Re:Why HN is the way it is, and why we hope it will stay tha...
by TeMPOraL on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:07PM
(#28853997)
You can flag submissions, which works sort of (but not quite) like a downvote. Plus, there are some mechanisms limiting "edgy content", e.g. if the comments/upvotes ratio starts screaming "flamewar!", the submission will drop off the front page like a brick.
Re:Why HN is the way it is, and why we hope it will stay tha...
by KennyBlanken on Thursday October 14, 2021 @03:14AM
(#28861387)
So basically all anyone has to do to suppress a topic is engage the flamewar detection mechanism?
What could possibly go wrong on a site where getting an account doesn't even require a pulse. I'm pretty sure I didn't have to fill out a captcha.
Re:Why HN is the way it is, and why we hope it will stay tha...
by fragmede on Thursday October 14, 2021 @03:51PM
(#28869099)
You're assuming what you see (eg lack of capcha) is all the protection that exists, and that there's no other protection. It's kind of like Disneyland - a lot of work goes into making the site what it is, and you don't see even a tenth of the work that goes on into making it look so good.
Re:Why HN is the way it is, and why we hope it will stay tha...
by Danieru on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:07PM
(#28853988)
True but links are sorted in competition with other links with a zero baseline. Comments piggyback on the link popularity will always show up on the page. Exception of course the massive 100+ comment hot topics.
Thus links resting state is a quick falloff and death. In contrast comments tend to hang around, even bad comments if they are part of an interesting conversation.
But that's the same system used for link submissions? you can upvote them but not downvote them.