Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mechanical_fish on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:46AM
(#288073)
The problem with this "inviolable rule" is that it's circular:
if you have a legal question, you should ask a lawyer, and only a lawyer
I agree, but what is a "legal question"? Only lawyers are qualified to answer that!
Many of those who pose legal questions to the web, rather than to a lawyer, do so because they don't recognize that their question crosses the boundary where they need a lawyer. It's not as if such edge cases are particularly rare, nor are they easy to resolve. Every post that I make to news.YC is a potential libel action; every quote that I cut and paste could be the subject of a copyright suit. (Just ask the folks who post about Scientology... and note that I just substantially increased my legal risk, and YCs, by using the word 'Scientology' in this context. Perhaps my lawyer would have suggested a different example...)
Everyone who writes software tiptoes around legal issues of patent and copyright. Should I consult lawyers every time I use Pastie?
Everyone who downloads a piece of software risks a lawsuit. Click a link that installs Firefox: legal. Click a link that installs a P2P client? Depends on what you do with it. What about HD-DVD ripping software? If I install it, am I committing a crime?
Yes, the ultimate arbiter of all of these issues should be a lawyer. I'm certainly not qualified. But we can't afford to pay lawyers every single day. In the end, we all have to develop our own sense of when we need professional legal advice and when we don't -- and the web is helpful for that, even though any individual anecdote (even the ones told by bona fide lawyers!) may be unreliable or inapplicable to your individual situation.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:02PM
(#288362)
"I agree, but what is a "legal question"? Only lawyers are qualified to answer that!"
I don't think you need a lawyer to know what's a legal question. Should I incorporate and if so, what type of entity is obviously one. What should be in my terms and conditions? Etc.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by river_styx on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:05PM
(#288368)
How can you be sure that any question related to your business doesn't have legal implications before first talking to a lawyer? You just gave examples of questions which obviously do require legal counsel, but what about examples of those which obviously don't?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:11PM
(#288374)
You can't, and it's clearly a judgment call on your part. I was referring more to the obvious legal questions, which are the ones I generally see here.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mechanical_fish on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @04:59PM
(#288474)
Should I incorporate and if so, what type of entity is obviously one.
Well, yes, once you've decided to ask that question it's obviously a question for a lawyer. But who should ask the question?
Should your personal blog be incorporated? Is that question worth asking a lawyer about? What if your personal blog is Boing Boing? What if you're Michael Arrington? What if you're Craig Newmark?
The point where you decide to seek investors is a pretty clear boundary: You need to talk to a lawyer. But if you're self-funding, and you're planning on releasing a free iPhone app for kicks, do you need a lawyer or not? I don't think it's all that obvious.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Tichy on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @08:43AM
(#287953)
Problem: can lawyers be trusted? They can easily tell me that I need to spend infinite amount of money on them. I might spend all my money on lawyers without ever getting any product off the ground.
I see how much money is wasted on IT consultants, why should it be different with lawyers? Except with IT consultants I can tell when shit is happening, with lawyers I can't.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by diego on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:08AM
(#288092)
The same applies to every aspect of life that you are not an expert at. Can doctors be trusted? Salespeople? Do your research, ask for recommendations. There are people in every profession with good reputations. These people usually have little to gain from screwing you over as opposed to providing good service. Conversely, if you are happy with their service you will keep coming back to them in the future once you trust them.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Tichy on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @12:19PM
(#288167)
Sure, but nothing else is so far removed from my daily experience. Even with doctors I would say that I can get quite far with my common sense. And doctors DO rip you off, as in recommend loads of useless treatments. Maybe they don't even mean bad, it is just a different perspective (it's not their money, it is yours - they can not make the judgment call of how much money to spend. As long as money is available, there is always something else that could be done).
I am also not saying that lawyers in general screw you over. But it seems very hard to find a lawyer I could trust.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by dreish on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:45PM
(#288531)
That's remarkable. If a doctor told you your arteries were dangerously clogged and you urgently needed a bypass, you would trust your common sense, even though the doctor is telling you you could have a heart attack at any moment? But if a lawyer recommends lots of expensive services, you wouldn't have the common sense or the assertiveness to seek a second opinion?
I didn't invent that heart-bypass example; it was a running scam exposed on 60 Minutes a few years ago.
I've been a client to maybe five or six independent civil lawyers over the years, and they all did pretty much nothing more or less than what I asked for going in.
I had a free consultation with a corporate criminal defense lawyer recently, not realizing she was a trial lawyer, so it would really only have been appropriate to meet with her had I been charged with something -- I was just looking for advice on how to avoid committing a corporate crime in a tricky situation. Not only did she listen to my story and not bill me for anything, she gave me the most cautious advice possible under the circumstances -- the advice least likely to cause me to need her paid services.
(I've been happy with the doctors I've had over the years as well, for that matter. I once saw a dentist who seemed both incompetent and fraudulent, but I didn't go back.)
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Tichy on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @06:31PM
(#288583)
First of all, as I repeatedly stated in this conversation, I don't want to knock down lawyers. It is just that I have the least knowledge about law, of all things, so the quality of lawyers is the hardest for me to judge. Also, are you denying that lawyers can get VERY expensive?
Your bypass example: yes, as it happens I have repeatedly read that bypass operations are complete nonsene, and there is actually a business of doctors referring patients to each other. Of course if they tell you you are going to die in one minute, there is no time to research the internet about the suggested treatment, which I would normally do.
With medicine I would do so - but with law, we have just learned that searching the internet is no good, because only a real lawyer should be trusted?
I have also had encounters with nice lawyers, who gave me free advice over the phone. However, it also seems common that lawyers don't want to be upfront about the costs they will incur. Also, I am in Germany, things might the different here than in the states.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by donw on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:42PM
(#288340)
Surprisingly, a large chunk of my friends are civil attorneys, and you know what? They all really care about serving their clients, and view themselves as champions of justice. Sure, there are scummy lawyers, just as their are lousy programmers, but I can't think of a single attorney that I've ever met, who wants to screw his clients over.
Especially in corporate law. If they do a good job at drafting your contracts and defending you in court against copyright infringement suits, you'll come back, and recommend your other business-people friends to that attorney's practice.
