News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by aboodman on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:55PM (#28844954)
Your comment doesn't address the point of the article. The author isn't talking about Ethereum itself, which they acknowledge up front can comfortably be considered decentralized.

The point is smart contracts. They are code, and they have to get updated if there are bugs. How do they get updated? Well, in the simple (and common) case somebody holds the private key and updates it. That's centralization, obviously.

You can get arbitrarily complex with how smart contracts are updated. You can have multisig, where 2:3 have to vote to update, or you can have actual voting, or you can even do voting by stakeholder in the contract.

But whatever you choose, it's fully a function of the smart contract itself what level of decentralization it achieves, and not at all about Ethereum.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by thebean11 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:10PM (#28845135)
Sort of..an individual smart contract is completely immutable; the code cannot be updated. You can create a proxy smart contract that points to the contracts actually handling execution, and update those pointers to point to new, updated version of the code which is what I assume you're referring to.

Plenty of popular smart contracts do not do this though, and are fully immutable. Rather than updates, the developers upload a new version. Users can use the new version, or stay on the old one forever (the developers cannot delete it).

Regardless of which one, though, this is known ahead of time. A user (or, more likely, a community of users) can inspect the code and see to what extent the key holders can modify functionality.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by Darvon on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:15PM (#28845716)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum_Classic#The_DAO_bailo...

Eth is immutable unless the central players lose too much money then they can roll it back

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by RealityVoid on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:28PM (#28845873)
I think the DAO hack is misrepresented in the crypto community lore. The network simply decided to follow the main developers and those that did not, kept with what is now ETH classic. A hard fork can happen in absolutely _all_ cryptocurrencies, and I see it as a feature rather than a bug.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by drdeca on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:41PM (#28846474)
While I generally agree, I will say that the ability to dictate a Schelling point is a form of power.

Imagine a first past the post election, where there is no official list of candidates (one simply writes in a name), but where a particular person has the position that they are always the first person to publicly recommend any candidate, and all voters hear this recommendation.

This would be a powerful position, even if that person was not eligible as a candidate, and even though everyone can vote for whatever candidate they want.

When in a position of significant power, even if this power is only of the form of one’s reputation and/or one’s influence on Schelling points, one has a responsibility to, when exercising this power, to take into account the effect it will have on others.

I don’t mean that he failed to do so. I imagine it must have been a difficult decision! And I do hold Vitalik in high regard.

But if one presents such a fork as being merely the the result of independent choices of each user, I think one is mistakenly omitting the power used by big names which promote one fork or another.

I don’t mean to say that this power being present is a problem that needs to be solved, making this power not present. I don’t think that is possible.

Like I said, I do largely agree with much of the “people are free to choose what fork they use” framing.

But while I think it is probably basically the best that can be achieved, I do think it is best to acknowledge that even without authority from things other than social influence and such, that there is still power through said social influence + Schelling point influence + etc. , and it is possible for this power to be misused (though I don’t claim that it was misused in this particular case).

In addition, I do think it seems prudent and good to avoid exercising this power unless the reason to use it is especially compelling (e.g. either part of an upgrade which basically the whole community has been expecting for a long time, or which has overwhelming support, or to handle something which , if not handled, could have an existential impact on the chain, or things like this) . (And, while I haven’t kept up with his latest writings and actions, I suspect he kind of agrees?)

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by RealityVoid on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:53PM (#28848052)
I think you are spot on, with the addendum that exercising this power comes with costs - see the very DAO hack we talked about. So while I fully agree this power exists, it is not unlimited and is invested by the users of the network. I also think Vitalik is aware of all these and they are actually using these principles in the ETH governance.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by nextaccountic on Thursday October 14, 2021 @08:46AM (#28863508)
This just means that as far as users are concerned there is no such thing as an immutable blockchain. That's because people don't interact with chains directly, they use "Bitcoin" and "Ethereum", and those names have an inherent mutability in what they refer to.

The Ethereum developers convinced enough players of the crypto ecosystem to change what chain the name "Ethereum" refers to, not unlike a dns change (but to a large extent, done manually; there were humans in the loop to activate the hard fork). So wallets and exchanges changed the chain that the name "Ethereum" pointed to. Nodes migrated, and miners too. And it just happened that this fork was made specifically to revert a certain transaction.

Those that were left on the original chain had to pick another name for it, and build another branding. It was now called ETC instead of ETH, even though it was ETH that changed; ETC points to the old chain that used to be called ETH.

From the perspective of users, the transactions on ETH were truly reversed. Immutability is a mirage. (This is not necessarily a bad thing though.)

