News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by dlikhten on Monday August 15, 2011 @10:32AM (#2887034)
To add:

a) there will be at least 1 company focused on android which will be protected with the cloth that is Google's legal team.

b) Google can make Motorola better

c) Google can make hardware to go with their software.

d) Google can finally make Motorola phones running android open.

e) We can finally see what it means for a hardware company to exist with a motto: "Don't be Evil". Sure Google is not perfect, but all other companies have the motto: "Money first, morals second."

f) Google can make an incredible experience which would become the de-facto standard for Android phones. Finally killing off HTC sense.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by intended on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:12AM (#2887206)
GOOG is a s/w company and not a manufacturer. The ability to integrate both sides of such different firms is very difficult. This puts both points b), c) and e) off the table.

Point f)? I'm not sure, but I really hope that they can do something while looking at exactly how it will play out on a phone. They did try this with the Nexus though, and that was not something which worked out perfectly imho.

M&A's have a tendency to be non-accretive to the purchaser. This looks like its going to be similar for Google.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by SkyMarshal on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:13PM (#2887477)
>GOOG is a s/w company and not a manufacturer.

Fanboys used to say the same thing about MS when they were working on the first Xbox, and they came out looking pretty silly for it. The first one was a bit clunky, but the second one, especially with Kinect, is gangbusters.

Integrating Motorola won't be as big a problem as you make it out for a company as smart and well funded Google.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by mrj on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:28PM (#2887537)
I'm not sure that's the example I'd use. They sunk billions in the first on for little to show for it. Billions fixing broken xboxes in the second one and only recently have begun to gather some steam -- and even then it was helped by Sony's numerous missteps.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by achompas on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:08PM (#2887726)
"Only recently?" If not for the $1B RROD write-down in 2008, Microsoft would have been profitable then. MS has been making money off Xbox ever since that writedown.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ZeroGravitas on Monday August 15, 2011 @05:57PM (#2888903)
Got a cite for that? I think I saw estimates that the XBox project was still 5-10 Billion in the red at that point. Have they been making profits to even cover the interest they could have earned with that size of investment by leaving it in something low risk?
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by achompas on Monday August 15, 2011 @07:37PM (#2889157)
No cite for my specific claim, but I found this Engadget article claiming MS's Entertainment & Devices Division (read: Xbox) was $80 million in the black in 2008:

http://www.engadget.com/2008/01/24/xbox-goes-profitable-almo...

Note that I got the write-down year wrong--it was 2007.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by bostonvaulter2 on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @03:50AM (#2890278)
Isn't that just profit for that year, not including all of the sunk costs to get started?
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by achompas on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @12:08PM (#2891700)
Are we looking at cumulative Xbox profits from day one? Generally one is interested in a division's ability to generate positive cash flow, no matter the initial cost, because it's assumed that division will generate said cash flow in perpetuity.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by roc on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:06AM (#2890969)
> "Fanboys used to say the same thing about MS when they were working on the first Xbox"

Microsoft already had a world-class design and manufacturing group at that point, making critically acclaimed peripherals. And the missing piece, making a glorified PC, was not nearly as cut-throat a business as making a phone. They didn't have to push the envelope and they didn't even try.

Google, having far less experience with consumer hardware, would have a far more difficult time making an already good hardware company better.

And, in any case, all indications are that they wanted a patent pool and are going to essentially leave Motorola Mobility alone for the near term. I'd be surprised if they even exerted pressure to bin or integrate MotoBlur extensions in the next couple years.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by zmonkeyz on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:18PM (#2893606)
Since Rahul Sood joined them i'm hoping he's doing the hardware for the next XBox.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lukeschlather on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:39AM (#2887318)
>This puts both points b), c) and e) off the table.

I don't see where you're coming from on b/c. Motorola makes great hardware - it would be hard to improve that. What Google can do is provide phones with unlocked bootloaders and the standard "Android Experience" UI. Google can make Motorola better precisely because they are a software company, and they can use that core competency to let Motorola focus on what they do best. (At the moment, Motorola shoots themselves in the foot by writing so much software.)

On e, yes, I think the hardware division will have to stay divided from Google.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by cube13 on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:09PM (#2887456)
>I don't see where you're coming from on b/c. Motorola makes great hardware - it would be hard to improve that.

