News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:14AM (#28839937)
I've never understood why Hirohito was kept in-place by McArthur and the USA (the OP touches on this only briefly).

The institution of Emperor is closely tied-up with rightwing Japanese nationalism, whatever the imperial flavour-du-jour is. I fear and dislike all rightwing nationalism. But an "emperor" is a byword for invading and dominating your geographical neighbours. An emperor that is also a god seems like a particularly bad idea.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dukeyukey on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:31AM (#28840140)
Japan has had an Emperor pretty much since Japan became a thing, going back at least since 100-ish BC and maybe a few hundred years beforehand. Getting rid of such a foundational institution is _not_ the way to get the population on your side and back to work.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Bayart on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:12AM (#28840714)
"Emperor" is a Latin title (through Old French). Whatever martial implorations might simply not exist in Japanese.

English isn't the universal language, its semantics aren't enough to describe all of humanity's reality.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:39AM (#28841076)
"Emperor" is an English word, referring to the ruler of an empire. It is derived from the Latin title "imperator" (meaning commander; same root as the word "imperative").

The Old French connection is interesting - thanks. I guess most English words derived from Latin arrived via Old French. But this doesn't shed any light on why the Japanese Emperor is called an emperor in English. He's called an emperor because he rules an empire.

As I understand it, the emperor of Japan ruled over a number of subordinate, regional rulers, right up until the late 19th C. I understand "emperor" to mean a person who rules over kings, which is what the Emperor of Japan did. Why do I need to get involved with Japanese semantics, when the word we are discussing is an English word, being used correctly to refer to a ruler over kings?

So if we're speaking of a ruler over kings, how's that different from the Emperor Napoleon, or the Empress of India?

Ruling over kings implies dominating the armies of those kings (a king with no army is known as an "exile"). You can't maintain an empire without at least threatening martial force. Nearly all emperors have been fighting men - either to establish the empire, or to maintain it. Emperors with no army get deposed, or the empire disintegrates.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by numpad0 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:57PM (#28842867)
I had to look up when did the Japanese monarchy lost its own military capacity - it was the aftermath of Jōkyū Disturbance(1221). Kamakura shogunate defeated force of a retired emperor and began disarming the Kyoto royal court(government). Since then, and through Meiji Restoration(1867) that transferred shogunate control back to Kyoto then to Meiji Government in Tokyo City, the pre-modern formal government in Kyoto remained a puppet of military shogunates and later democratic governments.

"The emperor of Japan ruled over a number of subordinate" is technically correct but it's mere matter of formality, or it could be said that formality had been their point of existence for along time. They've been out of the game for long time, not even around invention of gunpowder, but around the emergence of curved Japanese swords.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @03:09PM (#28843794)
Thank you for this; I think I will look-up some Japanese history tomorrow (so far, I've been pulling factoids out of my fundamental orifice, a practice that HNers will reliably pull me up on).
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Bayart on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:11PM (#28845140)
Alright, since it's an interesting subject I'll take a detour :

The only reason the Emperor of Japan is called an Emperor in Western translations is probably because within Japanese historiography it's considered the highest possible title for a head of state of any kind and in European precedence tradition the equivalent is Emperor, with the exception of the King of France [1].

All that to say that there's no need to call back to the military history of the term to explain its significance in the context of Japan.

[1]: the Medieval Empire, that is what is commonly referred to as the HRE, being an outgrowth of the Frankish realm, there's been a tacit understanding that the King and the Emperor were of equal standing and wouldn't dispute each other's claims. Hence the notion that the King [of France] is Emperor in his Kingdom, which is of great importance in the conceptual history of sovereignty. Note that the King of France in the Age of Discovery had an Empire, but never claimed an imperial title as it was a core ideological principle that no title could possibly be above King of France. You can see some of that in the Japanese 天皇.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:18PM (#28845209)
> the Medieval Empire, that is what is commonly referred to as the HRE,

Sure, the HRE name is three lies for the price of one, but its at least specifically understood in its referent; “the Medieval Empire” is...not. Byzantium, most notably, being a thing.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Bayart on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @05:32PM (#28845347)
I'm using that terminology because, unless stated otherwise, in historical European documentation Empire used by itself usually means the HRE.