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by staticassertion on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:07AM (#28848128)
Why is that preferable over a system that's just... mutable.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by thebean11 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:29PM (#28845885)
They cannot roll it back. Anybody can create a hard fork, and nobody is forced to use that version. In fact, the version that was not rolled back still exists, and we are all free to use it if we wish!
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by xg15 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:37AM (#28848582)
This ignores network effects at play. As soon as large parties or developers of popular front-end software announce their support, the majority of smaller users will quickly follow - simply because not following would put them on a massive disadvantage.

The developers of the clients do have a massive advantage here.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by thebean11 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @10:45AM (#28852781)
Yes but anyone can develop a client, there is no permission needed
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by xg15 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:20PM (#28854152)
Anyone can develop their own Android fork - this will still not put Google's dominance in any danger.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by thebean11 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:15PM (#28855502)
I disagree, a fork with a non-Google app store could absolutely threaten Google.

The Oculus Quest runs an Android fork for example. Are you saying if Google gets into VR Facebook will not be able to compete because of the fact they are using Android?

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by jcpham2 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @08:09PM (#28846670)
I know guys still holding on to their ETC bags.

Bitcoin folks think the DAO fuckup perfectly illustrates Ethereums weakest link: the creator.

The weakest link is and always will be Mr Buterin. Satoshi did it correctly by disappearing

Hi Vitalik! I bought into your nonsense too. I’m even staking for you so whatever

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by everfree on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:33PM (#28845937)
Ethereum Classic without the rollback still exists, the old history didn't go anywhere. You and anyone else are free to use it.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by pie_flavor on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @04:42AM (#28849753)
There is nothing of value in the history. The network of people using it is the value.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by baby on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:33AM (#28848272)
Consensus can mutate yes. People tend to forget that these protocols run on top of a consensus protocol.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by aboodman on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:54PM (#28846574)
Thank you for the information. Yes, I was talking about the proxy pattern. My mental model was that this was the classic approach.

I did not know that popular major projects were using immutable smart contracts.

This seems crazy to me, but it does at least address the question of centralization (while introducing massive bug risk).

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by javier123454321 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:52AM (#28848360)
Yeah I mean look at Uniswap. Billions of dollars in liquidity locked up and it is immutable. Software development in this context is much more similar to hardware engineering, the cost of rolling back is exponentionally more than rolling put a django app or whatever. But weve been doing this type of engineering for millenia, what happens if there is a bug in the design of a bridge? Its cratastophic, yeah so what do you do to prevent that? Should we not have bridges?
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by aboodman on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @06:24PM (#28858362)
I think it’s a little different because people do regularly maintain bridges without replacing them and rerouting all traffic. But I get your drift. What a crazy thought to have these completely autonomous programs moving billions in value.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by saurik on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:04PM (#28845064)
> Well, in the simple (and common) case somebody holds the private key and updates it.

I will grant you "simple", and maybe even "common"... but only because most people don't really understand decentralization and many of the ones who do don't care about it.

The "actual" way this happens, for the protocols and contracts that "actually matter" (certainly almost everything you would have heard of, as opposed to the long tail of tiny pet projects) is that, in the case that a bug is found, all of the users have to vote with their feet to move to and accept a new one.

Essentially, this is equivalent to saying "decentralized contracts simply aren't upgradable", but of course everything is upgradable if you accept the idea of people giving up on old software and using new software ;P.

(If this sounds familiar, it should be: this is in a very real sense similar to how Wireguard intends to deal with cryptographic breaks in its chosen cipher suite, as they aren't some centralized power able to upgrade everyone's computers remotely.)

(FWIW, there is something else you can do, but as it would be implemented by still more contracts that themselves might have bugs I don't consider it the answer here as it begs the question: you make a contract--hopefully a simpler one that is less likely to have a bug--that lets people vote on which contract is the current accepted one, assuming they can all have compatible APIs.)

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by Grimm1 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:14PM (#28845711)
> I will grant you "simple", and maybe even "common"... but only because most people don't really understand decentralization and many of the ones who do don't care about it.

So assuming that this is mainly an issue of people not understanding versus understanding and not caring (though you said there’s some of that) how is the Ethereum community going to get the word out so that this becomes a mainstream success versus mainly for speculation as it is now?

A common issue and one that I personally feel crypto in general suffers from is that neat tech isnt a a criteria on which most people flock to use something so what are the reasons end users need to know to be like ah yup I will drop my regular finance interactions for this or heavily augment them with this?