That's exactly the problem. Google, as a software company, doesn't currently have to worry about a lot of the issues that the hardware side of Motorola does, like supply chain management(both on the production and disposal side), dealing with retail outlets, directly dealing with cellular service providers as a device manufacturer, governmental agency compliance for hardware, etc. Google doesn't have really any experience with this, which means they absolutely need to keep the people that are currently doing those jobs.

Also, from what I've heard from people that used to work there, Motorola's engineering culture is on the "very corporate" side of things. Integrating that into Google's rather loose culture will be difficult, I think. This is especially important because both sides will need to be working with each other very closely.

Best case, Google doesn't change much, and integrates Motorola's hardware chain well. However, if they do exert a lot of control over the hardware side, quality could decline in the short term as the issues I mentioned above get worked out.

Overall, I think it's a much stronger position for both companies. Motorola gets Google's software expertise, and Google gets Motorola's hardware engineering and supply chain.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by pyre on Monday August 15, 2011 @02:02PM (#2887959)

  > Google, as a software company, doesn't currently have
  > to worry about a lot of the issues that the hardware
  > side of Motorola does, like supply chain management
The purchase comes with the employees that are currently running these things. It's not like Google bought the operation sans the talent, and now has to use current Google employees (with no experience in this field) to run Motorola Mobility.

All they have to do is operate it as a separate business that has to follow certain 'edicts' from on high. If they want to further integrate it into the Google fold they can do it gradually over time.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by cube13 on Monday August 15, 2011 @02:28PM (#2888076)
That's exactly why I said Google's priority needs to be keeping those employees with those skills and talents. As with any acquisition of this nature, people are going to leave Motorola because of this. Google needs to make a lot of effort to identify and keep the key people.

It's important to note that this isn't anything like any of Google's previous acquisitions, both in scale and the nature of the company being acquired. Google usually has absorbed the entire startup that they bought, and ran it as just a new team. They can't do that here. It's too big, and too complex to just do that.

EDIT: I think I'm giving off too negative a vibe here. I do think that this is a very good merger for Google and Motorola, and I think that Google will handle this merger in the best way they can.

I just believe that there are a lot of potential "gotchas" that can(and probably will) snag the companies in the short term.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by 18pfsmt on Monday August 15, 2011 @03:46PM (#2888338)
Remember the 280 North[1] acquisition by Motorola (they were a YC company)?

I don't know what will happen, but I'm optimistic as a complete outside observer. This acquisition was completely unexpected from any conventional/ conservative perspective.

Edit: I forgot to link: [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/280_North

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ga0bi on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:43PM (#2889289)
you bring up some great points, cube13.

personally, i'm looking forward to the acquisition so we can have Android devices that match up to the iPhone on a hardware level (emphasis on battery life). but the biggest concern i have is how Google is going to deal with the bureaucratic system that they will inherit from Motorola.

i'm currently working in the mobile industry, and a lot of manufacturing companies (Motorola included) indeed have a "very corporate" engineering culture. there are many levels between the devs/test engineers and the customer (whether it be the chip providers, service providers, other manufacturers) and the higher ups within the company. although Google is already a large company, i feel that they make an effort on minimizing the "corporate feel" and that a lot of engineers are attracted to that effort. but with this acquisition, will top-talent engineers get turned off? or will Google be able to minimize/eliminate the inefficiencies between the Google devs and Motorola engineers?

ps: i'm happy to finally be a part of the HN community :)

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by kls on Monday August 15, 2011 @02:44PM (#2888138)
I would not be surprised if they don't keep to patent and software assets and spin the hardware off into a non-Google company.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lambtron on Monday August 15, 2011 @06:53PM (#2889053)
i think this will be accretive as $39bn of cash was just sitting there collecting minimal interest and motorola is moderately profitable.

google has a strong management team with a pretty successful bolt-on acquisition history. even though this is one of their largest acquisitions, i have faith in the management team to either sell off the hardware component of the business, or otherwise somehow make this transaction a success.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by intended on Monday August 15, 2011 @10:01PM (#2889501)
I expect the same, spinning off the H/W component, but if they do that, they can't use it as a shield/target for the other android handset phone manufacturers.

