News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by Jabbles on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:00AM (#2886447)
Keeping Android open whilst treating their own phone manufacturing fairly will be a big challenge for Google. I hope they manage it. If done correctly the result should be a improvement in Android for all manufacturers, as the internal demands of Motorola will want to be heard, but cannot be prioritised.

I am still puzzled as to how Skype cost $8billion.

FYI Motorola Mobility had 24,500 patents when it was launched. http://mediacenter.motorola.com/Press-Releases/Motorola-Mobi...

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by cincinnatus on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:53AM (#2886617)
If they have any sense they are already negotiating the sale of the physical business on to someone else. Keep the patent portfolio and recuop $6 billion of the initial outlay.

Also, "open" in name only.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Monday August 15, 2011 @09:35AM (#2886806)
> Also, "open" in name only.

"open" as in:

  $ repo init -u git://android.git.kernel.org/platform/manifest.git
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by krakensden on Monday August 15, 2011 @10:43AM (#2887082)
unless you want the latest version...
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by runjake on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:51AM (#2887382)
I'm not sure why krakensden is being downvoted for their comment.

This is a continual gripe in the Android developer/hacker community. Has all of the Android 3.0/3.2 source finally been posted to android.git.kernel.org? Ice Cream Sandwich?

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:18PM (#2887784)
The 3.x branch is not open (yet). The 2.x branch (we are talking about mobile phones, not tablets) is open.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by mindcrime on Monday August 15, 2011 @01:49PM (#2887905)
I'm not sure why krakensden is being downvoted for their comment.

Maybe because Google have been pretty emphatic about the fact that the Honeycomb / Ice Cream Sandwich code will be released, and because their delay in releasing this one specific revision is hardly the same thing as "closing Android" or whatever hyperbole is being floated around.

That said, I didn't downvote him. I didn't think the comment added much to the conversation, but it's not worth a downvote in my eyes.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by runjake on Monday August 15, 2011 @02:11PM (#2887998)
I'm not sure I see the point of opening an Android release after it's developed. It defeats a primary benefit of open source software. And even then, on most models (HTC, Motorola), unless I'm willing to violate my warranty and root it or unlock the bootloader, I'm not able to actually use the source.

This whole "Android is open!" thing seems largely for marketing, not to actually promote any openness (unless you buy a Nexus phone, which is what I own, FWIW)

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by mindcrime on Monday August 15, 2011 @03:34PM (#2888297)
I'm not sure I see the point of opening an Android release after it's developed. It defeats a primary benefit of open source software.

Well, having the code released at all, is always better than not having it. The more code released to the world under a reasonable F/OSS license, the better, as far as I'm concerned. That said, you make a good point... Android isn't necessarily developed in the most open of fashions, despite the fact that the source itself is, technically, open source. :-(

And even then, on most models (HTC, Motorola), unless I'm willing to violate my warranty and root it or unlock the bootloader, I'm not able to actually use the source.

Nonetheless, you do have that choice. That's a fundamentally different scenario than with, say, a win7 phone or whatever, where you don't have access to the source at all. Plenty of people are willing to take the chance with the warranty situation in order to load custom versions of Android, so clearly this matters to some people.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Monday August 15, 2011 @04:08PM (#2888445)
> I'm not sure I see the point of opening an Android release after it's developed.

Why? I certainly see a point in having the source to the software running on devices being sold.

> It defeats a primary benefit of open source software.

The primary benefit is having the source, being able to modify it and to build upon it. No OSI compliant license grants you the right to immediate access to the latest commits by all developers.

> And even then, on most models (HTC, Motorola), unless I'm willing to violate my warranty and root it or unlock the bootloader, I'm not able to actually use the source.

The decision is yours. I voided my warranty and I am very happy with 2.3.4 on my phone.

