News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terraform vs. AWS CloudFormation by viraptor on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @10:54PM (#28781285)
> hanging (often), times out, rollback hanging not succesful

The timeouts in CF are ridiculous. Especially with app deployments. I can't remember which service it is, but something can wait up to 30min on a failed `apply` and then wait the same on a failed revert. Only then you can actually deploy the next version (as long as it wasn't part of the first deploy, then you get to wait until everything gets deleted as well).

(yes, in many cases you can override the timeouts, but let's be honest - who remembers them all on the first run or ever?)

Re:Terraform vs. AWS CloudFormation by holler on Thursday October 07, 2021 @01:41AM (#28782531)
I've been using CF for a few years now with minimal complaints but I just hit a create changeset endless timeout (2 days to finally time out).

The worst part is that there are no error messages. When it fails and I click "Details", it takes me to the stack page and shows 100% green. Support ticket seems slow to get a response too.

That aside, my overall experience has been positive!

Re:Terraform vs. AWS CloudFormation by theteapot on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:07PM (#28781376)
I regularly see 20m timeouts using Terraform on AWS. Well in the TF camp, but just saying.
Re:Terraform vs. AWS CloudFormation by viraptor on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @11:13PM (#28781417)
These are AWS service timeouts and they definitely exist too. But with CF you get CF retries/timeouts on top of those.