As for the patent portfolio, from what news I've currently read, it seems the patents aren't the most valuable commodity.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by binarycheese on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:33AM (#2887288)
Google Appliance
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by mbreese on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:41AM (#2887326)
I thought they farmed that out to Dell to build. Motorola is a slightly bigger operation. (I know Foxconn will probably ends up doing the assembly anyway, but they'll still have to design the products)
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by InclinedPlane on Monday August 15, 2011 @05:30PM (#2888799)
Given that Samsung and HTC have already embraced openness as a policy having "googarola" on that same team will add even more momentum to it. Even more when you consider that arduino is the basis for android accessories. In the near-term it's almost irrelevant if android were a worse experience and android devices were less capable (I don't think that's the case, which is all the better) because ultimately it's about development momentum and the OODA loop. If the android platform can congeal a larger critical mass of talented hackers and developers and they can get into a tighter and stronger feedback-develop-release cycle on their software and their hardware then they will beat the pants off of any of their competition.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by podperson on Monday August 15, 2011 @10:57AM (#2887143)
I hope you're right. But Google has certainly sold it to its Android partners as "we're going to use their patents to defend your crapware-ridden half-assed locked down handsets and then smother the hardware people with this wet pillow":

http://www.google.com/press/motorola/quotes/

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ericd on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:28AM (#2887274)
Wow, those quotes all sound the same... it's almost eerie.

We welcome today’s news, which demonstrates Google’s deep commitment to defending Android, its partners, and the ecosystem.

We welcome the news of today‘s acquisition, which demonstrates that Google is deeply committed to defending Android, its partners, and the entire ecosystem.

I welcome Google‘s commitment to defending Android and its partners.

We welcome Google‘s commitment to defending Android and its partners.

Those quotes are from the heads of 4 major companies...

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by com on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:53AM (#2887387)
It's not just almost eerie. It really is, and makes me think of zombies walking. PR zombies.

Seriously, though, I imagine that there are pretty intense discussions taking place within a number of handset manufacturers right now about how to manage their risk:

* treat (but how? it's a Gulliver situation even for someone like Samsung)

* transfer (almost impossible to transfer the risks in this situation unless you join the MS camp)

* accept (and have your shareholders crucify you if you made the wrong call)

A very brave move from Google (in the Yes, Minister sense)

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ChuckMcM on Monday August 15, 2011 @05:41PM (#2888841)
And do you think the PR guys asked them for a quote? No they did not. They wrote the quote and then asked the company if they would 'approve' it. (sort of quote by inference)

I was exposed early on to this when a PR person wrote up a quote, attributed it to me, and then ran it through the PR department where I worked who 'signed off' on the release although no one actually asked me if I had made that quote. When I protested they said "Oh it sounded like something you would say, should we seek a retraction?" It was a hell of an introduction to this 'known technique' in the PR world. I told them that in the future they had to clear any quote attributed to me, through me, which they were happy to do.

So my speculation is that the PR guys wrote these quotes, asked the partner's PR firm to approve, and they did, because none of the CEOs/GMs whatever have that flag set in their PR department that says "check with me before you approve something with a quote from me in it."

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by cperciva on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:57AM (#2887405)
You don't actually think the CEOs said those things, do you? Google's PR people would have written to them saying "can we quote you as saying X?", and they would have written back saying either "sure, that sounds fine" or "no, use this quote instead: ...".
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ericd on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:11PM (#2887734)
You might be right, though I would think that even a PR person would have tried to introduce some variability to make it sound believable.

I don't really know how these things typically work.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by baconner on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:23PM (#2887802)
I've long suspected there's some kind of madlibs for PR that all these companies use.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by yangtheman on Monday August 15, 2011 @03:43PM (#2888327)
I read the responses, and I felt exactly the same way. The news has been shared with the partners beforehand and all PR responses have been choreographed. I don't know what they would do exactly, though, since Android is the best mobile OS choice they have. Can't touch IOS. Windows Mobile sucks. Symbian is going away. Not an easy place to be.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by Calamitous on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:32PM (#2887836)
I, for one, welcome our new handset overlords...
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lurker14 on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:14PM (#2887484)
Paging Matt Cutts. Web Spam cleanup in Aisle 3. Paging Matt Cutts

The "See more results like this" SERP collapsed-grouping display is needed on that page.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by runjake on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:30AM (#2887282)
Sure Google is not perfect, but all other companies have the motto: "Money first, morals second."

You're kidding, right? By law, this is the modus operandi of any publicly-traded company. If you think any different, you've simply fallen for their rhetoric.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by tspiteri on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:03PM (#2887429)
I think that Google's interpretation of "Don't be evil" is consistent with money making. They do it because they believe that in the long run, they will be more valuable if they are not "evil". Doing what is morally objectionable may lead to short term gains, but has a high maintenance cost. Not being evil is like having a clean sustainable system design; there is no need for kludges to hide the bad parts.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ralfd on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:42PM (#2887876)
I am puzzled by this "Don't be evil" bullshit.

