News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

waterloosong

Who wouldn't.

This is a second price auction that we speak of. Every ad company is polled to send no more than two bids. Naturally those would be the two highest bids from thousands that they handle. So let's say that Google first and second bids are G1 and G2, Facebook F1, and F2, some other company C1 and C2 and so on. So if those bids are sorted in descending order it may look like, for example,

  A1 > B1 > A2 > C1 > B2 > C2 > ...
In this example, the ad belonging to A1 gets served, the price is the value of bid B1.

That's why it is called "second price" auction. If it was a first price auction, the A1 advertiser would pay A1 bid price, and could save some money by bidding slightly lower, but still more than B1. Neither of these companies know up-front what the other bid will be, but with a second price auction there is no need for it, the A1 advertiser pays the amount of B1 bid.

Same goes for bids G1 and G2, they don't know what other bids will be. It could end up like this:

  G1 > G2 > C1 > ...
From time to time Google overhauls their AI. Let's say for simplicity that the two highest bids from Google are the same ads, the new bid for G1 is G'1 and the new bid for G2 is G'2. Though it could change who wins the auction, for instance if it ends up like this

  G'2 > G'1 > C1 > ...
or C1 > G'1 > G'2 > ...

Or it could change only what the price is, for example if it ends up like this, the price will lower from G2 to C1

  G'1 > C1 > G'2 > ...
Or if there is some minimum bid value Z required by publisher and it it would be G'1 > C1 > Z > G'2, it would be only G'1 that is passed to the auction. "Google allegedly dropped the second-highest bids from publishers' auctions".

The "inflate only the bids belonging advertisers who used the company's Google Ads" is a mixture of G'1 > G'2 > G2 > ... and G'1 > C1 > G1 > ... and that sort of stuff

There is no accumulating money in a pool, keeping it to spending later on something; there is a need for balancing the two effects above, so that the overhaul won't go overboard either way.

The case of C1 > G'1 > G1 > ... is missing from the Reuters snippet. If it is in the lawsuit, it would end up as "secretly forcing the advertisers who used competing ad network to pay more", I guess

fair enough, reverse engineering media reporting on legal documents can be tricky

You need to realize just one more thing: to ensure that there is no peeking into bids of other networks, the actual code of the auction could be executed on a remote server. But only a naive implementation would ask every ad network client to send all their ad bids to the server; on the other hand having ad networks send only the highest bid would not be enough for a second-price auction...

A good introduction to that topic is About Enhanced CPC: https://support.google.com/google-ads/answer/2464964

"ECPC works by automatically adjusting your manual bids for clicks that seem more or less likely to lead to a sale or conversion on your website"

Of course, it is based on historical data

But you end up having a quite complicated code calculating the auction bid.

I doubt that you could code it easily based on a cursory reading of the About Enhanced CPC page.

Even more futile is guessing what specific details of that code function that project Bernanke optimized, if your only source is the lawsuit doc and newspapers relating it

Re:Truths about video game stories on Monday November 01, 2021 @07:14PM (#29074549)
I am wary of this kind of casual reduction of videogame plots to one-sentence summaries that is all frequent in online discussions. For all I know, the plot of Grim Fandango could be said to be "you're the chosen undead, and you must quest for some items" and Grim Fandango story is one of the best.

There's probably not so much of Grim Fandango story in Dark Souls, given there is not so many friendlies in the latter. If anything, I would compare it to System Shock 2, but in fantasy genre rather than sf. The story of System Shock 2 was fine, though maybe not that famous because Half-Life beat it to market.

Obviously those are examples from 90's and there is always the question about modern games; AAA as well as those made on lesser budgets. Funny the author of the blog roasts titles such as Firewatch and Spec Ops: Dubai.

Re:Truths about video game stories on Sunday October 31, 2021 @09:23PM (#29062153)
This is Jeff Vogel's blog.
Re:Alphabet Third Quarter 2021 Results [pdf] on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:29AM (#29013748)
I think you are missing the big picture in the details.

For the long-term growth is constrained by the sum of all campaign budgets, and those budgets are set by advertisers themselves.

What the company needs to do is to keep advertisers happy enough to have them increase the budgets, and also prevent the software engineers from breaking the system with bugs enough that the advertisers would walk away.

Re:Google digital advertising antitrust litigation [pdf] on Monday October 25, 2021 @10:37AM (#28988296)
The writer of the doc sports a quill of unbearable lightness: it is very much an Orwellian thing, to stretch selling something to include using the knowledge of that thing in marketing something else.