text, longer lines and a limited amount of cruft. I primarily use HN on mobile.
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by nightski on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:28PM (#29034849)
For me it is the same, very easy to follow. But then I remembered you can hit the "star" icon in the top to change your feed to chronological - which I had already done. Maybe that is why it is easier for us?
Re:The M1 Max is the fastest GPU we have ever measured in Af... by klodolph on Thursday October 28, 2021 @11:44PM (#29034926)
This is a link to the thread, so it should present the material in ordinary "threaded" order, no matter how you view it (there shouldn't be any buttons to change the order).