News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by vimy on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:18PM (#28847870)
The price is not relevant. The idea behind vaccine mandates is that it’s the only way to protect people so therefore it’s ethical to force people to take the vaccine. But this treatment has been available for almost a year… No one should be forced to take something if there are alternatives.

Instead we should have ramped up production of these game changing drugs. Why didn’t we?

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by arrosenberg on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:39PM (#28847982)
...because MCA is a treatment, while the vaccine is a prophylactic. Every person who refuses the vaccine and winds up needing ICU treatment means resources unavailable for breakout cases and non-covid emergency conditions. It's absolutely ethical to compel vaccination in order to safeguard the health and safety of the overwhelming majority of Americans who are being individually and socially responsible by getting vaccinated; and the healthcare system and workers, which are under tremendous strain.

Also, prior to COVID, monoclonal antibodies were being tested in single digit numbers of patients with highly aggressive cancers at a cost of $500K per treatment. The cost has come down 100x, so it's inaccurate to claim production hasn't ramped up. It has, it's just still way more cost effective to get a vaccine.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by vimy on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @08:21AM (#28851240)
MCA can also be a prophylactic.

The assumption that vaccines would end the pandemic was also based on the idea they would stop transmission. This turned out to be wrong. Vaccines are excellent at preventing hospitalization but do a crappy job stopping transmission.

So when we have vaccines who are only excellent at self-protection and we also have a cure, I don’t see why we would compel anyone to take something they don’t want to.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by arrosenberg on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:54PM (#28855281)
That is simply nonsense. The current vaccines are not completely effective at reducing transmission in a rapidly mutating virus when a significant minority is refusing to take it. If the vaccine was deployed to 95% of the population the virus would not have enough hosts to continue propagating and would reduce to background noise that can be easily handled by the medical systems with treatments like MCAs.

I'm also curious what is acceptable about monoclonal antibodies, but not the vaccine? They've been developed by the same types of scientists, on a similar timeline to the mRNA vaccine technology, and they work on similar fundamentals, but the MCAs are a less effective solution in terms of cost, production, deployment, and long term protection. The whole thing just seems like a temper tantrum with no rational basis.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by vimy on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:30PM (#28855647)
> I'm also curious what is acceptable about monoclonal antibodies, but not the vaccine?

I don’t know since I’m vaccinated. I just think people should have a choice.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:39AM (#28848297)
> It's absolutely ethical to compel vaccination

It's never ethical to compel the innocent to do anything.

A shifting of the incentives would be far more ethical, but difficult politically - perhaps make people who are unvaccinated pay a greater percentage of their treatment, or need to take special insurance. I'd advocate that kind of thing for most things relating to personal/lifestyle choice, obesity being a good example, giving better premiums to non-smokers, vegetarians etc but when the numbers of (possible) patients becomes big then it's unlikely to be taken up either by an electorate nor by a politician.

That's ignoring how many health systems seem fundamentally broken for other reasons (e.g. US and UK).

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by arrosenberg on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:57AM (#28848382)
> It's never ethical to compel the innocent to do anything.

What does that even mean? Innocent of what, having an immune system?

Financial incentives, such as being fired if you create a hazardous workplace by refusing vaccination, are a form of compulsion on an escalating ladder of methods to convince people. The government absolutely leaned on business to make that happen in order to avoid a direct mandate.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:09AM (#28848447)
> What does that even mean? Innocent of what, having an immune system?

Innocent of a crime. That's it's usual meaning, and we compel those guilty of crimes to do things they don't want to.

> Financial incentives, such as being fired if you create a hazardous workplace by refusing vaccination, are a form of compulsion on an escalating ladder of methods to convince people.

That's not an incentive, that's a punishment. I do agree, however, that it is a form of compulsion (a compulsion is never also an incentive).

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by sriram_malhar on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:56AM (#28848669)
I'm not sure what you are referring to with terms like "innocent", "crime", "compulsion" etc when the topic is a covid vaccine.

I don't know why everyone's up in arms about this particular vaccine. Kids around the world are given vaccines for polio, diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, measles, tuberculosis, hepatitis B, hiaemophilus influenza type b (Hib), diarrhea, smallpox etc.

Why is everyone up in arms about this particular vaccine, esp. when the mRNA based ones don't even have any part of the virus? I can't think of any reason other than stupid/criminal politicians on the right using whatever slogans they can to influence their sheeple to maintain their foothold. Jeez.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:21AM (#28848807)
> I'm not sure what you are referring to with terms like "innocent", "crime", "compulsion" etc when the topic is a covid vaccine.

Why I'm referring to them is because the only members of society we usually compel to do anything are:

- children - those in the military - those guilty of a crime - those who have lost their mind

Adults innocent of a crime, not in the military, and who are compos mentis are not subject to compulsion - to compel them would likely be a crime.

> I don't know why everyone's up in arms about this particular vaccine.