Furthermore including the Eastern Roman Empire as part of European Medieval history is dubious, or at least novel (and I'd wager the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the Cold war and the EU have something to do with that shift in perspective).

The European title precedence tradition I'm referring to, and from which the translation of 天皇 as Emperor is affiliated to, was solidified in the context of Late Medieval/Renaissance diplomacy [1], in which the Eastern Roman Empire was neither considered as part of the Western world (it was quite literally the East), not relevant as it had become a rump state.

[1]: If you're so inclined, read about the councils of Constance and Basel-Florence-Ferrara. They involved a lot of international politics, petty quarrels on precedence and as a bonus, the almost-but-not-quite end of the Great Schism. My favourite tidbit is the Spanish and Swedish bishops arguing over who among them were the true Goths.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dustintrex on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:26AM (#28840883)
天皇 is literally "heavenly king", and the full Japanese WW2 war cry was 天皇陛下万歳 Tennou heika banzai, "May the Emperor live ten thousand years". So yes, the implications are pretty martial, although the Emperors themselves don't sully themselves with actual fighting.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Aeolun on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:31AM (#28840976)
Yeah, and “For king and country!” Is not? I’m not sure what you are trying to say. Obviously war cries are going to be, well, martial.

I don’t see anyone shouting that now, and even if they did there wouldn’t be any martial connotations.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by dustintrex on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:38AM (#28841066)
GP was suggesting that emperor/天皇 may not have martial connotations in Japan, I'm pointing out that it does. As a perhaps better example, Japan's official name is now the bland State of Japan 日本国, and the old Great Japanese Empire 大日本帝国 sounds positively jingoistic.

And FWIW, it's not particularly hard to find fringe groups in Tokyo that proclaim their devotion to the Emperor from black vans equipped with loudspeakers.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Bayart on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:56PM (#28844975)
>So yes, the implications are pretty martial

The implications of these terms are spiritual, cosmogonic and social. I don't see what's martial about calling the big guy heavenly king or to wish "ten thousand years", all the more so that the later is a Chinese stock phrase and Japan imported their governance model part and parcel.

If the Australian army went to war at the cries of "Vegemite or death !", would you say Vegemite has martial implications ?

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by kibwen on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:33AM (#28840184)
> An emperor that is also a god seems like a particularly bad idea.

Remember that a condition of retaining the institution of emperor was the public renunciation of the emperor's godhood: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humanity_Declaration

> But an "emperor" is a byword for invading and dominating your geographical neighbours.

This might be reading too much into the English translation; we'd want to ask what the actual Japanese title is and what semantic implications it has in Japanese.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by BitwiseFool on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:03AM (#28840619)
I'd also like to point out that "invading and dominating your geographical neighbours" has actually been the norm throughout all of human civilization until very recently - and it still happens but under convoluted pretenses.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:52PM (#28841999)
> until very recently

I do not think that custom has gone away. I seem to be at war with my next-door neighbour, over rubbish-disposal; I just don't know which neighbour, what he looks like, or what his name is (but I'm not trying to seize his property by force of arms!)

People go to war with their neighbours over REAL things, like water-rights, and access to minerals and other resources. Those real things are still real. Fortunately, imperial wars don't seem to happen much these days; perhaps because great imperial powers can now transport a heavily-armed army of 200,000 across the world in a few days, squishing your imperial ambitions.

But the motivation is unchanged. Perhaps the Chinese occupation of Tibet is an example?

(Tibet used to be the imperial power, once upon a time - Chinese diplomats in the 14th C used to kow-tow to Tibetan kings)

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by disneygibson on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:25AM (#28840072)
The Japanese emperor concept precedes Western “invade everyone” imperialism by about a thousand years and has historically almost nothing to do with other countries. It really took Western ideas of imperialism to get Japan to be interested in the outside world.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @01:20PM (#28842395)
The Romans were into the "invade everything" business, 2,500 years ago. They ruled over kingdoms all around the Mediterranean.