Of course, your attorney will want to disembowel the opposing side, but that's what you want.
If you're worried about an attorney, look at their track record; unlike a lot of other professions, you can get all of it from the courthouse in the district where they practice. If you don't know where to start looking for a lawyer, call your local bar association, and ask them for a referral.
Or, if you've got very little money, look at Pre-Paid Legal Services. Yes, yes, it started as an MLM company, which looks pretty scummy, but they actually do provide a very, very useful set of services, and the total cost is less than twenty bucks a month.
It just makes me sad to see lawyers catching all the flack for the problems in our judicial system, when it's our elected officials who created the whole nightmare in the first place.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Tichy on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:34PM
(#288389)
If you can afford a highly paid professional, sure, it is no problem to ask a lawyer all the time. Operating on a shoestring, the decision comes a little bit harder.
I did not even mean to knock lawyers, maybe they all mean well, but they might be used to a different kind of level for their operation.
Not that I had so much experience with lawyers so far, but so far I found it hard to find good ones. I just happen to have no connections in lawyer circles.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by gaius on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:20AM
(#288043)
Lawyers are perfectly well aware that a) if they try to screw you, another lawyer will happily screw them right back on your behalf and b) their social position is precarious enough as it is; no jury would convict an anti-lawyer lynch mob.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by tstegart on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:03AM
(#288088)
Unfortunately, this is a legitimate concern. You can't really sue someone for giving you subpar legal advice. It has to be really, really bad. And you would be surprised at how rare it is for a lawyer to lose a malpractice case. Doctors, sure, lawyers, not so much. It turns out that juries actually respect the work lawyers do when you get them in a courtroom.
On the plus side, if you really do get screwed, a lot of states have funds set up to compensate you. But if you pay for some legal work that might not have been completely necessary, you're on your own.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by sethg on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:16PM
(#288702)
I don't think lawyers are inclined to go after their bretheren this way, but I do think lawyers get a lot of business through referrals, and clients who don't feel like they've been screwed will refer friends and colleagues.
This would be particularly important in corporate law for small businesses, where the lawyers have ongoing relationships with clients (as opposed to, say, personal injury law, where some guy hit by a truck picks an attorney out of the Yellow Pages and may never deal with the lawyer after that case is resolved).
Of course, I'm making suppositions based on my knowledge of economics. Maybe I should consult an economist.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:55PM
(#288355)
Lawyers, like most well-paid professionals, have strong incentives to act ethically. They generally have more business than they can handle, so they don't need to rip you off, and getting caught doing so (which would happen the minute you spoke to another one) would have seriously negative consequences, up to getting disbarred.
Of course just like doctors, it cannot hurt to get second opinion, because lawyers are of course not all ethical or infallible.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Tichy on Thursday August 28, 2008 @10:36AM
(#289150)
So how does it relate to IT consultants - would you say that it is completely different with lawyers? Maybe all IT consultants are ethical, too, but many are still clueless. Still, they manage to find their customers, and they are in high demand, too. Are lawyers in general less clueless?
I must admit that it often freaks me out to consider that other professions are just as messed up as the software world. For example, in medicine there is in all likelihood an equivalent to LISP and an equivalent to Java. Many hospitals might have invested in useless expensive machinery (Bea Weblogic, Oracle...), and now use it on their patients, even though better treatments are already available.
If not, I wonder how medicine has solved the problem that the IT world can't seem to get a grip on.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Thursday August 28, 2008 @09:09PM
(#289672)
I don't see what IT consultants have to do with lawyers, or how you think the two relate. Just because people waste money on IT consultants does not mean hiring a lawyer is a waste.
Also, anyone can just call themselves an IT consultant. You have to go through schooling and pass a test to become a lawyer. The barrier to entry is a lot higher.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by rokhayakebe on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:57AM
(#288010)
The audience does not ask legal questions related to marriage or asset management or mortgage. Their questions are startup related and they know a few entrepreneurs have already been through a similar situation and it makes sense to ask, but one should always consult a lawyer before making their final decision.
If you go to parenting site they ask questions about the best schools and those who answer are not teachers. Visit teenagers sites and you will see a lot of questions from young girls who are very confused with their bodies and want medical advices, those who answer are not doctors.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by asif on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @08:28AM
(#287946)
Black and white statements such as this are almost always wrong. While I would never trust a non-lawyer's legal advice over a lawyer's legal advice, there could certainly exist a person in the world whom I trust more than any given lawyer, that also has an experience pertinent to my situation. You'd be foolish to bypass that person's opinion. Just take it with the knowledge that that person isn't a lawyer.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by raganwald on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:30AM
(#287988)
Fine, construct some hypothetical edge case "There *could exist..." and then try to apply some reduction ad absurdum to conclude that Matt's advice is wrong.
Only, Matt's advice is correct. You should not ask for legal advice on HN, even if it is possible that in one of the many parallel universes there exists an entity you trust more than a lawyer.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by asif on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:56AM
(#288009)
I concede that HN is not the place to solicit legal advice. The level of trust that I was referring to most likely does not exist between users of this site.
Nonetheless, I believe it is incorrect to state that one would be putting one's self in harms way by discussing legal matters with a non-lawyer, as the article implies.
Here's an example: My neighbor has a large tree bordering my yard, from which a branch is hanging over the fence and interfering with my shit. Is it legal for me to chop the branch? Maybe in some jurisdictions, but who knows? Should I call a lawyer right away? Let me see what my wife thinks.
Me: "Hey honey, what should I do about this branch? Should I call a lawyer?"
Honey: "A lawyer?!?!? For God's sake why would you do that? That's just Ethel's tree. Just cut the damn thing down."
-- or --
"Umm, Johnny Cochrane, Jr. lives there. Call five lawyers."
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by raganwald on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:38AM
(#288063)
I agree that you are not putting yourself in harm's way by discussing legal matters with non-lawyers, even HN non-lawyers.