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by megameter on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:12PM (#28846254)
It helps to consider the context of finance as glue that helps make the real economy move by reducing fraud. Deciding to use a crypto solution is like deciding to use double-entry accounting: it creates a quick and reliable record of transactions in a certain context, this context being one of consent. Putting consent mechanisms on-chain gives many of the benefits of a trusted third party without designation of an actual fallable, corruptable person or institution. That allows the surrounding regulatory framework to be streamlined and take on more and smaller cases with a lower footprint. But there is a chicken and egg scenario there since the norms have to shift towards these solutions before they gain all the desired efficiencies.

That said, I was paid in crypto the other day through a DAO. I was told how to submit a proposal to be paid, and then the funds were released through a vote within hours. It was transparent and the only hiccup was in needing a 70 cent bond fee to submit the proposal - it wasn't "controlled" in the usual sense of assigning a person to handle funds. So I already see some benefit in organizational structure.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by Grimm1 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:33PM (#28847223)
Hmm yeah that is certainly interesting in the sense that it was easier to receive payment than it otherwise may have been in current financial systems. Easier to trace and such too I imagine if it was needed.

To your point about transparency and trust for general transactions, I can see how that will be useful but don't you lose the ability that most trusted entities have now which is to roll back the transaction or correct a situation if fraud has occurred, given what I understand to be the finality of a contract? That said, I'm personally not really worried about making a transaction over say VISA's network but I am concerned about the end party I'm interacting with and I feel like crypto in general doesn't do well to address that, which I almost feel like is the real issue. I don't think I understand why people feel like it's an issue if they have to transact over a bigger central authority, perhaps I'm just too far removed from the group of people not served by classical finance.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by saurik on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:42PM (#28846016)
I question your premise. If you analyze "by weight instead of by volume" then I maintain that all of the important projects you hear about--think of the decentralized exchanges or lending platforms, such as Uniswap--do not have back doors in their contracts for centralized code updates: when Uniswap wants to build a new version, they release a totally new system that happens to share a name.

That there are a large number of silly projects most people haven't heard of, or random tutorials on the web for getting started in crypto, that involve building contracts with backdoors is no different from any technology... most stuff isn't scalable or even slightly secure, even if the products from the biggest companies and used by the most people tend to be: like think how many websites have ubiquitous SQL or HTML injection attacks... only "by volume" (looking at the total number of such websites, irrespective of how much use they get) as "by weight" (looking at the websites you use during the course of a day by how much you use them) I bet almost none of them do.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by a1369209993 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @07:41PM (#28846471)
> to deal with cryptographic breaks in its chosen cipher suite

Interestingly, this is actually almost doable in the context of a decentralized contract/computing system (with bug bounties to incentivise reporting[1]). You can include in the contract a interface where someone provides a proof[0] that a given cryptographic primitive is broken (eg a pair of colliding messages for a hash function), and the contract self-modifies to no longer trust that hash function.

The other half of the process - adding new primitives - is harder, since you want to prevent the addition of deliberately broken primitives. Obvious ideas include requiring a machine-checkable proof of hardness from some reasonable axioms (eg ZFC + P!=NP + whatever else), although most primitives don't have such proofs, and that doesn't look likely to change. Or requiring a quorum of reliable-seeming cryptographers to vouch for it (refutation: NIST endorsed Dual_EC_DRBG). A escrow period, where a new primitive is accompanied by a deposit that's paid out to anyone who breaks it, might help, but you'd need a seperate mechanism to prevent NOBUS backdoors (again, see Dual_EC_DRBG).

0: Ideally, you want a semi-zero-knowledge proof such that someone who has the option of putting in a tractable but significant amount of work to prove it (eg hash collision in 2^64 operations) will expect to be able to recoup their losses without getting sniped by front-runners, but once such a proof has been used, it's only a matter of time before front runners recover it and warn every contract.

For hash collisions, probably the easiest design is a two-phase model, where the reporter provides a zero-knowledge proof to commit to a particular hash collision, but then has to provide the actual collision to get the bounty. This can also work for preimages of a Schelling point like all-bits-zero. I'm not sure what a good Schelling point for typical public-key cryptography like curve25519 would be though; zero is almost always algebraicly special.

1: Cryptographic primitives are generally broken incrementally, so this incentivises even malicious parties to report a not-yet-exploitable break immediately (and thereby neuter it), rather than spend time trying to develop a working exploit (and risk both the large and small rewards disappearing out from under them because someone else was either honest or just less patient).

