> Expecting the x86/MS platform to stay open forever is not realistic, because the incentives are biased towards locking down.
It's only unrealistic when these fatalist certainties are pushed as inevitable. Free, live free is more than the name of a novella, it's an act to be performed, to fight for.
So yes, say no to the TPM and other such measures such as SafetyNet, which are worse than useless to the most important endgame, to live free.
If there is no way to deal with cheating at games other than relinquishing ownership, disposition, and functionality of my own hardware, that is not my problem, and, it's not true anyway.
Consoles are just the easy way not the only way.
It is if you want to use someone else’s software that requires it; you can’t have something on your terms just because the cost of using it is paid in something other than fiat currency.
(and BTW my bank already does that, requiring non-rooted stock firmware for its app on mobile. With Samsung for example, rooting amounts to warranty loss; maybe in EU it's different, but I'm not in EU)
Whether you or me say yes or no to TPM is not hugely important. Most people are absolutely happy to trade freedom for convenience, and it aligns with Microsoft's incentive to lock everyone into using their products. This isn't new at all, I've seen loss of PC modularity and openness discussed since late 90s.
However, there are several counterbalances for that incentive.
1. Platform fragmentation, the major one. This alone can delay the inevitable for any amount of time.
2. Backwards compatibility.
3. PCs being used for many purposes, not just as an appliance. This is a minor but noticeable one.
4. Some groups advocating for the platform openness. This one is of little relevance in practice.
Expecting the x86/MS platform to stay open forever is not realistic, because the incentives are biased towards locking down. How much time it'll take to get to that state is a different question, though. It haven't happened yet is all that can be said.