I have often discussed legal matters with experienced businesspeople and investors. Of course, when the conversation turns to "Ok, what is the next action step?" the consensus is nearly always "Talk to a lawyer" :-)
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @06:00PM
(#288549)
You don't put yourself in harm's way as long as you realize that what you are giving or getting is not a substitute for legal advice. Unfortunately most people tend to forget that very easily, as humans are often misled by confident, and often confident that they know more than they do.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by jon_dahl on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:42AM
(#288126)
Personally, I think the article is half-right. "Let an attorney handle your legal questions" is absolutely correct - Random Guy on Internets should not be making legal decisions for you, and you should always have good legal representation if you're doing business of any sort (even as a freelance programmer).
But sometimes you aren't looking for specific legal advice - you're looking to educate yourself as an entrepreneur. I've learned quite a bit about contracts, business formation, tax law, etc. from my attorneys - but I've also learned a bit from other entrepreneurs.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by cosmo7 on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:41AM
(#287994)
> I can, without hesitation, proclaim that eating children is categorically wrong.
You are captain of a cruise liner full of children. The ship is boarded by pirates. These pirates are utterly evil and utterly truthful. They demand that either you eat one child, who happens to be about to die of a congenital heart defect, or they will blow up the ship and kill hundreds of children.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by khafra on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:36AM
(#288058)
Absolute veracity is generally acknowledged to be a virtue, conflicting with the "utterly evil" trait. Thus, the pirates disappear in a puff of logic. This once again proves that conjectural sophistry based on impossible examples is categorically un-compelling.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by jessewmc on Thursday August 28, 2008 @02:10PM
(#289357)
This is a different kind of wrong though... You're talking about morally wrong, while the parent is talking about factually wrong.
Also, though, in reference to the silly pirate example below, something being absolutely wrong does not prevent the possible necessity of doing that thing to prevent greater wrongs. Its still wrong, just possibly less wrong.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by asif on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:02AM
(#288014)
Ha. Thanks for pointing that out. Perhaps I instinctively avoid blanket generalizations so as to avoid the criticism that I am currently unleashing on this article.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by ntoshev on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:54AM
(#288140)
I don't know why the parent gets downmodded, he is right. What is considered morally right and wrong is culture specific, it is not absolute. For example, some cultures used to sacrifice children to their gods. We may consider this wrong, but they certainly didn't.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Eliezer on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:11AM
(#288030)
Name me a human culture that eats babies. Also you've committed the classic error of confusing "Culture X thinks Y isn't wrong" and "Y isn't wrong". Is it true in some societies that the Sun goes around the Earth?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by jauco on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:58AM
(#288083)
You're confusing ethically wrong (as in 'considered to be not nice') with scientifically wrong (as in 'considered to be not consistent with observations')
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by ars on Thursday August 28, 2008 @12:06AM
(#288828)
No, there are no absolutes.
Lets break it down. Is killing children always wrong?
In many countries it's legal (today) to kill children. In some cultures surplus children were left to die of exposure (Sparta for example).
And once the child is dead - well some cultures eat the dead as a form of burial.
There goes your absolute.
Just so you know: it's not possible to create a moral system from first principles. It always has to be imposed from outside. In most countries the bible serves as the starting point.
If you want, you can have one guy decide, and use his ideas. But you can never defend them as absolute and correct. Another person, just as logical, can come up with conflicting ideas, and you can never prove one is right and the other wrong.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by lehmannro on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:18AM
(#288039)
How come you think that?
I cannot see any biological advantage of not eating your children in emergency situations -- i.e. where you need to eat the child (survival, extortion, ...) and she won't survive anyways.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by lehmannro on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:36AM
(#288059)
Depending on your standards, you can justify absolutely anything. There is nothing that is inherently right or wrong -- perhaps something that is right or wrong in most views.
Our standards have changed, too -- not even a century ago, holocausts were considered absolutely appropriate (even by scientists!).
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by sant0sk1 on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:10AM
(#288096)
No. Despite your opinions, and your best efforts to redefine good and evil, there are things which are inherently wrong. Murder is one of those things. All humans know murder is wrong, whether they admit it or not.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by donw on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:58PM
(#288358)
Right, so the Samurai, who would randomly cut the heads off of people they didn't fancy, knew they were doing something wrong, and yet were totally okay with it? Beheading a few peasants was, after all, the right way to test out a new sword... there's even a term in Japanese for it: Tameshi-giri.
Plenty of societies, both ancient and modern, have legalized, or even encouraged, what we define as 'murder'.
And note that I'm not arguing that murder is acceptable; rather, that the definition for it changes so much between societies as to make the statement "Murder is wrong in all human societies." a completely meaningless phrase.
A likely explanation for the prohibition against the killing of other humans is strictly pragmatic: Societies where members can kill each other freely will self-destruct. This has nothing to do with 'murder being wrong', as much as free homicide not being a very stable evolutionary path.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by davidw on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:59AM
(#287890)
I don't think it's so bad to ask after other people's experiences and advice as long as you keep in mind that 1) free advice is worth what you paid for it 2) who they are and what their credentials are. Someone who's started 5 successful companies probably does have some insight into the legal part of it, even though he's not a lawyer.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by michael_dorfman on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @06:42AM
(#287897)
But part of the insight they are likely to have is that every case is different and that the differences matter, and that the legal judgments are best left to a lawyer.
Would you post a question here asking for medical advice?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by davidw on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @06:46AM
(#287899)
This site isn't remotely about doctors or health, so obviously not.
I don't believe every case is that different though, and there are some common threads, as can be seen in the recent advice-wanted article (LLC's are cheap and easy, definitely get a lawyer if there's more than one person). Would anyone here recommend that people use Cobol or Forth to make a web site with, unless the user has some really outlandish requirements?
In other words, advice here may be good for getting the 'gist' of how things are or ought to be. Clearly, when you want to get serious, at that point you should consult a lawyer. For example, I think pretty much anyone can tell you that forming a partnership instead of an LLC or corporation is likely to be a bad idea, or that people aiming for investments are likely better off with a C corporation. Of course, there are lots of underlying details that need to be looked after by a professional.