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by mgummelt on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:24PM (#28845825)
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by saurik on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:33PM (#28845944)
Axie as a product isn't even remotely decentralized, as far as I can understand (though I haven't tried to really pull it apart or anything, though I did spend way too long researching it a couple months ago): the majority of its product is a centralized gaming server that uses classic cheat-protection and rate limiting strategies, along with a game client that they require you to be using--they even ban bots! think: how can a decentralized game ban bots?!--which is important as it is effectively centrally minting its SLP token (by way of how that token comes from points you earn in the game from game play; this "should"--if it were actually decentralized--result in everyone using bots to play each other constantly for maximum SLP earning, instead of hiring people in the Philippines to play your characters for you). One would do better to ask "in what ways is Axie Infinity even a blockchain project?", as I feel like the answers are mostly going to suck.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by larsiusprime on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:22AM (#28848504)
Just wait till you see their Terms of Use.

https://axieinfinity.com/terms/

Whatever blockchain (supposedly) giveth, Axie taketh away

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by int_19h on Thursday October 14, 2021 @03:52AM (#28861583)
The amusing thing about those ToS is that they literally prohibit you from reading them in full until you agree to them.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by webinvest on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @12:27AM (#28848246)
Not really. By default, smart contracts can’t ever be edited or taken down. They’re permanently written into the Ethereum blockchain forever. They can only be modified based on any included state-modifying functions you originally wrote into the smart contract.

There’s some fancy complex stuff where you can deploy 2 smart contracts with one being a proxy contract. Here, the proxy contract functions a lot like DNS does on the Internet. In this case, the contract CAN be (almost) fully updated but the proxy contract has to be setup at the very beginning. In like 80% or more of the smart contracts I’ve seen, smart contracts do not utilize proxy contracts for (almost) full updatability due to the extra complexity it adds, the less trustworthyness, and some other reasons.

Source: I am a smart contract developer.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by mgummelt on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @03:38PM (#28856552)
Author here. You've probably read more smart contracts than me, but this hasn't been my observation. Rarible, for instance, is very popular and uses proxy contracts. Axie as well.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by exo762 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:58PM (#28844991)
Some projects avoid upgrading contracts at all. They deploy a new version, create a new UI and point this new UI to new contracts. Uniswap V2 vs Uniswap V3. This way users are actively opting into new set of contracts.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by aboodman on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:02PM (#28845045)
This makes sense to me and I think can be considered decentralized. How common are completely immutable contracts though?

It seems like for any contract that holds significant value it would be insane to make it immutable, particularly when it's written in a turing complete language like Solidity.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by patrickaljord on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:26PM (#28845278)
It's pretty common, the two biggest and most used decentralized exchanges uniswap and sushiswap hold $10.5B and are immutable.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by arisAlexis on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:17PM (#28845745)
Uniswap censored tokens representing stocks some months back. This is 100% mutable behavior of the project.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by snug on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @06:31PM (#28845911)
That was blocked at the web interface, if you wanted to use one of those tokens you could directly interact with the smart contract to get around those blocks
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by Acrobatic_Road on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @09:44PM (#28847291)
The Uniswap devs created a standard called Tokensets to allow different front-ends to curate which tokens are available without actually censoring anything.

https://www.tokensets.com/

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by exo762 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:27PM (#28845298)
Holders of large amounts of funds often value simplicity. Take old Gnosis Multisig vs new Gnosis Safe. While lots of projects migrated (moved funds) to Gnosis Safe, some are still using old Multisig contract, which was so simple it could be audited by anyone in an hour. Old Gnosis Multisig is immutable and can definitely be considered a huge success.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by DennisP on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:52PM (#28845522)
It's a tradeoff. There have been cases where an immutable contract was hacked, but there have also been cases where an admin key was compromised resulting in loss of funds. Users also have to consider the possibility that the admin is corrupt.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by carlosdp on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:20PM (#28845219)
> But this fails to hold true for general purpose chains acting as a VM, including the front-runner Ethereum. Ethereum nodes can in theory filter modifications to the smart contracts they execute, but in practice, node operators have no reason to inspect or reject these upgrades, because they have relatively little stake in the success of individual contracts or their ecosystems. If an owner of a smart contract publishes a new change, nodes will mindlessly run it. Ethereum is blockchain AWS.

This part does talk about Ethereum itself. It's just a conflation that, I agree, the author probably didn't intend, but nonetheless demonstrates the lack of understanding.

Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by mgummelt on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:24AM (#28848517)
It's not a conflation. The article is explicitly differentiating Ethereum services from the Ethereum protocol, just like aboodman says.
Re:Ethereum Services Are Centralized by vmception on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @01:01AM (#28848403)
Or you can burn the admin key and let the contract exist with bugs. That happens a lot too.

Decentralized communities choose to use a different contract or not.

I’m not really sure the point of the goal posts here.