News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by arianvanp on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:47AM (#28998688)
The fact that content sent to signal and Whatsapp resides unencrypted at the matrix homeserver makes this product completely useless to me.

I don't think I want to sacrifice the security for having all my chats in one place.

If they can fix that I might reconsider.

They already reverse engineered the Whatsapp protocol. I see little reason why it can't live in the client? I don't really follow why they move the bridge to the homeserver.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by liotier on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:08AM (#28998838)
> They already reverse engineered the Whatsapp protocol. I see little reason why it can't live in the client ?

Because Whatsapp crushes any client other than their official client. Everyone else is confined to scraping Whatsapp Web.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by kjaftaedi on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @04:14PM (#29005694)
At least it's better than getting zero-clicked.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by miguelrochefort on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:04AM (#28998805)
> They already reverse engineered the Whatsapp protocol. I see little reason why it can't live in the client? I don't really follow why they move the bridge to the homeserver.

Matrix bridges are rather complex. They rely on a combination of private APIs (WhatsApp), Chrome extension scraping (LINE), bots (Telegram), mobile clients (Android SMS), and jailbroken iPhones (iMessage).

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by have_faith on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:11AM (#28998854)
This is all very interesting from a technological perspective but it sounds incredible brittle. Do I break any terms with these 3rd parties by paying Matrix to scrape them?
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by miguelrochefort on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @08:46AM (#28999706)
I've been using Beeper.com for a while and it's surprisingly stable despite how brittle one would expect these bridges to be.

Given that puppeteering should be indistinguishable from real application usage and that $5/month/user should be more than enough to diversify IP addresses, I suspect the model can actually be sustainable in the long term.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by ev1 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:43PM (#29009303)
I'm kind of curious how Beeper will handle some of these - they claim to soon support WeChat, and emulating WeChat is a bit insane, because it collects so much data that it's a walking GDPR violation, there's no way to stop it, and we are talking things like "please repeat the numbers in chinese, then english, while looking straight into your phone" at login.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by spurgu on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:38PM (#29021725)
Uff, that sounds insane. I suppose they released those "features" gradually and people just went along.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by ev1 on Thursday October 28, 2021 @01:53AM (#29022841)
It's a Chinese chat app (that is also used for payments, thus linked to bank accounts). Getting an account more or less requires ID or similar. They go to extraordinary lengths, similar to Tiktok, to block automation, bot accounts, etc.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by ev1 on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @11:29PM (#29009245)
No one knows about detection or enforcement, but almost certainly yes.
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by radicalbyte on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:02AM (#28998793)
WhatsApp's backups are already stored unencrypted* on Google Drive if you use that feature.

* Encrypted with a private key which Google have access to.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by bogwog on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:11AM (#28999936)
So the encryption is there so that you can't access your own data (and migrate to a competing app/service), rather than to protect your privacy. I kind of ran into this issue myself when I was helping a family member move to iPhone. Since Whatsapp uses Drive on Android and iCloud on iOS, there was no way to transfer the data.

I wonder if you can get them via one of those data access requests?

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by kirimita on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:16AM (#28998889)
Data does not _reside_ unencrypted with End to Bridge Encryption : https://docs.mau.fi/bridges/general/end-to-bridge-encryption...
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by arianvanp on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:20AM (#29000035)
But the bridge is not hosted by me but by them. I need to trust matrix not to MITM me
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by tremon on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @10:47AM (#29001082)
Yes, in the same way that you need to trust Whatsapp not to MITM you. What's your perceived difference between these trust levels, other than one is something you pay for with money, and the other doesn't require money?
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by axelthegerman on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:25AM (#29010774)
THIS "in the same way that you need to trust Whatsapp not to MITM"

And on top of that Google or Apple or whoever you "trust" with your mobile operating system of choice.

Speaking of mobile OS, Element will likely run fine on mobile Linux whereas you can be sure Whatsapp will never release a Linux client

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by grassjumper on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @02:41PM (#29004470)
The Signal protocol (which WhatsApp still uses, I presume) is very good. WhatsApp can't MITM it.

Element, on the other hand, is MITM by design.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by chayleaf on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:04AM (#28998806)
they haven't, they simply host a VM with Whatsapp and connect to it via Whatsapp Web
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by iforgotpassword on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:53AM (#28998715)
Why don't you encrypt your hard drive?
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by krageon on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @06:55AM (#28998734)
What problem do you feel this would solve?
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by arianvanp on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:14AM (#28998876)
I don't follow. What does my hard drive have to do with plaintext messages on Element's servers?
Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by iforgotpassword on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @09:15AM (#28999984)
Aj, my bad. I skimmed over the part where it says they are hosting the bridge for you. Since matrix is focused on privacy etc I assumed this is available as a container/VM I can run at home or on a VPS.

Indeed then very weird why I should trust them more with my personal data than anybody else.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by IceWreck on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @03:03PM (#29004771)
> Since matrix is focused on privacy etc I assumed this is available as a container/VM I can run at home or on a VPS.

All bridges, and the matrix homeserver itself have been open source and self-hostable for years. I host a homeserver + some bridges myself.

This is just the sugar-coated SaaS for people who dont want to do it themselves.

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by KoftaBob on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:41AM (#29010845)
> Since matrix is focused on privacy etc I assumed this is available as a container/VM I can run at home or on a VPS.

It is! https://matrix.org/bridges/

Re:Element One – All of Matrix, WhatsApp, Signal and Telegra... by square_usual on Tuesday October 26, 2021 @07:21AM (#28998946)
As far as I can tell, the messages don't live in plaintext on Element's servers - they are bridged in plaintext to Matrix, which is end to end encrypted.