Furthermore, I like learning about this stuff, and it's not rocket science. Complex, in some cases, certainly, but this isn't a group of people that shys away from tough or complex things. The important thing is to keep in mind that we aren't experts in it, simply learners.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by michael_dorfman on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @07:07AM
(#287907)
I hear what you're saying, and I understand the desire to tackle complex and tough things-- but some things are best left to professionals, believe me.
I can think of a few times where a lack of proper legal advice cost me more than a million dollars.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by noonespecial on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:19AM
(#287883)
Excellent advice.
The law is not logical and the outcomes are not reasonable. This is a hard thing for the engineering mind to come to terms with given how much these seemingly random outcomes can affect peoples' lives.
The law is a system that's nearly completely hacked at this point. Think of it as a RedHat linux 5.0 system with wuftp enabled that's been running on the net since '97. Do you really think that ls is still ls?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by rrf on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @08:28AM
(#287947)
Whilst I agree with Matt's advice, I disagree that the law is not logical. It is fundamentally logical and shares many of the ideas found in logic: evidence, probability, relevance, reasonableness, precedent, presumption, proof, explanation, plausability, etc. That legal outcomes are not always considered reasonable may be due more to the fallibility of a judge, jury, expert or process. Further, drafting a legal document and programming are not that disimilar.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by raganwald on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:33AM
(#287990)
You know the expression "security theatre"? My cynical experience is that the part of the legal system that concerns evidence, probability, relevance, reasonableness, precedent, presumption, proof, explanation, plausability, etc is reason theatre.
Although the decision may not always go to the side with the deepest pockets and the most theatrically convincing lawyers, that's the way to bet.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by kylec on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:03PM
(#288298)
The only 100% way is to become your own lawyer. Barring that, the best thing to do is educate yourself and research the area in which you need legal advice. Once you can get a feel for the intricacies of the situation the less you'll have to blindly trust the advice of your lawyer.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by uuilly on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:26PM
(#288324)
This is very impractical advice. A good lawyer, like a good VC, is not out to "screw" you. They want to see your company get really big and give them steady M&A business for the next 30 years.
Only choosing a non-sharky Lawyer is much easier than a non-sharky VC. Go to some reputable law firms, tell them about your company, listen to them, and go with the one you like. If you haven't figured this out yet then it probably means that you have very little to be "screwed" out of anyways so you won't have to worry about them doing that.
Mentally masturbating over legal issues you'll never understand in a bootstrapped startup is just as impractical as not trusting landlords and insisting on building your own office.
If done right you will get a rough feel for legal issues as you go. And it will come from your lawyers.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by rob_rasmussen on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @07:47AM
(#287924)
Well said.
Jack Sheridan's talk at startup school (http://omnisio.com/startupschool08/jack-sheridan, a good talk that's not a sales pitch) was an eye-opener for me -- I've become much more disciplined about simply documenting agreements.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by yters on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @04:40PM
(#288456)
Heh, I like the first absolute rule. It's obviously in response to the ID/'evolution' debate, and consequently says absolutely nothing since neither side argues evolution (broadly defined as change of species over time) doesn't happen.
The only argument is about what mechanisms can be considered scientific explanations. If you don't believe me, read what the key ID thinkers actually say, instead of what the media says they say. The ID people explicitly make this point in Expelled.
So, even though Matt picks out this position to show his clear thinking skills in a controversial matter, it doesn't really pick out a controversial position. Matt's position on evolution is just empty rhetoric for those who don't know the debate. Alternatively, Matt doesn't get it either.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by dhimes on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:46AM
(#288004)
It's really experience that matters here.
Lawyers go through a lot of schooling to learn how to examine your situation and come up with the right answer
I guess that's relative. As far as graduate programs go, the law degree isn't really that long. They have probably haven't had many specialized courses; their expertise will come from experience.
Often, the work that's done in their office is done by someone without much training at all. You learn about business entities and how to form them in a sophomore undergraduate class.
But while the law can be hacked, it is rather complicated. Whether or not the person you asked had an understanding of precedents in your particular area would be a key factor in getting a quality response.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by linhir on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @12:00PM
(#288142)
This is a classic underestimation of the expertise afforded by non-PhD graduate programs. Three years is a fair length when compares to quite a few graduate programs. Expertise does come through experience, like in almost anything else, but I am hesitant to accept the ease with which you wipe away legal education's value.
Many of the comments here are underestimating the technical (although perhaps not technological) training a lawyer receives, at least a good one. If you look at the first year of law school, it is often about learning how to think like a lawyer. That, to respond to the comment below, is logical thinking, but within the legal system. Legal research, even the use of LexisNexis or Westlaw is an ability not easily mastered by the novice, no matter how brilliant their startup idea or programming acumen.
The truth is that almost everyone underestimates the difficulty of other's expertise. I could point to (hundreds of) thousands of blog posts about individuals who think it is easy to whip up a good website, program, etc and how stupid those people are. The parallel to that is programmers who think the law is easy.
Matt's key point, to address other comments, at least in my view, is not necessarily that you have to go to a lawyer when you have no money, but 1) when you have some money, go to a good lawyer and 2) know that you're ignorant. Know that you, your friends, the people you often talk to, likely have no idea what they are talking about where the law is concerned, and do not under any circumstance forget 1) because you did not realize 2).
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by dhimes on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:18PM
(#288318)
Ummm... The length of the JD, a doctorate, is 3 years; Ph.D.s tend to be 4 or 5 (or 6 or ...), and an MD, 4.
Short of someone who's done all three degrees, my estimate is probably pretty good. I had room-mates and friends in graduate school (Ph.D.) who were law students, and a friend of mine went on to get a JD after his Ph.D. My wife is an MD. You could say I have a bit of knowledge about this.
Perhaps you didn't mean to reply to my post, but rather to someone else's. I am not saying the law is easy, I'm saying that being a lawyer is not enough of a qualification for getting your hard questions answered. Experience matters.
Consider accounting: you can do the numbers yourself, but an experienced accountant can bring more to the table than just how to classify expenses.
(You could, of course, make the same arguments for the other degrees in various situations.)
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by donw on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:03PM
(#288364)
A newly-minted MD is just as useless as a newly minted JD, only more dangerous. Which is why MDs have to go through rotations and interning, because the medical system recognizes that a doctor with zero experience should not be dealing with patients without a few years' worth of supervision.
