Re:Cloudflare doesn’t have to cut off copyright-infringing w...
by tryauuum on Friday October 08, 2021 @09:17AM
(#28798921)
My point of view that an analogy cannot possibly be, in your words, "true". Don't you think any analogy is leaky and we shouldn't use them? Any point of view demonstrated with an analogy can be conveyed without it.
And no, I attack this method not because I don't agree with the conclusion of comment I was replying to, it's because I hate analogies.
How comparing cloudflare to ford and then saying "wouldn't that be ridiculous if Ford got sued if a criminal bought a car" can be accepted by anyone as a valid argument? Yes, it would be ridiculous but that's it
And no, I attack this method not because I don't agree with the conclusion of comment I was replying to, it's because I hate analogies.
How comparing cloudflare to ford and then saying "wouldn't that be ridiculous if Ford got sued if a criminal bought a car" can be accepted by anyone as a valid argument? Yes, it would be ridiculous but that's it