News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by echelon on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:12PM (#28924430)
I miss Michael Crichton. His writing and imagination reinforced my interest in science and engineering and got me interested in studying biochem in undergrad. I should not have been reading his books in the third grade, but it was a defining period for me.

The 90's were great. Michael Crichton, Bill Nye, Carl Sagan, LeVar Burton, Mr. Wizard, Stephen Hawking, Lonnie Johnson (local engineer and inventor of Nerf and Super Soaker). We were also fresh off the 80's wave of sci-fi with Aliens, RoboCop, Terminator, etc. The future always felt like it was going to have infinite potential.

It's probably even better for kids now with YouTube. Derek Muller, et al. are killing it.

Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by AlexCoventry on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:38PM (#28924632)
Crichton gave a lot of cover to climate-change denialism, though, speaking of Murray-Gellman effects.
Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by jimmygrapes on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:57PM (#28924782)
Less denialism than caution against jumping to conclusions and "consensus". He understood that to base society off of models with phenomenally low confidence has the potential to harm more than help, despite any good intentions.
Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by paulmd on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @08:34PM (#28925472)
Of course, which is why there isn't "one" model, there's lots of models, and they provide a statistical range of expected possibilities. And of course Crichton knows that damned well himself.

Applying impossibly high (or inappropriately high) standards of proof is a bog-standard rhetorical tactic - "how can we ever know anything with total certainty after all?". And yet the effects predicted by the consensus models have if anything proved to be too conservative, a possibility that the ever-so-open-minded Crichton never mentioned at all! Certainly that was always a possibility too, and yet he only cared to harp on the one possibility that was most comfortable to his mindset. And that's a kind of bias too - the willingness to dismiss presented evidence when it's inconvenient personally or politically.

As they say, though, science advances one funeral at a time. It's just rather sad that it occurred at such a critical time in our planet's history, and that this particular individual had a megaphone and yet used it for such negative ends.

Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by AlexCoventry on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @09:47PM (#28925898)
It's crazy to characterize those models as "phenomenally low confidence," and it seems at this stage that that ignorance is highly likely to get a lot of people killed. It was basic physical chemistry.

https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/michael-crichton-and-glob...

Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by 1cvmask on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:20PM (#28924499)
I had to look up who Derek Muller is.
Re:Gell-Mann amnesia and its opposite by MetricExpansion on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:59PM (#28924802)
He’s actually a person to whom I applied the “opposite” of the Gell Mann effect to. I first watched his videos on the stuff I did know something about to make sure he was covering the nuances before watching his other material. Now I watch his other videos on things I don’t know about, trusting that he’ll cover the nuances of those subjects.