Law firms often work the same way, with junior lawyers spending a few years 'learning the ropes' before they get put in charge of anything truly important.
I think I'm supporting your post, but I'm not sure. :)
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by linhir on Thursday August 28, 2008 @12:09AM
(#288835)
"As far as graduate programs go, the law degree isn't really that long."
I did not interpret this to mean doctorates. When you said graduate programs, I took you mean, all post-undergraduate programs. Since there are many master's programs out there of the one to two year length (especially professional degrees that can confer "expertise") I took a three year law degree to be fairly long. I have no doubt that you have a lot of knowledge about this, and obviously the number of years you state for the length of degree programs is accurate (although I guess, even more on your side would be the argument that although an MD is four years, medical education is much longer), I just had a misunderstanding of the sample space we were talking about.
Obviously you're correct that three years is not that long when compared to six.
I did mean for some of my reply to be in response to your post, obviously, but by no means was everything I said a reply to your post, but rather the thread at large.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by gills on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @12:18PM
(#288164)
Your rule is a good one, mattmaroon. I agree with it.
Unfortunately, you've tripped on Paul Buchheit's rule. You are overgeneralizing from your own risk profile. There may be some real cowboys on HN who are optimizing for different values and may be willing to accept significantly more legal risk in their lives in the process of launching their businesses.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Locke on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @12:09PM
(#288152)
"...if you have a legal question, you should ask a lawyer, and only a lawyer" [emphasis mine]
Because lawyers are magic people who never make mistakes? Who are completely trustworthy? Because the act of simply discussing a legal matter with friends will somehow cause irreparable harm?
I'm leery whenever someone tells me what I can and can't discuss with whom.
Let's say I'm having car trouble. I'm not stupid, I know I'm going to have to take it to a mechanic. But, first I discuss the problem with some friends and family. I get a couple uninformed opinions on what it might be, what it might cost to fix, etc.
When I take the car into a mechanic am I worse off for getting a few uninformed opinions?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:53PM
(#288543)
All chest pains are not a matter of life and death. Some are, others are simply indigestion. The only way to find out with any degree of certainty if yours is would be to call a doctor.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Locke on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @02:04PM
(#288299)
It occurs to me that I've strayed from the point I wanted to make. I'm not arguing that advice from non-lawyers can or should be used as a replacement for a lawyer's advice. I'm arguing against the idea that advice from non-lawyers is worthless and should be avoided at all costs.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:52PM
(#288542)
The only reason I think it should be avoided at all costs is that it's near impossible to pick the good advice from the bad. If you knew enough to do that, you wouldn't be asking the question in the first place. How does getting a bunch of advice whose quality you have no way of judging help you at all? The best case scenario is that you ignore it and go get qualified advice, and the worst case is disaster.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Locke on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @11:11PM
(#288787)
How do you know what questions to ask your lawyer? How do you know what info might be pertinent to helping your lawyer to give sound advice?
Let's say I were to ask for advice about X. Someone posts, "Oh, when I went through X, my lawyer advised me to do Y and I think it really helped." So, then when I talk to a lawyer I can ask about Y. I don't see how opening a dialog hurt anything?
How does a little extra knowledge lead to disaster? Note: I'm not talking about forgoing a lawyer's advice in favor of listening to an internet nutjob.
You seem to be advocating ignorance and/or blind faith lawyers. How do you recognize a bad lawyer if you don't make any effort to educate yourself?
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Thursday August 28, 2008 @01:43AM
(#288897)
Ask your lawyer the question you posted here. They aren't machines, they don't simply answer the question you asked and then stop. They'll dig around and ask you for any pertinent info. You don't need people on Hacker News to help with that.
Weeding out bad lawyers is not something that posting here will help you with (unless maybe you ask for recommendations, which I would encourage). Every legal advice post here gets 100 differing opinions. If you assume any lawyer who tells you something other than what you heard here is a bad one, then all of them will be.
The best route might be to do what you do with a doctor or any other professional: get a few opinions. Do a few consultations. They're generally free, and at least will give you some idea.
The problem with "extra knowledge" is that you're getting some amount of information and some amount of misinformation, and you likely have no good way to choose between them.
I don't advocate blind faith in anyone, but legal advice from a lawyer is orders of magnitude more likely to be correct than legal advice from a non-lawyer.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by DanielBMarkham on Thursday August 28, 2008 @01:29PM
(#289312)
Somewhere there is a lawyer board where right now posters are asking "So If I wanted to form a startup for legal advice, is there some kind of web thingy I might need for that?"
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by maxklein on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @05:58AM
(#287889)
Sometimes one just needs to know in general how the law looks like, and cannot be bothered to ask a lawyer. For example, let's say you want to know if it's legal to sleep with a 17 year old girl. You ask your friend who has experience with such things. You don't go calling up a lawyer straight away.. it makes you look suspicious.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by imgabe on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @08:37AM
(#287950)
If you were going to ask shady questions and worried about looking suspicious, a lawyer would at least be professionally bound to keep your inquiries confidential, your friend isn't.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by mattmaroon on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @03:10PM
(#288372)
Calling a lawyer only makes you look suspicious to the lawyer you called, who is legally prevented from doing anything about it. Also, he's probably seen worse.
Let's say you ask your friend, he says it's ok (which he is absolutely certain is true) and you go ahead with the deed. I mean, she was totally hot, and looked like she was at least 20, so I understand. Then you find out the hard way that your friend was wrong. Now you're a registered sex offender (which I think is B.S., but that's beside the point). You spend the rest of your life paying dearly.
Even if you were to assume going in that your friend is most lilkely right, the small possibility that he is wrong multiplied by the truly disastrous outcome makes it well-worth having just spoken to a lawyer. I don't know about you, but I'd gladly drop a couple hundred to prevent even a 1% chance of becoming a registered sex offender.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by Eliezer on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @10:15AM
(#288035)
And your friend says "Sure" but he doesn't realize that the "age of consent" varies from state to state, because it seems to him like that logically ought to be a fixed number - in fact it's never occurred to him that it might vary - in fact he doesn't distinguish between federal and state law, just lives with "the law".
