News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by pg_bot on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @11:35PM (#28926450)
Isn't this just a trade off? Is there never a scenario where you would trade transistor density for switching speed and lower power consumption?
Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by dogber1 on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @12:22AM (#28926727)
That's indeed done all the time in electronics: for example, RF CMOS usually trailing on a node three or four generations behind the bleeding edge.

However, all-optical/photonic computing is just intrinsically so much worse than electronics. On top of the issues that I touched on, there are also other fundamental problems, e.g. distribution of power: photons like to get absorbed by nearby electrons. How do you then supply all the active devices (switches/lasers/etc.) with power while maintaining some semblance of signal integrity and dense integration?

Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by jacquesm on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @05:19AM (#28928540)
There is a special case: pumped laser amplification of signal in underwater fiber optic cables. That's all optical for the signal path as far as I know.

https://www.laserfocusworld.com/fiber-optics/article/1655109...

Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by singularity2001 on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @02:43AM (#28927530)
Could nonlinear wave interactions be applied in near vacuum, isolated from the lasers, amplifiers and counters? Think 100000*100000 imprecise loss-full tensor/matrix multiplications.
Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by singularity2001 on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @02:39AM (#28927487)
Exactly. While this speed vs space trade off makes less sense in mobiles, it might make perfect sense in industrial settings. Imagine 3D computers the size of a room (Craigh 2) but a 1000 times faster than any TPU only cluster.
Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by ajuc on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @03:33AM (#28927825)
If you can trade single-core speed for parallelism cluster of traditional electronics make more sense, but for some algorithms you can't.

Imagine a CPU with the complexity of Arduino but running at 100 GHz.

Re:New Optical Switch Up to 1000x Faster Than Transistors by dumbfoundded on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @12:00AM (#28926601)
Yes. IIRC, amd chips have been beating intel chips for a while now on transistor sizes but intel even with larger transistors still have a greater density on a chip (maybe it's changed in the latest gen).

Another benefit of lower density is cooling.