The Greeks (well, Macedonians, if you prefer) built an empire that lasted 1,000 years, and stretched from the Mediterranean to Afghanistan. All during the lifetime of a warrior who died aged 32 (?). That was around 320BC.

So you have to go quite early in history, to find a culture that precedes "invade everything" imperialism (I doubt that there is any "beginning" to invade-everyone imperialism).

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by suction on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:30AM (#28840127)
Which of course is also the go-to "excuse" of the modern Japanese right-wingers to deflect any blame from the "pure" Japanese for what they did.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by disneygibson on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:32AM (#28840165)
Not sure how that has anything to do with my comment.

I’ll repeat it: the primary reasons which caused Japan to become “imperialist” are directly tied to Western imperialism. The Japanese emperor was mostly a political symbolic figurehead that united the Japanese islands, not a Roman emperor or British monarch intent on conquering the world.

This is all basic Japanese history.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Gupie on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:46AM (#28841175)
Are you forgetting the 1592 Japanese invasions of Korea which had the intent of conquering the Korean Peninsula and then the whole of China?
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by numpad0 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @02:49PM (#28843530)
I don’t think he is. Not even Korean right wings blame emperors for that invasion. By all intents and purposes it is Hideyoshi’s invasion.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by Gupie on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @04:46PM (#28844850)
My comment was in response to his assertion that "the primary reasons which caused Japan to become imperialist are directly tied to Western imperialism".
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by numpad0 on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:47AM (#28848963)
These are indeed matters of basic Japanese history as GP claims, although I’m not too sure whether “basic Japanese history” is actually common knowledges except for Japanese history majors or someone who has gone through Japanese compulsory education.

Wikipedia article on Shogun[1] has a nice quick summary on pre-modern Shogunate system. It’s similar to British constitutional monarchy in a sense: the emperor was to delegate all power to the government and was to remain within instructions and supervisions of the government.

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shogun

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by suction on Wednesday October 13, 2021 @02:39AM (#28848927)
Oh, it has everything to do with it. I don't understand how you couldn't see that, immediately, so I don't think further explanation would help you.
Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by nobody0 on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @11:31AM (#28840965)
I don't know why you are downvoted. But given even Unit 731 was granted immunity by the US, I guess justice ceded its place back then.

It's sad to see politicians made those 'practical' decisions to protect those criminals. Let alone countless people lost their lives or suffered just because a room of people wanted wars.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by MomoXenosaga on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:35AM (#28840209)
Because WW2 was over and everyone thought WW3 was imminent.

The Japanese were extremely anti communist to the point that it would make McCarthy look like a hippie.

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by denton-scratch on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @12:37PM (#28841769)
"Never trust a hippie"

~ Johnny Rotten

As a one-time hippie, I'm with Rotten on that. Very few hippes retained their principles. Lots of them had trust-funds. Lots of them are here on HN (sorry chaps; I don't mean to imply that you're all money-grubbing wretches, happy to have swapped your principles for a San Francisco developer's salary!)

Re:Akihito and the Sorrows of Japan: The Anxious Emperor (2020) by suction on Tuesday October 12, 2021 @10:28AM (#28840115)
It seems the common explanation is that the US went the "reverse course" to have a bulwark against the rise of communism in East Asia. Japan was not to adopt communism at any cost. And the best way to ensure a society does not adopt communism is to give the diametrically opposed forces in the country the upper hand: Right-wing nationalism.

So many people who were responsible for the worst atrocities Japan committed in the last two decades in Asia were made leaders of the new "democratised" Japan. Hirohito as the spearhead was only one example. The people who were actuallt prosecuted and sentenced to death for war crimes were all deemed expendable by the Japanese anyway.

This is what haunts Japan until today - Nippon Kaigi, Nippon Foundation (aka Sasakawa Foundation), etc. are all basically think tanks and well-budgeted secret government agencies promoting right-wing nationalist or even borderline fascist ideas in Japan and astroturfing them overseas.

Just read about the Sasakawa Foundation to get an idea.