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by volida on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @08:56AM
(#287962)
youtube founders managed to exploit a law for their growth and they werent lawyers.
almost certainly they must have asked for professional opinion, but equally certainly if they weren't sufficiently aware of the legal knowledge required they probably wouldn't have exploit it.
Re:One Inviolable Rule
by icey on Wednesday August 27, 2008 @09:30AM
(#287986)
When I see arguments like this, I can't help but think that the thought process is akin to: "I don't get into car accidents, so I shouldn't have to wear a seat belt."
if you have a legal question, you should ask a lawyer, and only a lawyer
I agree, but what is a "legal question"? Only lawyers are qualified to answer that!
Many of those who pose legal questions to the web, rather than to a lawyer, do so because they don't recognize that their question crosses the boundary where they need a lawyer. It's not as if such edge cases are particularly rare, nor are they easy to resolve. Every post that I make to news.YC is a potential libel action; every quote that I cut and paste could be the subject of a copyright suit. (Just ask the folks who post about Scientology... and note that I just substantially increased my legal risk, and YCs, by using the word 'Scientology' in this context. Perhaps my lawyer would have suggested a different example...)
Everyone who writes software tiptoes around legal issues of patent and copyright. Should I consult lawyers every time I use Pastie?
Everyone who downloads a piece of software risks a lawsuit. Click a link that installs Firefox: legal. Click a link that installs a P2P client? Depends on what you do with it. What about HD-DVD ripping software? If I install it, am I committing a crime?
Yes, the ultimate arbiter of all of these issues should be a lawyer. I'm certainly not qualified. But we can't afford to pay lawyers every single day. In the end, we all have to develop our own sense of when we need professional legal advice and when we don't -- and the web is helpful for that, even though any individual anecdote (even the ones told by bona fide lawyers!) may be unreliable or inapplicable to your individual situation.
I don't think you need a lawyer to know what's a legal question. Should I incorporate and if so, what type of entity is obviously one. What should be in my terms and conditions? Etc.
Well, yes, once you've decided to ask that question it's obviously a question for a lawyer. But who should ask the question?
Should your personal blog be incorporated? Is that question worth asking a lawyer about? What if your personal blog is Boing Boing? What if you're Michael Arrington? What if you're Craig Newmark?
The point where you decide to seek investors is a pretty clear boundary: You need to talk to a lawyer. But if you're self-funding, and you're planning on releasing a free iPhone app for kicks, do you need a lawyer or not? I don't think it's all that obvious.
you simply can't
I see how much money is wasted on IT consultants, why should it be different with lawyers? Except with IT consultants I can tell when shit is happening, with lawyers I can't.
I am also not saying that lawyers in general screw you over. But it seems very hard to find a lawyer I could trust.
I didn't invent that heart-bypass example; it was a running scam exposed on 60 Minutes a few years ago.
I've been a client to maybe five or six independent civil lawyers over the years, and they all did pretty much nothing more or less than what I asked for going in.
I had a free consultation with a corporate criminal defense lawyer recently, not realizing she was a trial lawyer, so it would really only have been appropriate to meet with her had I been charged with something -- I was just looking for advice on how to avoid committing a corporate crime in a tricky situation. Not only did she listen to my story and not bill me for anything, she gave me the most cautious advice possible under the circumstances -- the advice least likely to cause me to need her paid services.
(I've been happy with the doctors I've had over the years as well, for that matter. I once saw a dentist who seemed both incompetent and fraudulent, but I didn't go back.)
Your bypass example: yes, as it happens I have repeatedly read that bypass operations are complete nonsene, and there is actually a business of doctors referring patients to each other. Of course if they tell you you are going to die in one minute, there is no time to research the internet about the suggested treatment, which I would normally do.
With medicine I would do so - but with law, we have just learned that searching the internet is no good, because only a real lawyer should be trusted?
I have also had encounters with nice lawyers, who gave me free advice over the phone. However, it also seems common that lawyers don't want to be upfront about the costs they will incur. Also, I am in Germany, things might the different here than in the states.
Especially in corporate law. If they do a good job at drafting your contracts and defending you in court against copyright infringement suits, you'll come back, and recommend your other business-people friends to that attorney's practice.
Of course, your attorney will want to disembowel the opposing side, but that's what you want.
If you're worried about an attorney, look at their track record; unlike a lot of other professions, you can get all of it from the courthouse in the district where they practice. If you don't know where to start looking for a lawyer, call your local bar association, and ask them for a referral.
Or, if you've got very little money, look at Pre-Paid Legal Services. Yes, yes, it started as an MLM company, which looks pretty scummy, but they actually do provide a very, very useful set of services, and the total cost is less than twenty bucks a month.
It just makes me sad to see lawyers catching all the flack for the problems in our judicial system, when it's our elected officials who created the whole nightmare in the first place.
I did not even mean to knock lawyers, maybe they all mean well, but they might be used to a different kind of level for their operation.
Not that I had so much experience with lawyers so far, but so far I found it hard to find good ones. I just happen to have no connections in lawyer circles.
On the plus side, if you really do get screwed, a lot of states have funds set up to compensate you. But if you pay for some legal work that might not have been completely necessary, you're on your own.
This would be particularly important in corporate law for small businesses, where the lawyers have ongoing relationships with clients (as opposed to, say, personal injury law, where some guy hit by a truck picks an attorney out of the Yellow Pages and may never deal with the lawyer after that case is resolved).
Of course, I'm making suppositions based on my knowledge of economics. Maybe I should consult an economist.
Of course just like doctors, it cannot hurt to get second opinion, because lawyers are of course not all ethical or infallible.
I must admit that it often freaks me out to consider that other professions are just as messed up as the software world. For example, in medicine there is in all likelihood an equivalent to LISP and an equivalent to Java. Many hospitals might have invested in useless expensive machinery (Bea Weblogic, Oracle...), and now use it on their patients, even though better treatments are already available.
If not, I wonder how medicine has solved the problem that the IT world can't seem to get a grip on.
