News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by bowmessage on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:36PM (#28765932)
This is an "improvement" in the same way that abolishing police reduces the arrest rate.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by elviejo on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#28766001)
It really, is* an improvement the same way that netflix, when rented dvds, didn't allow you to take any other dvd until you returned the one you already had.

That strategy was enough to bankrupt blockbuster.

So it can work for NY public libraries.

Maybe if blockbuster had been willing to forgo the late fees income stream they would still exist today.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by SilasX on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#28766241)
Wait, what? Blockbuster did end late fees, and it was widely regarded as a disaster, because then people took their sweet time returning rentals (above and beyond the lost revenue):

https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna39332696

>Blockbuster tried dropping its late fees a few years ago, but that didn't work out well because it kept the most popular DVDs out of its stores for long stretches.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by RussianCow on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:04PM (#28766269)
I don't know this for a fact, but I'd wager a guess that interest in rental movies is mostly concentrated around a handful of titles at any given moment, whereas interest in library books is more evenly dispersed. This means that two people are much less likely to want to rent the same book at the same time, as opposed to the same movie.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by duskwuff on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @08:21PM (#28767560)
Libraries do sometimes get a lot of interest in hotly anticipated new titles sometimes. You're generally right that there is a lot more "long-tail" activity than in a video rental store, though -- and it's much easier for a library to maintain a collection of rarely used books.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by treeman79 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:04PM (#28766274)
Remember as a teen renting and returning two movies from Hollywood Videos. Me and a friend walked to Dropbox late at night so we were positive they were returned.

Got a 245 dollar demand letter a few letter a couple months later. For 2 unreturned movies.

Got a lawyer dads friend help me write a letter and the matter was dropped. Went from multiple rentals a week to never renting another video again.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by _hilro on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:40AM (#28773040)
> It really, is* an improvement the same way that netflix, when rented dvds, didn't allow you to take any other dvd until you returned the one you already had.

Everything doesn;t have to have a simplistic analogy especially when the analogy isn't applicable.

It's not really.

There is direct financial buy-in from the user. Netflix subscription wasn't 0 cost to user service.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by emacsen on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:44PM (#28766043)
This isn't an apt comparison.

Late fees are a designed to de-incentivize a certain behavior. We have little data on how effective it is, but we know it has costs both for implementation and its effects on patrons.

Let's take another example- charging people to use public transportation. We could do away with that as well, and some places have done that- finding that the cost of collection came close to overshadowing the income it generated.

Late fees are not part of the structure of a library except when they're implemented as such.

NYC will now have the opportunity to see if eliminating the late fees will have an impact on patron behavior or overall cost of running the library.

NYC's position is that late fees disincentivize the most vulnerable from using the library. If that's true and eliminating the fees would increase usage and not generally harm the income stream, then NYC- the largest municipal library system in the US, will have been an incredible test case.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by lalaland1125 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:41PM (#28765996)
But libraries do see more books being returned with these systems.

Telling someone that they will be automatically able to check out new books if they return the ones they have is really effective in practice. As opposed to the old system where you have to both return the book and pay money so lots of poor people would just ignore the library.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by hnaccount141 on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:54PM (#28766170)
When Chicago did the same, they saw an increase in the rate of returns.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/news/2019/10/30/20940677/chicag...

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by gremloni on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @06:02PM (#28766245)
The underlying metric (books returned) is massively improve though.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by glitchc on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:42PM (#28766010)
Deterrence often works until it doesn't, ergo deterrence never works.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by macinjosh on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:46PM (#28766074)
There is opportunity cost when someone leaves a library book under their bed and no one else can use it. Eventually the library must replace the book. In my experience the fees cap at the value of the book. I see it more as an attempt to recoup costs incurred. If it was for deterrence the fees would need to be exorbitant.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by glitchc on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:51PM (#28766129)
The cost to society at large for lost books is trivial, whereas the advantage of having these books distributed among low-income households is priceless. The New York Public Library has figured this out.

That's the whole point isn't it? That punishment doesn't work. Rich people can afford to shrug off the fine while the poor never return to the library again.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by jimmyvalmer on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @08:10PM (#28767454)
> having these books distributed among low-income households is priceless

That might have been true twenty years ago. With hook-or-by-crook internet access, the only reading poor kids are doing are their group chats.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by philistine on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @09:13PM (#28767928)
The joy of young kids reading books is alive and well, you grinch.
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by _hilro on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:44PM (#28766031)
> Deterrence often works until it doesn't, ergo deterrence never works.

Words don't become true just because you thought of them.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by kyleee on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:55PM (#28766185)
Nor just because one says them. Two things everyone should keep in mind
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by glitchc on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:47PM (#28766083)
At least I can think of something to say...
Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by _hilro on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @09:44AM (#28773086)
> At least I can think of something to say...

"The flow of quizzes stands upon somebody else's legs."

It's not hard to think of something to say.

The difference is my sentence was knowingly ridiculous and nonsensical.

Words that don't contribute to a discussion are just noise. The equivalent of someone banging pots and pans in the middle of a conversation because they want to get noticed.

edit: Brilliantly, you wrote a comment 6 days ago that opened with: "Critical thinking is at an all-time low in Western society."...the irony is palpable.

Re:New York Public Library ends all late fees by glitchc on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @12:10PM (#28774808)
It's common for the less erudite to confuse pithy for lack of intelligence. When I had time, I wrote a more complete response to a more neutral comment (see below). Many of us have lives outside Hacker News.

My point, as it still stands, is that punishment is meant to deter, and deterrence doesn't reduce criminal activity, history has proven that time and time again. Case in point: The Taliban is back to cutting hands for stealing, a terrifyingly high punishment for a basic crime that gets community service on average across North America (first offense). By your logic, theft should be eliminated altogether in Afghanistan. Is it? Is the per capita rate of theft higher or lower than North America? I leave it to you as an exercise to uncover, with a minor hint: it's higher.