Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by intlkleinblue on Sunday August 14, 2011 @03:08AM
(#2883020)
I'd be careful. That wiki mentions nothing about me being trademarked (although it did before) and has suspect sources cited at the bottom. The IP status of Intl Klein Blue is not very clear from my personal research into the matter.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by wisty on Sunday August 14, 2011 @04:04AM
(#2883097)
The difference being, coloring fiberglass insulation serves to identify its brand, and serves no other purpose.
Red soled shoes are arguably better looking, which is a functional purpose of shoes. So you shouldn't be able to trademark them. Trademarks should only prevent people passing off goods as yours, not copying your function.
Similarly, Apple shouldn't be able to trademark Aluminium notebooks, or single button phones, as they have a functional purpose.
Of course, their is a question as to whether aesthetics is a function, and whether restrictions on aesthetics will limit the function of competitors' offerings. In fiberglass insulation, I doubt it. High-heels, maybe.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by delinka on Sunday August 14, 2011 @10:27AM
(#2883719)
I'd have argued that the red soles were indeed intended to be for identification only. Anything else is a function of people's perceptions (e.g. beauty is in the eye of the beholder.)
Lest we argue that red soles are aesthetically functional as well, regardless of the designer's intent, let's consider the possible repercussions of pink insulation when applied inside transparent walls. Or perhaps the calming effect the color has on installers. Now, the pink is functional. Does that make it less able to be protected?
I really think it goes back to the intent of the creator/designer/architect of the product. The designer of the shoes seems to have argued the aesthetic qualities of the color on the sole and therefore nullified his ability to claim the use of color was not "functional." If he'd held out with the argument that his intent was identity, he may have won.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by tzs on Sunday August 14, 2011 @04:10AM
(#2883101)
I read the article. And then I commented, providing information NOT PROVIDED IN THE ARTICLE. Namely, a correct legal citation to one of the most famous color trademark cases, and a link to the court's decision.
edit: could the down voters please explain yourselves? Am I wrong in assuming that some people would like to read the actual case mentioned in the article, instead of just a couple sentences about it?
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by westicle on Sunday August 14, 2011 @06:39AM
(#2883333)
When contributing value to the discussion, context is important. The article clearly distinguishes this situation from the case you cited. If you want to discuss that decision in more detail, try:
"If anyone is interested in the case mentioned in the article, here is a link to the full-text decision. [link]
Because the colour used in that trade mark was purely for the purpose of identifying the product and had no practical or aesthetic purpose, the court held that the colour could not be used by competitors."
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by callmeed on Sunday August 14, 2011 @01:13PM
(#2883983)
When I worked at UPS, they told us the company had a trademark on "Pullman Brown". Not sure if that's actually true or not (can't find reliable info with a quick search).
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by colanderman on Sunday August 14, 2011 @02:18PM
(#2884108)
It is true according to my IP instructor. UPS has a trademark on the color in the context of delivery services, it being strongly associated with their brand.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by hm2k on Sunday August 14, 2011 @05:53AM
(#2883274)
"lastminute.com", "lastminute" and the colour magenta are all trade marks owned by Last Minute Network Limited and/or its group companies.
The T-MOBILE acoustic logo, and the color magenta are registered and/or unregistered trademarks of Deutsche Telekom AG in the US and/or other countries
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by zalthor on Sunday August 14, 2011 @12:38PM
(#2883914)
I remember Cadbury (the chocolate company) tried to trademark the color purple. I think they failed at it because “purple” apparently wasn't a clear and concise description of the trademark.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by tobylane on Sunday August 14, 2011 @09:11AM
(#2883548)
You shouldn't be able to trademark colours, but a specific colour on a specific area of a specific item (red soled shoes), that others copy purely so customers are confused about the brand image, does sound more like what is needed.
Re:Can You Trademark a Color?
by maeon3 on Sunday August 14, 2011 @08:52AM
(#2883510)
Yes you should be able to trademark colors. Also, people should be allowed to trademark specific tones, like middle 'C' on the piano. I bought that one, you can't use it.
http://www.engadget.com/2008/03/31/deutsche-telekom-t-mobile... http://www.engadget.com/2008/04/01/painting-the-town-magenta...
o_o
Red soled shoes are arguably better looking, which is a functional purpose of shoes. So you shouldn't be able to trademark them. Trademarks should only prevent people passing off goods as yours, not copying your function.
Similarly, Apple shouldn't be able to trademark Aluminium notebooks, or single button phones, as they have a functional purpose.
Of course, their is a question as to whether aesthetics is a function, and whether restrictions on aesthetics will limit the function of competitors' offerings. In fiberglass insulation, I doubt it. High-heels, maybe.
Lest we argue that red soles are aesthetically functional as well, regardless of the designer's intent, let's consider the possible repercussions of pink insulation when applied inside transparent walls. Or perhaps the calming effect the color has on installers. Now, the pink is functional. Does that make it less able to be protected?
I really think it goes back to the intent of the creator/designer/architect of the product. The designer of the shoes seems to have argued the aesthetic qualities of the color on the sole and therefore nullified his ability to claim the use of color was not "functional." If he'd held out with the argument that his intent was identity, he may have won.
edit: could the down voters please explain yourselves? Am I wrong in assuming that some people would like to read the actual case mentioned in the article, instead of just a couple sentences about it?
"If anyone is interested in the case mentioned in the article, here is a link to the full-text decision. [link]
Because the colour used in that trade mark was purely for the purpose of identifying the product and had no practical or aesthetic purpose, the court held that the colour could not be used by competitors."
The article also details why that case is different from the one the article is about.
This use of red seems very different from contrasting soles - and having a trademark that blocks red high heels seems a bit overreaching to me.
The T-MOBILE acoustic logo, and the color magenta are registered and/or unregistered trademarks of Deutsche Telekom AG in the US and/or other countries
The footer contains the text "ANZ's colour blue is a trade mark of ANZ."
The actual web site contains multiple blues, so I am wondering which exact one they have trademarked?
You can find that disclaimer on any site containing mentions of pink nitrile gloves for use in hospitals.