something you know with something you have.
I'd say this covers the 99% of how credentials are being misappropriated.
We debunk this often several times per week on HN
Yes, AWS doesn't allow you to enroll more than one FIDO authenticator. No, AWS isn't "most" services, in the same way that Jeff Bezos isn't "most" people. When you mean "AWS" just say "AWS" not "Most services".
I have multiple Security Keys enrolled with, among others, Dropbox, Facebook, Google, and GitHub.
(Aside: I have a story for another time about how I soft-bricked my first while finally getting around to setting up a second; that I've not yet quite recovered enough to properly tell...)
1. They get repeated.
2. They get phished.
Even just as a single factor, even without a fingerprint reader, a yubikey is far superior to a password. Adding a biometric on top of that is wayyyy better than a password.
Most of what MFA has done for us is actually just provide slightly better "A's". It's not the quantity that counts, it's the quality.
Previously to reach a good quality we'd need multiple factors. We've reached a point now where we have standards for authentication that are strong, often "strong enough", even with a single factor. A password then becomes a bit of a bonus.
I meet a lot of people who bought yubikey nanos and leave them plugged in all the time. Defeats the purpose. There should be a kiosk where you can exchange people’s unattended yubikeys for a cookie or some other treat. That would take care of that problem.