Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf]
by ehnto on Monday October 25, 2021 @12:05AM
(#28984413)
Technically not sharing your user data, I would suggest that in practical terms it is selling the use of your personal data. It's a nuance that may not matter in the publics eyes, which I frankly agree with.
So if we may agree that it is exploitive but not technically illegal, then I think we can reason that we are the edge of what is right to do and it's time to consider how to make the exploitive thing illegal.
Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf]
by waterloosong on Monday October 25, 2021 @10:37AM
(#28988296)
The writer of the doc sports a quill of unbearable lightness: it is very much an Orwellian thing, to stretch selling something to include using the knowledge of that thing in marketing something else.
Disagree with the claim here. Certainly, Google is utilizing your personal information against you, but:
1. That's certainly not selling your personal info.
2. To make this argument, US states must concede that active commercial advertising has an aspect of harm and manipulation. I doubt any of them are actually willing to go ahead and adopt that position consistently.
Having said that... when we read Google's claim that
> it will “never sell your personal information to anyone”
let's also not forget that it's quite willing to give it for free to the US government, in bulk and forever.