How would be "killing HTC Sense" not evil? How is Google not evil in requiring real names for G+ and banning people with pseudonyms? How is shutting down APIs (like translation) which developers have grown to depend on not evil? How is monetizing their search monopoly to undercut the business of other companies not evil? Or shaping with their mystical page rank the fates of a whole economy?

And on the other side: What is Microsoft particularly doing today that they are seen as "evil"?

I have a ton of respect for Google, but companies are neither persons which act moral nor are they nations for which you pledge allegiance. You get no real life karma points for defending them delusionally in Internet flamewars.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by chc on Monday August 15, 2011 @02:07PM (#2887979)
You seem to have a very low bar for "evil". I don't see how most of those things (e.g. naming policies, shutting down or charging for free services that turn out to be too much of a burden, being popular enough that their algorithm is important to many business models) are even moral concerns. They might be stupid acts on Google's part, or very inconvenient for some people, but evil is a different kind of thing. You can't just expect others to live up to your own idiosyncratic idea of evil.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by Hawramani on Monday August 15, 2011 @03:56PM (#2888393)
What made Microsoft evil: They used to go into acquisition talks with small companies without planning to buy them. They'd learn about their technology and duplicate it themselves.

Another example of evil is cell phone carriers giving users high internet speeds but putting ridiculous caps on them. Or Apple banning apps from the app store then copying their functionality into their own software.

I don't know if Google has done or does anything like that, and that is why people tend to think they're 'better' than other companies.

Therefore by evil what is meant is the company using slimy underhanded tactics on competitors or customers (such companies usually use them on both). Maybe it can be expressed in one word: Cheating. Does the company cheat customers, partners, etc?

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lhnz on Wednesday August 17, 2011 @06:22AM (#2894787)
Shutting down the translation API wasn't an evil act, it was being used by content farms to steal content from other publishers and get advertising from it.

Having a privacy policy which requires your real name isn't evil. You are not being forced to opt-in.

Is monetizing your core product really evil..? I didn't expect to read an anti-business comment on a site such as this...

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lallysingh on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:32AM (#2887286)
Not when the founders are major stockholders. They won't sue themselves.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by mbreese on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:43AM (#2887331)
They still have a feduciary responsibility to the minority stock holders.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by r00fus on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:40PM (#2887869)
Actually, IIRC, there ARE no minority shareholders with voting interest. ALL of it is locked up within the triumvirate (Page, Brin, Schmidt).

Whether this gives them any more leeway isn't clear to me, but Google is quite non-standard as far as corporate structure.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by william42 on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @02:14AM (#2890100)
There are two classes of stock. The class that Page, Brin, and Schmidt have has ten times as much voting power.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by nknight on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:46AM (#2887349)
The law absolutely does not require corporations to make decisions on any particular basis, and definitely does not require them to put profits first. Please stop spreading this myth, it confuses people and gives amoral executives an "out" for their horrible behavior.

Fiduciary duty is an abstract concept that basically means a duty of trust. If shareholders are told that profits are secondary, you don't violate trust by not putting them first.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by malbs on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:54PM (#2889325)
In regards to point e) I'm not sure how "Don't be Evil" applies to a company that makes bomb components and missile guidance systems.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by donaq on Monday August 15, 2011 @09:25PM (#2889397)
Making bomb components and missile guidance systems is not evil in itself. If only evil men made and used weapons, the world would be in very bad shape.

I'm not arguing that the specific weapons mentioned weren't used for evil, I'm just making a general point that all the peaceful people in the world can afford to be that way because there are guns protecting them, so it's not as simple as weapons == evil.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by groby_b on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:16PM (#2889684)
I'm not sure they're part of Motorola Mobility...
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by malbs on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:35PM (#2889744)
Ahh you're right, classic me, I just parsed the headline and assumed it was the whole company, not just the mobile division.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by groby_b on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @11:33AM (#2891540)
No worries - I did the same thing :) I just had the benefit of already having digested a first wave of news when I finally came to the comments here.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ecaradec on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @03:10AM (#2890209)
Given what they've done with self driving cars, they could do awesome missiles.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by malbs on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:59PM (#2889344)
Unless of course the first thing GOOG does is wipe out all the IP and Patents owned by Motorola that have anything to do with... you know, killing people.