Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by wmf on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:48PM
(#28924208)
Also not a lawyer, but can't you sue in California over any product sold in California?
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by perihelions on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @06:45PM
(#28924694)
I believe a non-California defendant could move that suit into a federal court ("diversity jurisdiction" isn't it?)
But federal courts don't seem to put too much weight on how individual states interpreted a law -- hence my question.
(Same /not-a-lawyer as above)
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by User23 on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:03PM
(#28925978)
If you have the money for lawyers you could always Thiel yourself a suitable plaintiff.
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by jfrunyon on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @05:59PM
(#28924320)
Sure, if you live in California. (I think IANAL is a given because I don't think any lawyer is giving out legal advice on HN)
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by boomboomsubban on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @09:55PM
(#28925943)
The Software Freedom Conservancy is based out of New York, and they are the plaintiffs here.
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by jfrunyon on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:04PM
(#28925986)
... and your point is?
The Software Freedom Conservancy is a business which can do business in many states and be subject to the jurisdiction of courts in all of them, unlike an individual, who can be resident in only one state. (And even then, an individual could also sue in California if the event being sued over - like a purchase or an accident - occurred in California)
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by boomboomsubban on Tuesday October 19, 2021 @10:30PM
(#28926115)
Being a resident isn't really a requirement if at most all you need to do to bypass it is form a company anywhere.
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by pabs3 on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @12:58AM
(#28926918)
nitpick: the Software Freedom Conservancy is a charity, not a business.
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by jfrunyon on Thursday October 21, 2021 @12:22PM
(#28946788)
Charities are a form of business. I didn't say they were for-profit.
Re:Software Freedom Conservancy files GPL lawsuit against Vizio
by staticautomatic on Wednesday October 20, 2021 @12:16AM
(#28926687)
Presumably the suit is federal because it’s a copyright case. So, yeah, it would have some significance within the 9th circuit until the appeals shake out.
Would such a decision have any usefulness outside of California? This specific lawsuit is filed in a California state court, against a California defendant.
/not a lawyer