Also, anyone can just call themselves an IT consultant. You have to go through schooling and pass a test to become a lawyer. The barrier to entry is a lot higher.
If you go to parenting site they ask questions about the best schools and those who answer are not teachers. Visit teenagers sites and you will see a lot of questions from young girls who are very confused with their bodies and want medical advices, those who answer are not doctors.
Only, Matt's advice is correct. You should not ask for legal advice on HN, even if it is possible that in one of the many parallel universes there exists an entity you trust more than a lawyer.
Nonetheless, I believe it is incorrect to state that one would be putting one's self in harms way by discussing legal matters with a non-lawyer, as the article implies.
Here's an example: My neighbor has a large tree bordering my yard, from which a branch is hanging over the fence and interfering with my shit. Is it legal for me to chop the branch? Maybe in some jurisdictions, but who knows? Should I call a lawyer right away? Let me see what my wife thinks.
Me: "Hey honey, what should I do about this branch? Should I call a lawyer?"
Honey: "A lawyer?!?!? For God's sake why would you do that? That's just Ethel's tree. Just cut the damn thing down."
-- or --
"Umm, Johnny Cochrane, Jr. lives there. Call five lawyers."
I have often discussed legal matters with experienced businesspeople and investors. Of course, when the conversation turns to "Ok, what is the next action step?" the consensus is nearly always "Talk to a lawyer" :-)
(Sorry, it was there, I had to...)
When you consider the legal questions that are asked, his advice seems very sound.
But sometimes you aren't looking for specific legal advice - you're looking to educate yourself as an entrepreneur. I've learned quite a bit about contracts, business formation, tax law, etc. from my attorneys - but I've also learned a bit from other entrepreneurs.
Good thing you included the word "almost"... :~)
You are captain of a cruise liner full of children. The ship is boarded by pirates. These pirates are utterly evil and utterly truthful. They demand that either you eat one child, who happens to be about to die of a congenital heart defect, or they will blow up the ship and kill hundreds of children.
What do you do?
I can, without hesitation, not delaying for one second, not second guessing myself whatsoever, with certainty as broad as the universe itself...
Also, though, in reference to the silly pirate example below, something being absolutely wrong does not prevent the possible necessity of doing that thing to prevent greater wrongs. Its still wrong, just possibly less wrong.
So I would agree that eating children is wrong.
Eating a child is wrong regardless of how one would justify it.
Lets break it down. Is killing children always wrong?
In many countries it's legal (today) to kill children. In some cultures surplus children were left to die of exposure (Sparta for example).
And once the child is dead - well some cultures eat the dead as a form of burial.
There goes your absolute.
Just so you know: it's not possible to create a moral system from first principles. It always has to be imposed from outside. In most countries the bible serves as the starting point.
If you want, you can have one guy decide, and use his ideas. But you can never defend them as absolute and correct. Another person, just as logical, can come up with conflicting ideas, and you can never prove one is right and the other wrong.
I cannot see any biological advantage of not eating your children in emergency situations -- i.e. where you need to eat the child (survival, extortion, ...) and she won't survive anyways.
Our standards have changed, too -- not even a century ago, holocausts were considered absolutely appropriate (even by scientists!).
Plenty of societies, both ancient and modern, have legalized, or even encouraged, what we define as 'murder'.
And note that I'm not arguing that murder is acceptable; rather, that the definition for it changes so much between societies as to make the statement "Murder is wrong in all human societies." a completely meaningless phrase.
A likely explanation for the prohibition against the killing of other humans is strictly pragmatic: Societies where members can kill each other freely will self-destruct. This has nothing to do with 'murder being wrong', as much as free homicide not being a very stable evolutionary path.
Would you post a question here asking for medical advice?
I don't believe every case is that different though, and there are some common threads, as can be seen in the recent advice-wanted article (LLC's are cheap and easy, definitely get a lawyer if there's more than one person). Would anyone here recommend that people use Cobol or Forth to make a web site with, unless the user has some really outlandish requirements?
In other words, advice here may be good for getting the 'gist' of how things are or ought to be. Clearly, when you want to get serious, at that point you should consult a lawyer. For example, I think pretty much anyone can tell you that forming a partnership instead of an LLC or corporation is likely to be a bad idea, or that people aiming for investments are likely better off with a C corporation. Of course, there are lots of underlying details that need to be looked after by a professional.
Furthermore, I like learning about this stuff, and it's not rocket science. Complex, in some cases, certainly, but this isn't a group of people that shys away from tough or complex things. The important thing is to keep in mind that we aren't experts in it, simply learners.
I can think of a few times where a lack of proper legal advice cost me more than a million dollars.
Once burned, twice shy.
People commonly discuss everything from depression to motivational issues.
The law is not logical and the outcomes are not reasonable. This is a hard thing for the engineering mind to come to terms with given how much these seemingly random outcomes can affect peoples' lives.
The law is a system that's nearly completely hacked at this point. Think of it as a RedHat linux 5.0 system with wuftp enabled that's been running on the net since '97. Do you really think that ls is still ls?
Although the decision may not always go to the side with the deepest pockets and the most theatrically convincing lawyers, that's the way to bet.
When you execute a legal document twice, the same results both times would be fall-out-of-your-chair unexpected.
Even simple, clear-cut legal documents like wills are at best, probability functions.
Only choosing a non-sharky Lawyer is much easier than a non-sharky VC. Go to some reputable law firms, tell them about your company, listen to them, and go with the one you like. If you haven't figured this out yet then it probably means that you have very little to be "screwed" out of anyways so you won't have to worry about them doing that.
Mentally masturbating over legal issues you'll never understand in a bootstrapped startup is just as impractical as not trusting landlords and insisting on building your own office.
If done right you will get a rough feel for legal issues as you go. And it will come from your lawyers.
Jack Sheridan's talk at startup school (http://omnisio.com/startupschool08/jack-sheridan, a good talk that's not a sales pitch) was an eye-opener for me -- I've become much more disciplined about simply documenting agreements.
The only argument is about what mechanisms can be considered scientific explanations. If you don't believe me, read what the key ID thinkers actually say, instead of what the media says they say. The ID people explicitly make this point in Expelled.
