A contractual sales commitment is valued differently compared to a "what if" calculation.
Re:Tesla shares surpass $1T in value
by missedthecue on Monday October 25, 2021 @05:20PM
(#28993292)
As far as I can tell, there is no contractual sales commitment. Just a press release.
Except your average market participant doesn't have the same resources for that analysis as Herz.
Many of them have more resources. Hedge funds have been using satellite photography to estimate Tesla's production numbers for years. The price is expected to move if even a few participants have the new information.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20243810
Honestly I'm a little dumbfounded that people are arguing this is definitely a rational move in the price while we've got phenomena like GameStop still happening.
Any market participant could _already_ have gone through the same calculus. There is no new public information except the decision itself, which by this reasoning was A) perfectly predictable and B) not inherently worth $100B