> This whole "Android is open!" thing seems largely for marketing

Things like Cyanogen Mod wouldn't be possible without this "Android is open!" thing. If that's marketing, then I love it.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by kinofcain on Monday August 15, 2011 @10:39AM (#2887065)
"open" would be if that actually got me the latest code.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:19AM (#2887242)
I may be mistaken, but I believe (and you can check if you want) the last commit on that tree happened 40 hours ago.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by ktsmith on Monday August 15, 2011 @11:53AM (#2887390)
Everyone is referring to the ice cream sandwich specific code which is not currently available.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by d0nk on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:09PM (#2887455)
There still hasn't been a release of honeycomb's source (3.0-3.2).
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by kinofcain on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @01:35AM (#2890027)
You're not mistaken about the commits, but you're mistaken about what it means. That command will clone the 2.3 branch, aka Gingerbread. Honeycomb has been shipping on devices for months now, and Ice Cream is the current development branch.

Even if you want to claim that I shouldn't be able to see the current work in progress in an "open" project, which is debatable, I should at least be able to get the code for the currently released version, which would be Honeycomb.

I can't get access to those unless I'm in Google's Super Best Friends club.

GPL issues notwithstanding, Google is completely within their rights to keep their code away from me. However, it makes their trite definitions of "open" look pretty hollow.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @09:41AM (#2891087)
I am quite sure all the GPL parts of Gingerbread are available. I am also sure Google is not withholding parts of Gingerbread for no reason. I have no knowledge about their reasons to do so, but, considering many if not all 3.x tablets run on Nvidia chips, I'd bet this has some relationship to Nvidia's historic reluctance in supporting open-source. I am also quite sure Google is working on that as it's not in their best interest to alienate the open-source developer community.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by kinofcain on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @11:39AM (#2891571)
I'm going to assume you mean Honeycomb.

So you agree then, that Honeycomb is not available, and that google is withholding it for "some reason" (although you just have to look at their own statements, they're withholding it because they don't want OEMs putting it on phones).

How is that "open"?

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Tuesday August 16, 2011 @01:30PM (#2892082)
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2382585,00.asp

"Android 3.0, Honeycomb, was designed from the ground up for devices with larger screen sizes and improves on Android favorites such as widgets, multi-tasking, browsing, notifications and customization," Google said in an email to PCMag.com. "While we're excited to offer these new features to Android tablets, we have more work to do before we can deliver them to other device types including phones. Until then, we've decided not to release Honeycomb to open source. We're committed to providing Android as an open platform across many device types and will publish the source as soon as it's ready."

Meaning it's not ready. (emphasis mine)

I have to agree that, right now, Android has a closed branch (two - HC and whetever's not released) but claiming it's closed-source because it has one branch closed is not quite honest - like claiming MySQL is not open-source because they sell proprietary addons. My phone runs the open-source 2.3.4 version that was assembled by developers who don't work for Google.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by lojack on Monday August 15, 2011 @09:56AM (#2886896)
I believe the point is that google can now produce closed source motorola specific software, and not that android is no longer open source software.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by rbanffy on Monday August 15, 2011 @09:57AM (#2886907)
Google always could. The Google apps you find on your Android phone are not open-source. HTC's Sense or Motorola's Blur aren't open source either. In fact, everyone could. My Nook is full of proprietary software. Android is just a software environment people build apps on top. The open-source core is fairly decent when compared to the competition, but no phone manufacturer I know ships only that.
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by Tyrannosaurs on Monday August 15, 2011 @09:00AM (#2886642)
Who would be interested in buying a marginally profitable manufacturing business in a highly competitive market for any significant amount of money.

Besides, I think Google are doing this, in part, to produce what everyone has been asking for - an Android phone without the crap heaped on it, a phone that will allow people to judge Android for what it is rather than for what Samsung, HTC and others think it should be.

Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by joelhaasnoot on Monday August 15, 2011 @08:10AM (#2886482)
This will indeed be a challenge: keeping the interests of their own cell phone division and third party hardware makers. Might be just another "HTC Sense" type skin added to Android...
Re:Google Buys Motorola For $12.5 Billion by jonursenbach on Monday August 15, 2011 @12:09PM (#2887453)
Motorola already has that with Motoblur.