I am not everyone and I am not up in arms about the vaccine, I am responding to the element of compulsion and violation of the normal situation of legal standing between an individual and the government (who would be the ones doing the compelling). If you compel someone to get any of the other vaccines listed, then I would be "up in arms" about that too.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by sriram_malhar on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:59AM (#28850252)
All laws and rules of a society are compulsions if you want to read it that way. Stopping at a red light, removing ones shoes at the airport, not going the other way on a one-way street, headlights turned on in the dark, stopping for pedestrians .... these are all compulsions and public safety measures. I see the covid vaccines (now that they have been so extraordinarily tested) as benignly ... I don't see why words such as 'compulsion' and 'crime' even enter the picture.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:23AM (#28850423)
I find that when people need to expand the definitions of common words to render them virtually meaningless and, more importantly, strangely convenient to their point of view and the argument they are presenting, that is the point I realise that they’re not interested in a proper discussion and leave, entirely unpersuaded.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by kelseyfrog on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:45AM (#28848616)
What a strange way of looking at the world. When did you choose to have that perspective and why?
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:16AM (#28848782)
You need to be more specific, especially to keep within the commenting guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#comments
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @10:56AM (#28852961)
Everyone is compelled to do many things they don't want to do every day.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:10PM (#28857774)
Are they compelled by law to undertake invasive medical procedures?

From [1]:

> An invasive procedure is one where purposeful/deliberate access to the body is gained via an incision, percutaneous puncture, where instrumentation is used in addition to the puncture needle, or instrumentation via a natural orifice. It begins when entry to the body is gained and ends when the instrument is removed, and/or the skin is closed. Invasive procedures are performed by trained healthcare professionals using instruments, which include, but are not limited to, endoscopes, catheters, scalpels, scissors, devices and tubes.

Without the consent of the person it would constitute a serious form of assault and battery, a common law crime that stretches back at least 1000 years. I do hope that you or anyone else is not subject to such things on a daily basis.

Are you?

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6678000/

[dead]
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:30AM (#28848863)
> They're not guilty of a crime on the books

Then they are innocent and there should be no compulsion.

> I would hardly call antivaxxers innocent

1. People who are against compelling the innocent are not antivaxxers by dint of being against that.

2. Those who would compel innocent people probably are and should be guilty of a crime on the books.

> Punishments are an incentive

They're not, they are a disincentive. Incentives encourage, disincentives discourage. The carrot is an incentive, the stick is a disincentive.

> Moreover, if you want to talk about the law, no one is entitled to their current job

Did I mention tyranny?

> and employers have been given carte blanche to set and modify employment conditions

I'm not an American and even if I were, not all states have the same rules for employment. You're creating a straw man. If we were really talking about the law, and criminal law at that, where's the mens rea?

> Losing ones' job for failing to meet the bare minimum workplace safety requirement of not being a vector for a highly communicable disease

It's not a bare minimum requirement unless you start compelling people, you're begging the question.

> is free to forfeit their job, but they are not entitled to be a victim about it. That's a personal choice.

I'm pretty sure I heard this form of argument in the 80s about homosexuals and HIV, it didn't hold water then and it shouldn't now. Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

Edit: a tyrannical typo

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by arrosenberg on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:54AM (#28849010)
Losing your job for creating a workplace hazard isn’t tyranny, unless you believe you can compel your employer and coworkers to deal with that. It’s not begging the question - someone is going to be forced into a situation that they aren’t happy with. Obviously, it should be the people who insist on being a vector for communicable disease. That opposite conclusion is juvenile and silly, and that’s why antivaxxers who are fired and play the victim on social media are being rightly ridiculed for it.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @05:13PM (#28857804)
> Obviously, it should be the people who insist on being a vector for communicable disease.

I hate to break it to you, but the vaccines we have do not produce sterilizing immunity[1], everyone is a possible vector by dint of being a living, breathing mammal.

Perhaps you were arguing this whole time from the perspective of original sin.

[1] https://thehill.com/changing-america/well-being/prevention-c...

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by morsch on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:12AM (#28848757)
Ok. So let's flatten the curve with mass produced MCA. You can't wait giving MCA until people are hospitalised, they're not effective anymore at that late stage.

So do we test everyone all the time to determine whether they need the stuff? If they test positive, how do we encourage them to take the MCA? Or we could give them to everyone all the time, continually, as a prophylaxis. I'm sure that would to over well.

You could also limit the prophylaxis to particularly endangered folks, but you'd still fill the hospitals with not particularly endangered people who drew the short straw.

That's essentially what we are doing, except the not particularly endangered people can just get the vaccination.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by Gibbon1 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:23AM (#28848228)
What really protects people is herd immunity. Ethically malingers that don't voluntarily contribute to that need to be forced. You might not like that for ideological reasons, but really who cares.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by skrbjc on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @03:15PM (#28856218)
What's wrong with letting them go out and get sick, if that's what they're comfortable with? You're telling them they need to either stay home or get a shot? Why not let them go out, and take the risk of getting sick? We already know, at a population level that complications from Covid happen in a very small percentage of people. At this point we have the knowledge and tools to manage things. Let everyone out, some get sick, many recover, and we get over this in 6 months. Really it seems the lockdowns are the problem since it's letting this disease meander and figure out the best way to keep transmitting.
Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by brigandish on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:44AM (#28848321)
The people at most risk are the "Ethical malingers". The people at least risk are those who already have a low risk profile and/or those who take the vaccine.

I wonder what other populations you might compel to do things - or not - for the "herd" and their health. My guess is it would look cruel and capricious very quickly, much like any other tyranny.

Re:Scientists discover a highly potent antibody against SARS... by vajrabum on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:36AM (#28848288)
Monoclonal antibodies are expensive and hard to make and the manufacturing processes don't scale all that well.