One of the founders of WhatsApp donated $50M to Signal [1] out of regret for how WhatsApp shifted away from privacy after being acquired by Facebook.
The entire project is freely visible to anyone on github [2]. They've made it so even if you don't trust their servers, you can set up your own server and clone your own android/ios app, change some settings and have everything hosted yourself.
There's no reason not to expect Signal to maintain the focus on privacy that they've put in thus far.
[0] https://www.signal.org/ [1] https://www.wired.com/story/signal-foundation-whatsapp-brian... [2] https://github.com/signalapp
If your life depended on it, you would be foolish to depend solely on Signal.
How nice it is that encryption has emerged from the dark corners of life and death to become a fashion accessory. But for those that still exist in the world beyond fashion, your criticism seems naive.
> Security and convenience are almost always in conflict
I think this is less true than people tend to think. See e.g. Signal/WhatApp rolling out relatively seamless E2EE to billions of people -- that was hard to imagine just a few decades ago!
So you should have an encrypted message that you hand to Signal. Signal encrypts it again and hands it to the bridge. Eventually, whether at the bridge or at the other end or wherever, something decrypts the Signal message. Then the person you are communicating with applies the final decryption outside of Signal, Matrix, or whatever.
If this sounds terribly inconvenient to you, perhaps privacy is not as important as you claim. Security and convenience are almost always in conflict.