So, even though Matt picks out this position to show his clear thinking skills in a controversial matter, it doesn't really pick out a controversial position. Matt's position on evolution is just empty rhetoric for those who don't know the debate. Alternatively, Matt doesn't get it either.
Lawyers go through a lot of schooling to learn how to examine your situation and come up with the right answer
I guess that's relative. As far as graduate programs go, the law degree isn't really that long. They have probably haven't had many specialized courses; their expertise will come from experience.
Often, the work that's done in their office is done by someone without much training at all. You learn about business entities and how to form them in a sophomore undergraduate class.
But while the law can be hacked, it is rather complicated. Whether or not the person you asked had an understanding of precedents in your particular area would be a key factor in getting a quality response.
Many of the comments here are underestimating the technical (although perhaps not technological) training a lawyer receives, at least a good one. If you look at the first year of law school, it is often about learning how to think like a lawyer. That, to respond to the comment below, is logical thinking, but within the legal system. Legal research, even the use of LexisNexis or Westlaw is an ability not easily mastered by the novice, no matter how brilliant their startup idea or programming acumen.
The truth is that almost everyone underestimates the difficulty of other's expertise. I could point to (hundreds of) thousands of blog posts about individuals who think it is easy to whip up a good website, program, etc and how stupid those people are. The parallel to that is programmers who think the law is easy.
Matt's key point, to address other comments, at least in my view, is not necessarily that you have to go to a lawyer when you have no money, but 1) when you have some money, go to a good lawyer and 2) know that you're ignorant. Know that you, your friends, the people you often talk to, likely have no idea what they are talking about where the law is concerned, and do not under any circumstance forget 1) because you did not realize 2).
Short of someone who's done all three degrees, my estimate is probably pretty good. I had room-mates and friends in graduate school (Ph.D.) who were law students, and a friend of mine went on to get a JD after his Ph.D. My wife is an MD. You could say I have a bit of knowledge about this.
Perhaps you didn't mean to reply to my post, but rather to someone else's. I am not saying the law is easy, I'm saying that being a lawyer is not enough of a qualification for getting your hard questions answered. Experience matters.
Consider accounting: you can do the numbers yourself, but an experienced accountant can bring more to the table than just how to classify expenses.
(You could, of course, make the same arguments for the other degrees in various situations.)
Law firms often work the same way, with junior lawyers spending a few years 'learning the ropes' before they get put in charge of anything truly important.
I think I'm supporting your post, but I'm not sure. :)
I did not interpret this to mean doctorates. When you said graduate programs, I took you mean, all post-undergraduate programs. Since there are many master's programs out there of the one to two year length (especially professional degrees that can confer "expertise") I took a three year law degree to be fairly long. I have no doubt that you have a lot of knowledge about this, and obviously the number of years you state for the length of degree programs is accurate (although I guess, even more on your side would be the argument that although an MD is four years, medical education is much longer), I just had a misunderstanding of the sample space we were talking about.
Obviously you're correct that three years is not that long when compared to six.
I did mean for some of my reply to be in response to your post, obviously, but by no means was everything I said a reply to your post, but rather the thread at large.
My guess for the one inviolable rule was, "Have enough cash to pay your bills each month or die."
Could there possibly be two inviolable rules?
Unfortunately, you've tripped on Paul Buchheit's rule. You are overgeneralizing from your own risk profile. There may be some real cowboys on HN who are optimizing for different values and may be willing to accept significantly more legal risk in their lives in the process of launching their businesses.
(I'm not one of them.)
Because lawyers are magic people who never make mistakes? Who are completely trustworthy? Because the act of simply discussing a legal matter with friends will somehow cause irreparable harm?
I'm leery whenever someone tells me what I can and can't discuss with whom.
Let's say I'm having car trouble. I'm not stupid, I know I'm going to have to take it to a mechanic. But, first I discuss the problem with some friends and family. I get a couple uninformed opinions on what it might be, what it might cost to fix, etc.
When I take the car into a mechanic am I worse off for getting a few uninformed opinions?
It's more akin to feeling a sharp pain in your chest and asking a friend rather than a doctor.
There's no variability? There are no minor legal issues? I should consult a lawyer about, say, a parking ticket?
Let's say I were to ask for advice about X. Someone posts, "Oh, when I went through X, my lawyer advised me to do Y and I think it really helped." So, then when I talk to a lawyer I can ask about Y. I don't see how opening a dialog hurt anything?
How does a little extra knowledge lead to disaster? Note: I'm not talking about forgoing a lawyer's advice in favor of listening to an internet nutjob.
You seem to be advocating ignorance and/or blind faith lawyers. How do you recognize a bad lawyer if you don't make any effort to educate yourself?
Weeding out bad lawyers is not something that posting here will help you with (unless maybe you ask for recommendations, which I would encourage). Every legal advice post here gets 100 differing opinions. If you assume any lawyer who tells you something other than what you heard here is a bad one, then all of them will be.
The best route might be to do what you do with a doctor or any other professional: get a few opinions. Do a few consultations. They're generally free, and at least will give you some idea.
The problem with "extra knowledge" is that you're getting some amount of information and some amount of misinformation, and you likely have no good way to choose between them.
I don't advocate blind faith in anyone, but legal advice from a lawyer is orders of magnitude more likely to be correct than legal advice from a non-lawyer.
Let's say you ask your friend, he says it's ok (which he is absolutely certain is true) and you go ahead with the deed. I mean, she was totally hot, and looked like she was at least 20, so I understand. Then you find out the hard way that your friend was wrong. Now you're a registered sex offender (which I think is B.S., but that's beside the point). You spend the rest of your life paying dearly.
Even if you were to assume going in that your friend is most lilkely right, the small possibility that he is wrong multiplied by the truly disastrous outcome makes it well-worth having just spoken to a lawyer. I don't know about you, but I'd gladly drop a couple hundred to prevent even a 1% chance of becoming a registered sex offender.
almost certainly they must have asked for professional opinion, but equally certainly if they weren't sufficiently aware of the legal knowledge required they probably wouldn't have exploit it.
(I hate to post something that is essentially "+1", but in this case I think it really needs to be said.)